Buyers Guides - Bikerumor https://bikerumor.com/buyers-guides/ All the best cycling news, tech, rumors and reviews Wed, 07 Feb 2024 21:22:28 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.4.3 https://bikerumor.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/bikerumor-favicon-144-1-120x120.png Buyers Guides - Bikerumor https://bikerumor.com/buyers-guides/ 32 32 190730048 The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024 https://bikerumor.com/best-bike-chain-lube/ Wed, 07 Feb 2024 21:13:55 +0000 https://bikerumor.com/?p=349836 A quality chain lubricant is vital for the performance and lifespan of the entire drivetrain. As the chain runs across your cassette, chainrings, and rear…

The post The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
Chain lube lead image

A quality chain lubricant is vital for the performance and lifespan of the entire drivetrain. As the chain runs across your cassette, chainrings, and rear derailleur pulleys, any contamination or lack of lubrication will gradually wear down the precisely machined teeth of these components, leading to noise, a reduction of efficiency, sloppy shifting, and eventually, a hefty replacement cost.

Think of the chain as the heart of your bike’s drivetrain. If it’s gunked up with contaminants, it’s not able to function efficiently, and performance suffers. Not only will you waste power overcoming more friction in your chain, but that friction will accelerate wear on all of your drivetrain components, which can combine to cost many hundreds of dollars to replace. By making a small investment in a quality chain lube, big gains in not only performance but bank account balances can be achieved.

There are a dizzying number of chain lubes on the market, with wet lubes, dry lubes, and wax-based drip-on coatings all claiming to be the best. All these options can make it hard to figure out which is the best lube for your bike, riding style, and the conditions you encounter out on the road or trail. Additionally, there are very strong and widely varying opinions on what lubes are the best. Based on our experience, popularity, and independent test lab results, we gathered 14 of the best chain lubes on the market to test and compare.

Our top chain lube recommendations are listed below, followed by the best of the rest which we feel are all worthy of consideration as well. To see all the chain lubes we tested at a glance, check out our comparison chart. If you’re unsure of what you need, our buying advice includes helpful information to guide your purchase decision, and we’ve got answers to common questions in our FAQ section.

The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024


Best Overall Drip Wax Chain Lube

Effetto Mariposa Flowerpower Wax

Specs

  • MSRP $21.00 (100ml), $68.00 (500ml)
  • Volume 100ml (4.06 oz), 500ml (16.9 oz)
  • Price Per Ounce $5.17 (100ml size)
  • Type Wax
  • Composition Sunflower Seed Wax, NO hazardous additives
  • Recommended use All conditions
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Highly efficient
  • Over 50% wax content
  • Long-lasting
  • Biodegradable

Cons

  • Requires perfectly clean chain
Best Value Drip Wax Chain Lube

Squirt Long Lasting Chain Lube

Specs

  • MSRP $15
  • Volume 4 oz (120ml), also comes in 15ml and 500ml
  • Price Per Ounce $3.75
  • Type Wax
  • Composition 100% biodegradable waxes with water
  • Recommended use All Conditions
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Runs quiet
  • Inexpensive
  • Extends drivetrain service life

Cons

  • Can separate if it freezes
Runner-Up Best Drip Wax Chain Lube

CeramicSpeed UFO Drip All Conditions

Specs

  • MSRP $24.00
  • Volume 100ml (3.38 oz)
  • Price Per Ounce $7.10
  • Type Wax
  • Composition Non-toxic and biodegradable wax-based formula
  • Recommended Use All Conditions
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Runs quiet
  • Hangs tough in wet conditions
  • Long-lasting

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Extensive chain prep required
Best Money-No-Object Drip Wax Chain Lube

absoluteBLACK GraphenLube

Specs

  • MSRP $19.95 (0.47 oz) to $145.95 (4.7 oz)
  • Volume 0.47 oz (14ml) / 4.7 oz (140ml)
  • Price Per Ounce $42.45 (0.47 oz size)
  • Type Wax
  • Composition Hydrocarbon (wax) based water emulsion containing a special mix of high purity Graphene.
  • Recommended use All conditions
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Runs super quiet
  • Saves watts
  • Protects drivetrain
  • Lasts a long time

Cons

  • VERY expensive
Best Wet Chain Lube

Silca Synergetic Wet Lube

Specs

  • MSRP $25 (2oz)
  • Volume 2 oz
  • Price Per Ounce $12.50
  • Type Oil
  • Composition ZDDP Oil with nano-particles of Tungsten Di-Sulfide
  • Recommended use All conditions
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Tribofilm protects from wear
  • Easy to apply
  • Precise applicator reduces waste

Cons

  • Quite expensive
  • Prone to settling – needs vigorous shaking
Best Value Wet Chain Lube

WD-40 Specialist Bike Wet Chain Lube

Specs

  • MSRP $10
  • Volume 4 oz
  • Price Per Ounce $2.50
  • Type Oil
  • Composition Proprietary oil-based formula
  • Recommended Use Wet Weather
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Reasonable price
  • Works well in wet, muddy conditions
  • Easy to apply

Cons

  • Not great for dry conditions
  • Needs frequent cleaning and reapplications – like most wet lubes
Easiest Chain Lube to Use

Wolf Tooth WT-1 Chain Lube

Specs

  • MSRP $18.95 (2oz) $6.95 (0.5 oz)
  • Volume 2 oz, also comes in 0.5 oz
  • Price Per Ounce $9.48
  • Type Oil
  • Composition Solvent refined light naphthenic oil
  • Recommended use All conditions
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Pushes out contaminants as you ride
  • Affordable
  • Zero chain prep is required

Cons

  • Fairly expensive

Best of the Rest

Pedro’s Slick Wax

Specs

  • MSRP $12.50
  • Volume 4 oz (120ml)
  • Price Per Ounce $3.13
  • Type Wax
  • Composition Wax, plant-based and biodegradable chemistry, No Parrafins or PTFE
  • Recommended use Dry weather
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Runs quiet
  • Stays clean
  • Biodegradable

Cons

  • Needs extensive chain cleaning for 1st application
  • Needs time to cure

Silca Super Secret Chain Lube

Specs

  • MSRP $45 (8oz) $25 (4 oz) $16 (2 oz)
  • Volume 8, 4, or 2 oz.
  • Price Per Ounce 8oz: $5.63, 4oz: $6.25, 2oz: $8
  • Type Wax
  • Composition Tungsten Disulphide, biodegradable waxes, with alcohol
  • Recommended use All conditions
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Quickly penetrates
  • Runs quiet
  • Extends drivetrain service life

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Requires a new chain to be stripped clean

Motorex Chainlube with PTFE

Specs

  • MSRP $12.85 (100ml)
  • Volume 100ml (3.38 oz)
  • Price Per Ounce $3.80
  • Type Oil
  • Composition Oil-based, fully synthetic with PTFE
  • Recommended use Dry weather
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Repels dirt and dust
  • Hangs tough on wet rides

Cons

  • PTFE is non-biodegradable
  • Requires frequent reapplication

Rock N’ Roll Gold

Specs

  • MSRP $8
  • Volume 4 oz, also comes in 16 oz
  • Price Per Ounce $2.00
  • Type Oil
  • Composition Oil-based
  • Recommended use All Conditions
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Repels dirt and dust
  • Hangs tough on wet rides

Cons

  • Needs time to cure

Rock N’ Roll Holy Cow

Specs

  • MSRP $8.00
  • Volume 4 oz
  • Price Per Ounce $2.00
  • Type Wet lube
  • Composition No information available
  • Recommended use All conditions
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Stays fairly clean
  • Affordable
  • Cleans and lubes in one

Cons

  • Requires more frequent application than some

Maxima Chain Wax Parafilm Lube

Specs

  • MSRP $11
  • Volume 4 oz
  • Price Per Ounce $2.75
  • Type Wax
  • Composition Proprietary Parafilm Formula
  • Recommended use All conditions
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Runs quiet
  • Inexpensive
  • Easy-to-use applicator

Cons

  • Strong scent

Muc-Off Dry Weather Lube

Specs

  • MSRP $12.00
  • Volume 120ml (4.06 oz), also comes in 50ml
  • Price Per Ounce $3.00
  • Type Wax
  • Composition Wax-based
  • Recommended use Dry weather
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Precise application
  • Stays clean

Cons

  • Needs frequent reapplication

Muc-Off C3 Ceramic Wet Weather Lube

Specs

  • MSRP $17.00 (120ml)
  • Volume 120ml (4.06 oz), also comes in 50ml (1.7 oz)
  • Price Per Ounce $4.19
  • Type Oil
  • Composition Oil-based with fluoro polymers and boron nitrides
  • Recommended use Wet weather
The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024

Pros

  • Reatively affordable
  • Precise application
  • Hangs tough in horrid conditions

Cons

  • Needs frequent reapplication
  • Gets dirty – chain needs to be wiped down regularly

Comparison Chart

Chain LubeMSRPVolumePrice per OunceTypeRecommended Use
Effetto Mariposa Flowerpower Wax$21100ml (3.38 oz)$5.17WaxAll Conditions
Squirt Long Lasting Chain Lube$154 oz$3.75WaxAll Conditions
Ceramic Speed UFO Drip All Conditions$24100ml (3.38 oz)$7.10WaxAll Conditions
absoluteBLACK Graphenlube$19.950.47 oz$42.45 (0.47 oz. size)WaxAll Conditions
Silca Synergetic Wet Lube$252 oz$12.50Oil-basedAll Conditions
WD-40 Specialist Bike Wet Lube$104 oz$2.50Oil-basedWet Weather
Wolf Tooth WT-1 Chain Lube$18.952 oz$9.48Oil-basedAll Conditions
Pedro’s Slick Wax$12.504 oz$3.13WaxDry weather
Silca Super Secret Chain Lube$45 – $168, 4, or 2 oz$5.63 to $8 (varies by size)WaxAll Conditions
Motorex Chainlube with PTFE$12.85100ml (3.38 oz)$3.80Oil-basedDry Weather
Rock N’ Roll Gold$84 oz$2.00Oil-basedAll Conditions
Rock N’ Roll Holy Cow$84 oz$2.00WetAll conditions
Maxima Chain Wax Parafilm$114 oz$2.75WaxAll Conditions
Muc-Off Dry Weather Lube$124.06 oz$3.00Wax-basedDry Weather
Muc-Off C3 Ceramic Wet Weather Lube$174.06 oz$4.19Oil-basedWet Weather

Why You Should Trust Us

At Bikerumor, we ride all kinds of bikes, a lot, and we know there are few things more annoying than a squeaky chain or wearing out expensive drivetrain components prematurely. Of course, taking good care of and maintaining our drivetrains helps, but we’ve also learned that choosing the right chain lube can do wonders to keep things running smoothly, and quietly, and reduce the friction that causes our chains, chainrings, cassettes, and derailleur pulleys to ultimately wear out. We’re also in the business of reporting on and testing new products and technologies, and we strive to provide our readers with trustworthy and honest opinions of the products we review.

For our chain lube buyer’s guide, we tasked Bennett Shane with testing the vast majority of the 14 different products in this review and added a couple that are highly regarded by other members of our team. Bennett is an avid road cyclist who spends an inordinate amount of time riding for fun, fitness, and product testing purposes. He lives outside of Portland, Oregon where he encounters the full spectrum of riding conditions throughout the year. He has a small fleet of high-end road bikes and prefers it when they run quietly, smoothly, and efficiently while protecting his expensive drivetrain componentry from premature wear. Bennett has been testing a huge range of product categories over the past year, including road bike tires, cycling bib tights, winter cycling gloves, road bike helmets, and more. His years of riding experience combined with his testing experience have given him an excellent ability to tease out the often subtle differences between the products he tests, which is of particular importance for something like chain lube.

It’s important to note that we did not perform scientific friction or wear testing on the lubricants in this buyer’s guide. Since this type of analysis is quite difficult to perform and requires highly specialized equipment, we’ll leave that to the experts who already do that type of lab testing. Zero Friction Cycling (ZFC) is one such resource that does independent laboratory testing of chain lubricants and publishes in-depth findings online. Much like Virgina tech’s independent helmet impact testing, we use ZFC’s findings to inform ourselves and help choose the products we tested. Our testing focuses more on using these products in the real world while examining factors like ease of application, drivetrain noise, contamination, cleanliness, and longevity when used in various weather conditions. To do that we gathered a diverse selection of 14 of the best chain lubes on the market to test and compare. Bennett Shane personally tested the vast majority of the chain lubes included here, and we added a few options that are favorites of our bike-obsessed editors, with the goal of highlighting the best options for every budget and riding condition.

Bennett Shane testing the best chain lubes
Chain lube testing requires significant time spent riding. Fortunately, Benett Shane doesn’t seem to mind. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Buying Advice: How To Choose Bike Chain Lube

With so many options on the market, it can be hard to decide which chain lube is right for you. We’ll cover some of the factors to consider in this buying advice article with more information provided in our FAQ section below.

Types of Bike Chain Lube

Although there are a dizzying number of chain lubes available, all claiming to be the best available, they can be broadly divided into three categories, wet, dry, and wax-based, one of which will likely suit your needs best for most of the season, if not all throughout it. Generally speaking, wet lubes are best for wet conditions, dry lubes are aimed at dry conditions, and most of the drip-on wax lubes we tested claim to be effective in all conditions unless otherwise stated.

Riding through a puddle on a gravel bike in conditions that are best suited to a wet chain lube
Wet, oil-based lubes are generally a good choice for conditions like these. (photo/Jim Graham)

Wet

Synthetic or oil-based “wet” lube, goes on thick and wet, and remains highly viscous, helping the chain run quiet and shift smoothly between gears. A benefit of many wet lubricants is that they repel water and stick tenaciously to the chain, making them a great choice for riding in wet conditions. The potential downside to this type of lube is that its oil-based composition remains wet and sticky which can attract contamination from dust and dirt that lingers in the air or gets sprayed up from wet roads. So, cleaning the chain and reapplying wet lube generally needs to be done more frequently to maintain its effectiveness. Examples include WD-40 Specialist Bike Wet Lube, Muc-Off C3 Ceramic Wet Weather Lube, and Silca Synergetic Wet Lube.

Riding a mountain bike on dry trails in conditions well suited to using a dry chain lube
Dry conditions are where dry lubes work best given that they are less prone to collecting contaminants like dust and dirt. (photo/ Heather Benson)

Dry

Next up are light and midweight “dry” lubes. While the term “dry lube” may sound strange, rest assured that these will not dry out your chain and cause it to squeak and slow you down. These lubrications are dry in the sense that they don’t attract and absorb contaminants the way wet lubes do. So, for arid, dry, and dusty conditions, they can keep your chain running more smoothly and save the components in your drivetrain from wearing out prematurely. Dry lubes are typically more susceptible to washing off in wet conditions, however, leaving your chain dangerously exposed to premature wear. We tested three lubes that are specifically intended for use in dry conditions including Pedro’s Slick Wax, Muc-Off Dry Weather Lube, and Motorex Chainlube with PTFE.

Riding a road bike that is lubed with a wax-based drip-on chain lube
Most wax-based drip-on lubes claim to be good for all conditions and are preferred by many high-performance, high-mileage riders for their ability to reduce the rate of wear on the drivetrain and their often long application intervals. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Wax

Wax-based chain lubes are actually more of a protective coating. These coatings cover the chain in liquid wax and then cure to the metal to create a barrier against friction and contamination. Traditionally, these wax chain coatings required full immersion of a perfectly clean and ideally brand-new chain in a crock pot full of searing hot wax. The process takes time and effort to complete and comes with a high initial cost, meaning that immersive wax is a growing but still niche style of chain maintenance that isn’t for everyone. Still, there are quite a few hot melt wax options like Molten Speed Wax, Silca Secret Chain Blend Hot Melt Wax, absoluteBlack’s GraphenWax, and others that are widely considered to be the gold standard.

Hot melt chain waxes, like Silca’s Secret Blend, have a loyal following for many reasons, but the process is a bit more involved than the drip-on alternatives. (photo/Silca)

The good news regarding wax-based lubricants is that they are now available in drip-on versions. The compositions of these drip lubes are similar to their immersive counterparts, so they promise a very high percentage of the same benefits in efficiency and protection against premature wear. They drip on just like wet and dry lube but still require the chain to be super clean in order to work effectively. Traditionally, they haven’t been the quietest lubes available, but some of the latest options are among the best in terms of drivetrain noise. Some of the drip-on wax-based lubes we tested at Effetto Mariposa Flowerpower, Ceramic Speed UFO Drip, Squirt Long Lasting, Maxima Chain Wax, and absoluteBLACK GraphenLube.

Pre-waxed Chains

Kogel is one brand that sells pre-waxed chains so you don’t have to go through the hassle of deep-cleaning a brand-new chain yourself. (photo/Kogel)

Some brands and retailers offer brand-new chains that have been deep-cleaned and pre-waxed so that you don’t have to go through the hassle of doing it yourself. This is a good option for those who need to replace their chain and want to switch over to wax, but who might not have the tools, solvents, or time to do the whole deep-cleaning process for themselves. With a little searching, you can usually find popular high-end chains that come prepped from Kogel, Silca, Ceramic Speed, or absoluteBLACK, among others.

Applying Ceramic Speed UFO Drip chain lube to a bike chain
Recommended application instructions vary between types of lube and brands. Most drip-on wax lubes need to be applied to a perfectly clean chain and allowed to cure for up to 12 hours to work best. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Application

With all chain lubes, it’s best to follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for application. This varies by the type of lube and often from brand to brand, but applying lube to a clean chain is almost always the best way to achieve optimal results. Many drip-on wax lubes specify that the chain must be perfectly clean before applying, so extensive cleaning must be done before the initial application. Even brand-new chains must be stripped of the factory coating so that the lube can effectively penetrate and lubricate the surfaces inside the rollers. Depending on the conditions you ride in and the amount of grime that gets stuck to the chain, subsequent applications may be as simple as wiping down the chain and reapplying, or as involved as a deep clean before reapplication.

Another important fact to remember is that the rollers of the chain are the critical points to lubricate. The outer plates are simply linking the rollers together, and do not need to be lubricated in order for the chain to be efficient. Excess lubrication on the surface of the chain will usually result in faster build-up of contamination and less efficient performance.

A clean drivetrain on a road bike
A clean and well-lubricated drivetrain is a happy drivetrain that’ll run smoother, quieter, and last longer. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Cleaning

Whichever chain lube you choose to apply, it’s vital to also regularly clean the surface of the chain and occasionally deep clean it using a solvent or degreaser. This will remove contaminants that form an abrasive mess inside the chain internals over time. To clean the surface, it’s best to use a microfiber or course cotton cloth that pulls away surface junk before it infiltrates the chain. To remove that internal gunk, remove the chain and submerge it in a degreaser, or better yet in an ultrasonic cleaner. For a relatively deep clean without removing the chain, handheld chain scrubbers are a quick, easy, and effective option.

The best time to clean a nasty chain is as quickly as possible after you finish your ride. Don’t wait until 15 minutes before your next ride, by which time the gunk and debris have solidified and are much more challenging to remove. Additionally, any reapplication of lubricant needs time to penetrate the chain rollers in order to be effective, so at a minimum, it needs to be done a few hours ahead of time in the case of oil-based wet lube, or 12 hours for wax-based lube. 

Silca Super Secret Chain lube and Silca Synergetic Wet Lube
While some modern chain lubes, like the Silca Super Secret Chain Coating and Synergetic Wet Lube, are relatively expensive, they can last a long time between reapplications while extending the life of your drivetrain components, which can save you money in the long term. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Value

Keeping your drivetrain clean and lubricated can help improve your efficiency and reduce friction that can lead to premature wear of your (often expensive) drivetrain components. As such, the upfront cost of a quality lube can save you money in the long term by extending the life of your chain, chainrings, and cassette. Still, chain lubes vary quite dramatically in price from around $2 an ounce up to over $40 an ounce. It is absolutely fair to wonder what makes some lubes so much more expensive than others and if the added cost is worth it.

While there is most definitely some science backing up the friction reduction and watt savings of some high-end lubes, we’re still talking about marginal gains that are of most interest to super high-performance riders and racers. Most people will be just as well served by a lube that costs less and performs nearly as well. That said, many of the higher-end lubes also happen to be the longest lasting, meaning that some of the higher cost is offset by less frequent applications.

Riding up a paved mountain road with a well lubed bike chain
Choosing the right chain lube and properly maintaining your drivetrain can lead to many miles of carefree riding while focusing on nothing but the road (or trail) ahead. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do I need chain lube?

Think about all of the work that your bicycle chain does. It’s what makes your bike move forward, and every revolution of your pedals forces each chain link to click over hundreds of teeth on your chainring and cassette. You’re basically grinding metal on metal.

If the chain is dry, rusty, or coated with a layer of grime, it reluctantly creaks and grinds through each pedal stroke while the friction and contaminants slowly grind at the contact surfaces and cause all of the components, the chain, cassette, and chainring, to wear out.

Chain lube not only protects against corrosion, but it reduces friction to help keep that chain moving freely which can enhance efficiency and reduce the wear on your drivetrain. It helps to keep your drivetrain running smoothly and quietly and can extend the service life of all your drivetrain components.

How often do I need to apply chain lube?

Unfortunately, the answer here is “it depends.” There are various factors at play including the conditions you ride in and the lube you use. If your chain is looking or feeling gritty, or you’re starting to hear it squeak, that’s a good indicator that it’s time to clean and re-lube your chain. This may come after a single muddy, wet ride, or it could come after several hundred miles of dry riding. Paying close attention to how your drivetrain looks, feels, and sounds will be the best way to determine when it’s time to reapply.

How do I apply chain lube?

Most chain lubes won’t work well if you’re applying them incorrectly. Thankfully, it’s a pretty simple task, though it can be messy if you’re not careful. (Stay off white carpets while applying it.) There is some variability between types of lubes and brands, but most manufacturers provide recommendations to achieve the best results.

Start by cleaning and degreasing your chain (keep reading for tips on how to do that).

For oil-based lubes most experts recommend dripping a single drop of lube on each roller in the chain. Use the quick link as your starting and finishing point so you don’t do it twice! Let it sit for 30 seconds, then backpedal for 15-20 revolutions to allow the lube to sink in and penetrate the nooks and crannies of the chain. Once you’ve done that, take a clean rag and wipe down any excess lube before heading out the door. Don’t skip this step or you’ll instantly start to collect grime.

For drip-on wax-based lubes, it is recommended to apply it to a perfectly clean and dry chain (for the initial application) and to give the lube time to “cure” for up to 12 hours. This takes a little more forethought than just squirting some lube on the chain minutes before you head out for a ride, but typically it’s easy enough to apply the lube the night before and let it sit overnight so that it has adequate time to penetrate the chain’s internals and form a hardened protective layer.

Can I use chain lube as a cleaner or instead of a degreaser?

Often, people will skip the degreasing step and just lube the chain, counting on the lube and subsequent wipe-down to remove most of the built-up gunk. While this will quiet a chain, this is definitely not the best way to approach cleaning and lubing your drivetrain and may actually accelerate wear with more lube trapping more grit and contaminants. It does, however, depend on the type of lube you’re using, as a few brands claim that their products clean and lube the chain in one.

Even with those all-in-one lubes, like those from Rock N’ Roll or the Wolf Tooth WT-1, we feel it’s always best to start with a super clean chain and go from there. They are intended to push contaminants out as you ride, so you’ll want to be sure to wipe those away frequently to remove them from the system.

Since wax-based lubes don’t attract as much grit and tend to flake off a bit as you ride, you may only need to wipe down your chain unless you can feel grit trapped in there. In general, wax-based lubes don’t require as frequent of cleaning.

Most oil-based lubes aren’t designed to clean your chain (with the exception of the Wolf Tooth WT-1 Synthetic mentioned above). In fact, it can just end up creating a sludge that acts like liquid sandpaper and wears down your entire drivetrain faster, costing you more in the long run. Not to mention getting all over your socks, legs, walls, car…everything.

What’s the difference between wax and oil lube?

The more common oil-based lubricants are classic because they’re easy to use, and in most cases, they keep a chain running quietly and smoothly. But unless you’re regularly cleaning and degreasing your chain, oil lubricants are dirt magnets, attracting dust and grit as you pedal.

On the other hand, some cyclists might have experience using actual wax, which provides the same smooth and quiet riding experience without as much grime. Originally, waxing a chain required a labor-intensive wax melting process (and the use of a slow-cooker or saucepan). While it was cumbersome, the results couldn’t be matched by oil-based lubricants.

Thankfully, new technology has allowed for the development of wax lubricants in liquid, drip-on form, making them as easy to apply as their oil-based counterparts but with the longevity and friction-reducing benefits of wax. So, with drip-on wax-based lubes like Effetto Mariposa Flowerpower, Ceramic Speed UFO Drip, Silca Super Secret, and Squirt, you can get the best of both worlds.

Is there a time I should choose oil over wax lube?

If you’re riding inside on the trainer, you may want to stick to an oil-based lube. Wax sloughs off as it’s used, so you may end up with a carpet stained by “greasy” chunks of wax if you’re not careful.

And if your riding conditions are wet and sloppy, wet, oil-based lubes, especially those specifically designed for wet conditions, have traditionally been better to overcome the constant onslaught of rain, mud, slush, and grime. That said, in those conditions, you’ll want to be sure to clean your drivetrain and reapply lube more frequently.

Why are some lubes labeled as biodegradable?

It’s only in recent years that lube companies have shifted to looking for eco-friendly options. According to The Ecologist, many lubricants were made with environmentally unfriendly Teflon and petroleum distillates. More recently, many chain lube brands are striving to provide more environmentally friendly products that still perform just as well.

Think about how you wash your bike, near a storm drain or on the grass in your backyard, or how your chain lube may get into the soil if you’re out on a long ride. It seems like a minor thing, but finding a chain lube that is biodegradable is just a small way to help reduce your carbon footprint (or tire tread in this instance).

In addition to the environment, chain lubes that don’t include toxic chemicals are also better for our health. Getting a lube on your hands that’s made from sunflower seeds like Effetto Mariposa Flowerpower, for example, is much less concerning than one that contains PTFEs or other forever chemicals.

Why can’t I just use regular WD40?

Actual WD40 might seem like a substitute for chain lube since you use it to silence squeaky hinges or loosen tight bolts. But using WD40 as a lube on your chain is doing more harm than good: It acts as a degreaser, not a lubricant.

Use WD40 to clean your chain if you don’t have any Simple Green or your chain is so dirty that grease-fighting dish soap isn’t doing the trick, but we don’t recommend using it as a lubricant. (That said, the WD40 brand does make a chain lube that we recommend above.)

Can I use the same chain lube on all my bikes?

Yes. Your choice of chain lube should be more condition-dependent rather than bike-dependent. If you’re heading out on a wet or muddy ride, opt for wet chain lube. (Those tend to be popular with cyclocrossers.)

Ride in the desert? You’ll want a dry or wax-based chain lube to avoid a buildup of grit. If you bounce between settings or weather conditions, look for an all-around chain lube, though be prepared for frequent cleaning and reapplication, especially after particularly dusty or wet rides.

How do I switch from oil to wax-based lube?

If you’re making the switch to a wax-based lubricant, the same rules as above apply: Clean and degrease your chain first. But it’s even more important when making this switch since the oil lube and wax lube won’t mix well together, so you want your chain to be completely oil and contaminant-free before making the transition. (Even if you’re starting with a new chain, clean and degrease it, since new chains come coated in heavy grease.)

Are those expensive chain lubes worth it?

Depends. Like most things in life, as you reach the upper echelons of performance, the price increases exponentially faster than the benefits. The gains in watts savings and friction reduction are real, but they are marginal enough that it probably doesn’t really for the vast majority of riders.

So, while the performance gains are subtle, there are other benefits: Longevity and silence.

The Silca, absoluteBLACK, and CeramicSpeed lubes are among the quietest we’ve used. When we’re cruising along and can’t hear or feel our drivetrain, we trick ourselves into feeling like it’s faster. So there’s that subliminal benefit, too.

They’re also some of the cleanest and longest-lasting. And some have ingredients that better protect the drivetrain, extending its lifespan.

Bottom line: Yes, they’re better, but maybe only worth the price if you’ve already optimized everything else.

How do I properly clean my chain?

The best and most thorough way to clean your chain is to remove it, soak it in degreaser or mineral spirits for an hour (or overnight), then spray it down with fresh degreaser and scrub all sides of it with a toothbrush. Then maybe some soap and water, rinse it and allow it to completely dry (like in a low-temp oven or direct sunlight).

Yes, this takes time, but if you’re prepping for a big event, complete overhaul, or switching to one of the premium chain lubes mentioned here, it’s worth the effort.

Alternatively, chain cleaners like the Park Tool Chain Gang kit often get it “clean enough” without having to remove it. The kit comes with a cassette cleaning tool and degreaser, too.

If you’re really time-crunched, the Finish Line Speed Bicycle Chain Degreaser works so well it’s scary. It literally blasts grease and dirt off your chain, leaving nothing but bare metal. The downsides are it’s not biodegradable (but is at least ozone-friendly), and that all that grease and grime ends up getting blasted onto whatever’s behind the chain…which can be your bike, garage floor, etc…make sure it doesn’t spray onto your disc brakes!

Should I degrease a new chain before installing it?

Here’s where it gets funny…most chain manufacturers will say no, that the stock grease is perfectly fine. Most chain lube brands will tell you that grease is too thick and a magnet for dust and dirt that also prevents lube from penetrating properly. We’d agree on the latter (third-party testing backs that up, too) and recommend using the cleaning method above to completely clean your chain first if you want to get the best possible performance from a lube.

How can I extend the life of my chain?

Appropriate chain cleaning and lube reapplications will help elongate your chain’s lifespan. After every ride, give your chain and other drivetrain components a quick wipe-down to dry them off and remove buildup, especially if they got wet during your ride. This is even more important if you use a wet lube and ride in wet conditions frequently as mud, grit, and grime will get all over your chain. Consider the conditions you ride in, inspect your chain frequently, and clean and re-lube accordingly.

How much is too much chain lube?

Many riders over-lube their chains. Generally, if there’s anything more than a light coating of chain lube on the outside of the chain, you’re just wasting lubricant, and risking it getting into other parts of the bike including the brake surfaces or rotors. Excess lube also ends up on the teeth of your cassette, chainrings, and derailleur pulleys. It becomes difficult to properly clean your drivetrain, collects dirt, and accelerates wear on your cassette and chainrings.

Avoid this by wiping excess lube from the chain after applying, ensuring that it’s nearly or entirely dry to the touch. Remember, generally speaking, you only need to apply lube to the rollers on the chain. Again, following the manufacturer’s recommendations is always a good idea.

Related Content

The post The Best Bike Chain Lubes of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
349836
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024 https://bikerumor.com/best-bike-handlebar-bags/ Thu, 01 Feb 2024 22:01:15 +0000 https://bikerumor.com/?p=350544 Handlebar bags are a simple and effective way to add storage to your bike while keeping your essentials within arm’s reach. Whether you’re simply looking…

The post The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
Collage photo of handlebar bags for lead image

Handlebar bags are a simple and effective way to add storage to your bike while keeping your essentials within arm’s reach. Whether you’re simply looking to free up your jersey pockets or gearing up for a massive day on the bike, choosing the right handlebar bag can help you stay organized on any ride or adventure.

Handlebar bags saw a resurgence in popularity during the 2010s as road riding became more adventurous and gravel riding exploded. Compared to the handlebar bags of old, modern models are robust, functional pieces of equipment that are both technical and pleasing to the eye. And, the growing popularity of the humble handlebar bag means there are more great options to choose from than ever before, coming in a range of shapes, sizes, and capacities to suit nearly every storage need. Of course, all those options means that finding the perfect bar bag can be a challenge.

To help, we gathered 19 of the best handlebar bags on the market and tested them for months while examining their materials, construction, ease of use, storage capacity, organizational features, stability, and attachment systems. Review author, Bennett Shane, personally tested each model to see how they perform in the real world and how they compare to each other.

Whether you’re searching for something small, medium, or large, or are interested in finding the best value, our top handlebar bag recommendations are listed below, followed by the best of the rest, which, quite frankly, are all great options in their own right. To see the specs of all 19 models we tested at a glance, check out our handy comparison chart. Not sure what you need? Check our buying advice for useful information to help steer you in the right direction or our FAQ section for answers to some common questions.

The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024


Best Overall Bike Handlebar bag

Ornot Handlebar Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $86.00
  • Volume 3.1 liters
  • Dimensions 5.4" x 8.5" (13 x 22cm)
  • Weight 261 grams
  • Material ECOPAK™ recycled fabric
  • Water-resistant? Yes, PFC-Free DWR treatment
  • Color options ECOPAK White, ECOPAK Coyote, ECOPAK Black
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Adjustable strap width
  • Super stable and quiet
  • Great zipper access
  • Bomber construction
  • Structured design holds shape well

Cons

  • Moderately expensive
  • Not super light
Best Value Bike Handlebar Bag

Lead Out! Mini Bar Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $50.00
  • Volume 1.3 liters
  • Dimensions 8" x 3.5” (20 x 9cm)
  • Weight 105 grams
  • Material 840D Ballistic Nylon Carbonate fabric exterior; Robic 210 Baby Riptstop interior.
  • Water-resistant? Yes, very
  • Color options Black, Charcoal, Orange
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Light
  • Durable
  • Organized
  • Tidy Straps
  • Quiet

Cons

  • Smaller volume may be limiting for some users
Best Small Capacity Bike Handlebar Bag

Arundel Mini Bar Czar

Specs

  • MSRP $70.00
  • Volume 1.2 liters (75 cubic inches)
  • Dimensions 7” x 4.5” x 3.5” (18 x 11.5 x 9cm)
  • Weight 110 grams
  • Material Polyester
  • Water-resistant Yes
  • Color options Grey
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Light
  • Out of the way
  • Magnetic closure is super easy to use
  • Oval shape makes it roomier than expected

Cons

  • Only comes in grey
  • Moderately expensive
Best Medium Capacity Bike Handlebar Bag

Mission Workshop Toro Handlebar Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $105.00
  • Volume 1.7 liters
  • Dimensions 9" x 4” (22.8 x 10cm)
  • Weight 140 grams
  • Material Dimension Polyant X-Pac® and Cordura Multicam fabrics
  • Water-resistant? Yes, "weatherproof"
  • Color options Orange VX, Yellow VX, Teal VX, Purple VX, Olive VX, Coyote VX, Gray VX, Black VX, Black Camo, Tropic Camo, Stratus Black, Stratus Blue, Stratus Purple
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Very light
  • Beautifully constructed – made in USA
  • A multitude of colors to choose from
  • Solid YKK zipper
  • Compatible with shoulder strap

Cons

  • A smidge wide for narrower handlebars (40cm and under)
  • Expensive
Best Large Capacity Bike Handlebar Bag

Road Runner Bags West Coast Burrito

Specs

  • MSRP $125.00
  • Volume 5 liters
  • Dimensions 11” x 6” (28 x 15.2cm)
  • Weight 396 grams
  • Material 1000D Cordura
  • Water-resistant? Yes, PFC-Free DWR treatment
  • Color options Black, Burgundy, Grey, Navy, Olive, Rust, Coyote
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Quality materials and construction
  • Huge storage capacity
  • Handmade in the USA
  • Surprisingly stable
  • Retains shape thanks to internal structure
  • Convertible to shoulder bag with optional strap

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Aero penalty
  • Heavier weight
  • Too wide for bars narrower than 42cm
Best Perceived Quality Bike Handlebar Bag

Wizard Works Lil Presto Barrel Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $88.00
  • Volume Large: 3.4 liters (tested), Small: 1.8 liters
  • Dimensions Large: 8.6" x 5.5" (22 x 14cm), Small: 7.9" x 4.1" (20 x 10.5cm)
  • Weight 325 grams (excludes straps)
  • Material Cordura
  • Water-resistant? Yes, very
  • Color Options Black Camo, Fluro Pink, Olive, Rust, Splatter (custom design option available)
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Gorgeous
  • Massive but tidy
  • Heirloom-level quality
  • Comes in two sizes

Cons

  • The anchor cord could be longer or stretchier
  • Moderately expensive
  • Not the lightest
Best Handlebar Bag for Mount and Carry Versatility

Rapha Bar Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $70.00
  • Volume 2 liters
  • Dimensions 9.25" x 4.3" x 3.1" (23.5 x 11 x 8cm)
  • Weight 168 grams (255 grams with shoulder strap)
  • Material DWR treated polyester
  • Water-resistant? Yes, PFC-Free DWR treatment
  • Color options Black
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Good size for most rides
  • Can be mounted on handlebar or frame
  • Converts to shoulder carry
  • Good internal organization

Cons

  • Top strap position is not adjustable

Best of the Rest

Unique Modular Design

Swift Industries Kestrel

Specs

  • MSRP $120.00
  • Volume 2 liters (up to 4 liters with optional accessories)
  • Dimensions 10” x 5” x 3” (25.4 x 12.7 x 7.6cm)
  • Weight 171 grams
  • Material ECOPAK recycled Sailcloth
  • Water-resistant? No
  • Color options Redwood, Coyote, Black, Teal
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Untouchable modularity
  • Built to last
  • Easy to attach
  • Lots of storage options
  • Light

Cons

  • Expensive
Excellent Quality and Organization

ALMSTHRE Signature Bar Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $65.00
  • Volume 2.4 liters
  • Dimensions 7.5” x 5” (19 x 12.7cm)
  • Weight 219 grams
  • Material Nylon Ripstop
  • Water-resistant? Yes, water-repellent main body, waterproof zippers
  • Color options California Gold, Cosmic Blue, Midnight Black, Passion Pink, BWR, Two-Tone (Blue/Gold)
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Quality build
  • Lovely appearance
  • Tidy straps
  • Well-organized storage

Cons

  • None
Impressively Lightweight

Orucase Smuggler

Specs

  • MSRP $44.00
  • Volume 1.15 liters
  • Dimensions 7.5" x 3.5” (19cm x 8.9cm)
  • Weight 86 grams
  • Material Challenge EPX200
  • Water-resistant? No
  • Color options Black, Black Camo, Coyote, Fuschia, Golden Daze, Lilac, Ocean Blue, Tropical Teal
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Super light!
  • Durable
  • Easy to attach
  • Reasonably priced

Cons

  • No anchor cord
  • Zipper requires two hands
Highly Reflective

Blackburn Grid Handlebar Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $45.00
  • Volume 1.2 liters
  • Dimensions 8” x 3.5” (20.3 x 8.9cm)
  • Weight 106 grams
  • Material 600d Polyester
  • Water-resistant? DWR treated for water resistance
  • Color options Black
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Light
  • Stable
  • Reflective
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Only comes in one color

Arundel Handlebar Czar

Specs

  • MSRP $80.00
  • Volume 2 liters (120 cu. in.)
  • Dimensions 9.5" x 5" x 3.5” (24.1 x 12.7 x 9cm)
  • Weight 184 grams
  • Material Water-resistant material with sonic-welded seams
  • Water-resistant? Yes
  • Color options Black
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Stable
  • Easy to open and close
  • Sleek appearance

Cons

  • Moderately expensive
  • Only comes in black

Ornot Handlebar Bag Mini

Specs

  • MSRP $54.00 (ECOPAK), $44.00 (regular)
  • Volume 1.15 liters
  • Dimensions 7.25” x 3.5” (18.4 x 9cm)
  • Weight 140 grams
  • Material Ecopak Recycled Fabric
  • Water-resistant? Yes, PFC-Free DWR treatment
  • Color options Black ECOPAK, Coyote ECOPAK, White ECOPAK, Black, Stone Blue, Olive, Morroco, Nordic
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Light
  • Stable
  • Easy to open and close
  • Super tidy look on the bars

Cons

  • Straps may need to be trimmed for thumb clearance
  • Smaller volume may be limiting for some riders

Lowland Crafts Bike Handlebar Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $55.00
  • Volume 2.2 liters
  • Dimensions 9" x 5" x 3” (22.8 x 12.7 x 7.6cm)
  • Weight 150 grams
  • Material Duck Canvas (Waterproof Ottertex also available)
  • Water-resistant? No (but you have the option for Ottertex fabric)
  • Color options Lots, you pick when ordering
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Handmade to order
  • Reasonable price
  • Low-bulk straps
  • You choose colors and fabric

Cons

  • Zippers and fabric are not waterproof

Swift Industries Bandito Bicycle Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $95.00
  • Volume 3.25 liters
  • Dimensions 8.5” x 5.5” (21.6 x 14cm)
  • Weight 227 grams
  • Material ECOPAK™ recycled fabric
  • Water-resistant? No
  • Color options Coyote, Black, Teal, Redwood
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Stable
  • Built to last
  • Easy to attach
  • Looks great

Cons

  • On the larger and heavier side
  • Moderately expensive

Rapha Explore Bar Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $80.00
  • Volume 2.4 liters
  • Dimensions 8” x 4” x 3” (20.3 x 10 x 7.6cm)
  • Weight 170 grams
  • Material Recycled Nylon, Polyurethane internal coating, DWR exterior treatment
  • Waterproof Highly water-repellent
  • Color options Black, Navy, Olive Green, Rose Brown
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Rugged durability
  • Light
  • Converts to hip pack or shoulder bag
  • Easy to attach

Cons

  • Shoulder strap is permanently attached and can fiddly to deploy and put away
  • Moderately expensive

ALMSTHRE Compact Bar Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $55.00
  • Volume 1.2 liters
  • Dimensions 7.5” x 3.5” (19 x 8.9cm)
  • Weight 158 grams
  • Material Nylon Ripstop
  • Water-resistant? Yes, water-resistant main body, waterproof zippers
  • Color options Midnight Black, Plum, Melon Green, Sunflower Yellow, Cosmic Blue, California Gold
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Lovely appearance
  • "Hard-shell" design retains shape
  • Plenty of organization options

Cons

  • Smaller size may limit usefulness for some riders

Chrome Industries Helix

Specs

  • MSRP $45.00
  • Volume 3 liters
  • Dimensions 9” x 6” x 3” (22.8 x 15.2 x 7.6cm)
  • Weight 272 grams
  • Material Proprietary tarp exterior, polyester
  • Water-resistant? Yes, PFC-Free DWR treatment
  • Color options Black, Fog
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Tough material and robust build
  • Easy to access
  • Lots of storage space

Cons

  • Might not fit small bikes
  • Significant aero penalty
  • A bit big for those with lower storage needs

Rockbros Bike Handlebar Bag

Specs

  • MSRP $21.00
  • Volume 2 liters
  • Dimensions 9” x 3.5” (22.8 x 9cm)
  • Weight 216 grams
  • Material Polyester
  • Water-resistant? No
  • Color options Black, Dark Green
The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024

Pros

  • Very inexpensive
  • Nice material
  • Converts to shoulder carry

Cons

  • Might be too wide for 40c or narrower handlebars.
  • Handlebar strap attachment points sag a bit

Comparison Chart

Handlebar BagMSRPVolumeDimensionsWeightWater-Resistant?
Ornot Handlebar Bag$863.1 liters8.5″ x 5.4″261 gramsYes
Lead Out! Mini Bar Bag$501.3 liters8″ x 3.5″105 gramsYes, very
Arundel Mini Bar Czar$701.2 liters7″ x 4.5″ x 3.5″110 gramsYes
Mission Workshop Toro$1051.7 liters9″ x 4″140 gramsYes, “weatherproof”
Road Runner Bags West Coast Burrito$1255 liters11″ x 6″396 gramsYes
Wizard Works Lil Presto$883.4 liters (1.8L option)8.6″ x 5.5″325 gramsYes, very
Rapha Bar Bag$702 liters9.25″ x 4.3″ x 3.1″168 gramsYes
Swift Industries Kestrel$1202 liters10″ x 5″ x 3″171 gramsNo
ALMSTHRE Signature Bar Bag$652.4 liters7.5″ x 5″219 gramsYes, very
Orucase Smuggler$441.15 liters7.5″ x 3.5″86 gramsNo
Blackburn Grid Handlebar Bag$451.2 liters8″ x 3.5″106 gramsYes
Arundel Handlebar Czar$802 liters9.5″ x 5″ x 3.5″184 gramsYes
Ornot Handlebar Bag Mini$541.15 liters7.25″ x 3.5″140 gramsYes
Lowland Crafts Handlebar Bag$552.2 liters9″ x 5″ x 3″150 gramsNo
Swift Industries Bandito$953.25 liters8.5″ x 5.5″227 gramsNo
Rapha Explore Bar Bag$802.4 liters8″ x 4″ x 3″170 gramsYes, very
ALMSTHRE Compact Bar Bag$551.2 liters7.5″ x 3.5″158 gramsYes, very
Chrome Industries Helix$453 liters9″ x 6″ x 3″272 gramsYes
Rockbros Bike Handlebar Bag$212 liters9″ x 3.5″216 gramsNo

Why Should You Trust Us?

For the team at Bikerumor, writing about and riding bikes isn’t just our job, it’s our passion. Long rides, short rides, road, gravel, mountain, we love being out there. We also love being prepared for whatever may come our way, whether we’re out for an hour or the entire day. Being prepared means having everything we need to stay comfortable, nourished, and ready to fix mechanical issues that may arise, so we need space to keep all of the important things with us. More recently, handlebar bags have become one of our favorite ways to keep our essential items close at hand wherever our rides take us.

For our handlebar bags buyer’s guide, we called on the expertise of Bennett Shane to test and compare a diverse selection of the best handlebar bags on the market. Bennett has been cycling seriously for over two decades and spends an inordinate amount of time on the bike while riding for fitness, fun, and lots of product testing. He lives just outside of Portland, Oregon, and enjoys both long and short rides throughout the countryside and mountains of the Pacific Northwest (and everywhere else for that matter). Living in an area with highly variable weather and often embarking on half to full-day rides in the mountains means that he often needs to carry lots of gear, food, and tools to be prepared for changing temperatures and weather while remaining self-sufficient. Since it isn’t always possible, or comfortable, to stuff everything into jersey pockets, Bennett relies on handlebar bags to expand his on-bike storage capabilities and keep essentials close at hand. Having owned and used many different handlebar bags over the years, Bennett has unique insight into this growing category of products. Bennett also has loads of experience testing and reviewing other products like handlebar tape, cycling shoe covers, winter cycling gloves, road bike shoes, cycling bibs, road bike helmets, and more.

After researching the best handlebar bags on the market, we gathered 19 different models for testing and side-by-side comparison. Our diverse selection includes a range of sizes, brands, and price points, with models suitable for any type of riding or storage need. After examining the materials and construction of each model, Bennett mounted them up on his small fleet of road bikes, loaded them with jackets, gloves, snacks, phones, cameras, keys, and more, and hit the road. Over the course of several months, Bennett rotated through these handlebar bags on his daily rides while assessing each model’s storage, attachments, stability, zippers, ease of use, weather resistance, and all-around performance in real-world riding conditions. When testing concluded, we zeroed in on our favorites and those that excel for specific reasons compared to the rest.

Bennett Shane testing handlebar bags
Bennett Shane tested all of the handlebar bags in this review on road rides throughout the Pacific Northwest. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Buying Advice: How to Choose a Bike Handlebar Bag

Handlebar bags are fairly simple pieces of gear, but with so many models on the market, choosing the right one can be more challenging than you might expect. While many bar bags share a similar barrel-like shape, sizes, materials, and constructions vary such that some are likely to suit your needs better than others. For instance, some are impressively weather-resistant while others are simple but effective canvas. Some use internal reinforcement to hold their shape, while others offer less structure and thereby shed weight. Many offer a host of features like external pockets, as well as straps for attaching lights and securing lightweight clothing while others are more simple. We’ll break down important factors to consider when choosing a handlebar bag below.

Closing the zipper on the Wizard Works Lil Presto Handlebar bag
Modern handlebar bags like the Wizard Works Lil Presto are good-looking, functional pieces of equipment that can ensure you’re prepared and organized on every ride. (photo/Ben Guernsey_

Size

Finding the right size handlebar bag is arguably the most important aspect of getting one that serves your needs the best. Thankfully, handlebar bags come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and storage capacities to meet different storage needs and wants. We tested 19 different models with nearly all of them having capacities ranging between 1.15 and 3.4 liters (with one outlier at 5 liters), which are all great options for adding a bit of extra storage to your bike for everyday rides. Of course, with those different capacities come varying dimensions which will impact how they fit and how much space they take up on your handlebar.

Capacity

The storage capacity or volume of handlebar bags is typically expressed in liters and sometimes in cubic inches. The bags we tested range between 1.15 liters on the smaller end and up to 5 liters on the larger side of the spectrum. What size works best for you will depend on what you’re intending to carry in it. Of course, this may vary depending on the length of your ride, the weather conditions, or the season, so for some riders, having more than one handlebar bag to suit varying needs may be necessary. For others, finding a versatile size that works most of the time is the best bet. And, in addition to a handlebar bag’s stated capacity, other storage features like external mesh or zippered pockets can effectively increase their capacity.

The ALMSTHRE Compact Bar bag mounted on a road bike handlebar
Smaller capacity bags like the 1.2-liter ALMSTHRE Compact easily fit the essentials, don’t weigh much, and take up little real estate on the handlebar. (photo/Bennett Shane)

For riders with low storage demands, the smaller, 1.15 to 1.3-liter, options may be ideal for stashing ride essentials like a phone, keys, nutrition, winter gloves, or other small items while incurring the lowest weight and aerodynamic penalty. We tested six bags in this size range including the Arundel Mini Bar Czar, Lead Out Mini, Ornot Mini, Orucase Smuggler, ALMSTHRE Compact, and the Blackburn Grid. Not surprisingly, these bags all share similar compact dimensions and are lighter weight than larger options.

The Ornot Handlebar Bag mounted to a road bike handlebar
Though just slightly larger at 1.7 liters, the Mission Workshop Toro holds significantly more than the “mini” or “compact” models. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Moving up a step in storage capacity are what we’re calling medium-capacity handlebar bags. We tested eight models between 1.7 and 2.4 liters with most of them falling at or closer to 2 liters of storage. These bags fall into what could be called the “goldilocks” zone where they are neither too big nor too small, instead, they are “just right”. These bags easily accommodate everything you can fit into the smaller models while having enough additional space to squeeze a packable jacket for variable weather and/or more snacks to keep you fueled on longer rides. These include the Mission Workshop Toro, ALMSTHRE Signature, Swift Industries Kestrel, Rapha Bar Bag, and several others.

The Mission Workshop Toro handlebar bag mounted to a road handlebar
The 3.1 liter Ornot Handlebar Bag is spacious inside along with very well-executed external storage features. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Moving up once more, we tested four bags that hold 3 to 3.4 liters. While 3 liters is by no means huge, it is quite a bit of storage space and plenty for most riders to tackle all-day rides and carry everything they need without being prohibitively large or heavy. These bags will allow you to bring multiple layers, larger food items, or even bigger cameras. The four bags in this size range are the Ornot Handlebar Bag, Swift Industries Bandito, Wizard Works Lil Presto, and the Chrome Helix. For those with even greater storage needs, the 5-liter Road Runner Bags West Coast Burrito has you covered.

The Road Runner Bags West Coast Burrito Handlebar Bag mounted to a road bike handlebar
Those seeking maximum storage can find it in the Road Runner West Coast Burrito. You could easily fit several Burritos in there, but all that storage results in a bag that takes up much more space on the handlebar. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Dimensions

Along with their capacity, the shape and dimensions of handlebar bags vary too. As storage volume increases, so do the dimensions of the bag. Eleven of the models we tested share a barrel shape and have measurements for their length and circumference. The remaining eight models have more of a rectangular (or flattened oval) shape that include measurements for length, height, and width. Many of the barrel-shaped bags have rigid internal structures that help them retain their cylindrical shape which prevents them from sagging and helps keep them more stable, even when they aren’t full.

Riding with the Lead Out! Mini Handlebar Bag
The smaller the bag the less storage it has, obviously, and the less likely it is to interfere with your hand positions on the handlebar. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

It is important to consider the dimensions of a handlebar bag as it may impact how well it fits on your handlebar and whether or not it conflicts with your hand positions. Depending on the shape and width of your handlebars, some bags might be too wide/long. The models we tested range between 7 and 11 inches in length, with most of them falling between 7.5 and 9.5 inches. It’s worthwhile to have a friend measure the space between your hands in these positions, so you can use the measurements provided in this guide to choose a bag that is ideally sized for you and your bars. 

A closer look at how handlebar bags attach with the Ornot Handlebar Bag Mini
A closer look at the Ornot Handlebar Bag Mini demonstrates the typical attachment method of handlebar bags with two bar straps and a tether cord. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Attachment

Most handlebar bags attach to the handlebars in a similar way although there are slight variations on the theme. The typical bar bag attachment system includes two straps that loop around the handlebar on both sides of the stem along with an elasticized tether cord that loops around the headtube or stem to anchor it and add some stability. The handlebar straps on some bags are fixed in position, while others have multiple attachment points that allow you to position them optimally for your cockpit setup.

While they all achieve the same goal, different brands use different handlebar strap types to attach bags to the bars. Some use hook and loop (velcro) straps, others use nylon webbing straps with plastic buckles, and some use rubber (Voile-style) straps. They all work in relatively the same way, although some make it a little easier to install and remove a bag and some are more grippy and stable than others.

The Blackburn Grid Handlebar Bag with straps positioned close to the stem
Many bar bags, like the Blackburn Gird pictured here, allow you to adjust the position of the handlebar straps to have them closer to the stem or wider out on the bar tape. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Depending on whether you have accessories like lights or a computer mounted on your bars, or where you place your hands on the bar tops, having the option to adjust the position of the attachment straps may be worthwhile. If, for example, the space immediately next to your stem is already cluttered with computer and/or light mounts, it’s nice to be able to move the straps out and have them over your handlebar bar tape. Conversely, if you want all the space possible for your hands on the bar tops, moving the straps closer to the stem can give your thumbs more room. The Ornot Handlebar Bag is a good example here, as it has two attachment points for the Voile straps at 4 inches apart and 6 inches apart.

Riding with the Lead Out! mini Bar Bag
With a water-resistant shell fabric and waterproof zippers, the Lead Out! Mini Bar Bag should keep its contents dry in most situations. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Water Resistance

Depending on the weather conditions you ride in, water resistance may or may not be a deciding factor in your handlebar bag choice. Fortunately, there are plenty of options that are highly water resistant (some even claim to be “weatherproof”) and are made with DWR-treated fabrics, water-resistant linings, waterproof zippers, or all of the above. While few bags claim to be completely waterproof, there are many that are pretty darn close, like the Mission Workshop Toro, Rapha Explore Bar Bag, and several others. These can typically fend off showers, road spray, and mud with ease while keeping your precious cargo nice and dry. Others have simpler constructions that aren’t quite as water-resistant but will usually fare well against super light amounts of moisture.

The reflective detail on the front of the Ornot Mini Handlebar Bag
It’s small, but the reflective strip on the webbing on the front of the Ornot Mini is better than nothing and may improve your chances of being seen. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Reflectives

Some brands and models of handlebar bags have reflective elements added to them to add a bit of visibility in low-light conditions. While we don’t feel it is a requirement, and most of the bags we tested don’t have them, we do appreciate reflective features when they are added to an accessory like a handlebar bag if it increases our chances of being seen by motorists. The Blackburn Grid is a standout for its reflectivity as the entire front face of the bag lights up when hit with a headlight. Some other models have reflective strips integrated into the front-facing webbing like on the models from Ornot and Rapha. Many bags also have daisy chain-style webbing attachment points where clip-on lights can be attached for those rides where you’re flirting with darkness.

The handmade Lowland Crafts Handlebar Bag can be ordered in custom colors.
Handlebar Bags give you the opportunity to express your personal style. The handmade Lowland Crafts bag is made to order and you have the option to choose the colors for a custom look. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Style

While many riders probably don’t think of a handlebar bag as a fashionable accessory, there are plenty who do, and it is one of many ways to easily and affordably add some personal flair to your bike. Some handlebar bags only come in one or a few safe color options like black or grey which are easy to coordinate with just about any bike, while others are available in a range of colors. ALMSTHRE, Orucase, Mission Workshop, and Wizard Works offer some of the most color options among the models we tested. Lowland Crafts is unique in regards to style since these bags are handmade to order and the buyer is given the option to choose the main fabric, front panel, and attachment webbing colors when purchasing.

Value

Compared to many things in cycling, handlebar bags are a relatively inexpensive accessory. That said, they come at a range of prices with the majority of the models we tested training between $40 and $125. In general, the larger the bag, the more expensive it is, and vice versa. Still, some of these seemingly simple little bags cost a little more than you might expect. One of the reasons is that many of the brands that make handlebar bags (like Wizard Works, Swift Industries, Road Runner, and Mission Workshop) are quite small, produce in small batches, use recycled fabrics, and/or make their products in the USA where costs are higher. All those factors make the price go up, but should also correlate to added value with long-term durability thanks to quality materials and constructions.

Pulling a pair of cycling gloves out of the Ornot Handlebar Bag
You can easily expand your on-bike storage with the right handlebar bag. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Frequently Asked Questions

Why should I use a bike handlebar bag?

Handlebar bags have been around for ages, but they’ve recently seen a resurgence in popularity with more models on the market than you can shake a stick at. There are several reasons that people choose to use one including convenience. The handlebar-mounted position keeps your ride essentials like a phone, camera, snacks, gloves, etc., within arm’s reach in a place that can be easily accessed when stopped or even while riding. They offer additional storage capacity that can be used to hold items that you might normally carry in a jersey pocket which can enhance your comfort by freeing up your lower back and reducing the need to awkwardly reach back to your jersey pockets to access them. They also come in a range of shapes, sizes, and colors, so you can get one that meets your specific needs for storage and suits your personal aesthetic.

What size handlebar bag do I need?

Handlebar bags come in a range of sizes to suit varying storage needs and choosing the right size really comes down to figuring out what you want to store in it. If you need something to simply hold your phone, nutrition, cycling gloves, credit card, and keys on your everyday rides, then a lower-capacity bag (1.2 liters or so) like the Ornot Mini, Orucase Smuggler, Lead Out Mini, Blackburn Grid, and ALMSTHRE Compact bar bags are all great choices.

If your storage needs are slightly greater and you need space for all the previously mentioned essentials plus things like arm warmers or a light jacket, then a medium-capacity bag (around 2 liters, give or take) provides a little more flexibility to fit more gear for longer rides or variable weather conditions. For those who frequently head out for all-day epics or like to be super prepared with packable cycling jackets, a camera, a sandwich, you name it, the larger capacity packs (3 to 5 liters, or more) will readily accept more cargo. And, for those with greater storage needs, like bikepackers, for example, there are lots of even larger options to carry even more gear.

Of course, you don’t always need to fill a larger handlebar bag to its capacity either, so they can work quite well for smaller loads, just with a slight weight and aero-penalty compared to smaller options. When in doubt, we suggest erring on the slightly larger side rather than ending up with a bag that is too small.

There are lots of options on this list, which one should I get?

There are lots of great handlebar bags on the market, so you’ve got a lot of options. We tested 19 different models, and there are plenty of others to choose from as well. Realistically, they all work pretty darn well, so choosing the best one for your needs comes down to getting one that’s the right size, meets your demands for weather resistance, and organizes your gear, snacks, etc., in a way that appeals to you.

Related Content

The post The Best Bike Handlebar Bags of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
350544
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024 https://bikerumor.com/best-handlebar-tape/ Fri, 26 Jan 2024 17:10:00 +0000 https://bikerumor.com/?p=350542 Handlebar Tape is an often overlooked upgrade that can greatly improve your relationship with your bike. The tape on your handlebar is quite literally where…

The post The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
Handlebar tape lead image

Handlebar Tape is an often overlooked upgrade that can greatly improve your relationship with your bike. The tape on your handlebar is quite literally where your hands connect to the bars, serving as a critical contact point between you and your machine and one that can greatly impact your comfort and control.

Most bikes’ original handlebar tape is chosen for its low cost, but a well-chosen and high-quality roll will maximize control and comfort while refreshing your bike’s appearance and amplifying its style. While it won’t transform your riding abilities, the right tape can improve performance by providing the desired grip and vibration-dampening characteristics. And like anything else in cycling, handlebar tape comes in a vast array of materials, constructions, thicknesses, surface textures, prices, and color/pattern options to suit varying needs and preferences.

For most riders, once they find a tape they like, they tend to stick to it, pun intended. That said, if it’s been a while since you tried something new, there may be something better that utilizes more advanced materials and offers a nicer feel. But with hundreds of options to choose from, finding the best handlebar tape can be a challenge. To help, we gathered 15 of the best and most popular handlebar tapes on the market to test and compare.

After months of testing, we’ve chosen our favorites with our top recommendations listed below, followed by the best of the rest which are all quality options that we feel are worthy of consideration. You can check out our comparison chart to see the models we tested at a glance. If you need help deciding what to buy, our buying advice provides useful information, and we’ve got answers to common questions in our FAQ section.

The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024


Best Overall Handlebar Tape

Supacaz Super Sticky Kush Star Fade

Specs

  • MSRP $45.00
  • Material Material: Polyurethane, Foam, Aluminum plugs
  • Thickness 3mm
  • Length per roll 2,160mm
  • Color options Oil Slick, Platinum, Red, Blue, Neon Pink, Neon Orange, Celeste, Neon Yellow (also comes in numerous "Classic" and "Galaxy" color options)
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Excellent grip in all weather conditions
  • Subtly stylish
  • Classy bolt-on bar end plugs included
  • Easy to re-wrap
  • Can usually be found for less than MSRP

Cons

  • Moderately expensive
Best Value Handlebar Tape

Zipp Service Course Bar Tape – Road

Specs

  • MSRP $27.00 (road) – $30.00 (CX)
  • Material Polyurethane, foam
  • Thickness 3.5mm
  • Length per roll 1,900mm
  • Color options Black, White, Red
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Grippy surface
  • Clean, tidy appearance
  • Durable
  • Easy to wrap

Cons

  • Be careful ordering as it comes in textured (CX) and smooth (road) finishes
  • Might be a little thick for those with small hands
Runner-Up Best Handlebar Tape

Silca Nastro Cuscino 2.5

Specs

  • MSRP $50.00
  • Material Polyurethane, EVA Foam
  • Thickness 2.5mm (also comes in 3.75mm)
  • Length per roll not specified
  • Color options Black, Red, Cyan Blue, Grey, Neon Pink, White
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Damps without excess bulk
  • Hard-wearing
  • Crash-replacement discount

Cons

  • Patience is required to wrap
  • Expensive
Most Comfortable Handlebar Tape

ENVE Handlebar Tape

Specs

  • MSRP $40.00
  • Material Polyurethane with vibration damping silicone backer strip
  • Thickness 3mm
  • Length per roll 2,500mm
  • Color options Black Grey, White
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Easy to wrap
  • Cushy and grippy
  • Long enough for super wide bars

Cons

  • Limited color options
  • Moderately expensive
Best Handlebar Tape for Wet Conditions

Fizik Tempo Bondcush 3mm Soft

Specs

  • MSRP $45.00
  • Material EVA Foam, Microtex
  • Thickness 3mm
  • Length per roll 2,350mm (+/- 20mm)
  • Color options Green, Red, Yellow, Black, Orange
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Uniquely pleasant feel
  • Excellent performance in wet conditions
  • Nice looking

Cons

  • Can break down unless cleaned regularly
  • Moderately expensive
Classy Looks and Reasonable Price

Arundel Wraptor Wrap

Specs

  • MSRP $27.95
  • Material Polyurethane, Foam
  • Thickness 3.3mm
  • Length per roll not specified
  • Color options Black, White, Red, Blue, Pink
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Excellent grip in all weather conditions
  • Beautifully tuned damping
  • Classy style
  • Offset logos can be exposed or hidden

Cons

  • Not stretchy
Another Good Value Handlebar Tape

FSA PowerTouch Handlebar Tape

Specs

  • MSRP $33.20
  • Material Hybrid Cork
  • Thickness 3mm
  • Color options Black, White, Pink, Red, Orange, Yellow, Green, Blue
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Grippy texture
  • Excellent performance in wet conditions
  • No adhesive for easy removal and re-wrappings

Cons

  • None
Ron's Favorite Handlebar Tape

Camp and Go Slow Western Rattler Bar Tape

Specs

  • MSRP $44.00
  • Material Nylon blend with 1.5mm foam backing
  • Thickness 1.9mm (measured)
  • Length per roll 3,300mm
  • Color options Western (brown) or Eastern (green) Rattler colors
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Distinctive looks
  • Easy to unwrap and rewrap
  • Cleans up nicely with soap and water
  • Super durable
  • Comes in a reusable bag

Cons

  • Moderately expensive
  • Doesn't come with bar plugs or finishing tape

Best of the Rest

Classic and Affordable

Cinelli Cork Ribbon Bar Tape

Specs

  • MSRP $20.00
  • Material Natural cork, Synthetic Foam
  • Thickness not specified
  • Length per roll "fits bars up to 46cm"
  • Color options Black, White, Blue, Denim, Yellow, Orange, Red, Grey, Light Blue, Natural, Blue Prince, Pink Jersey
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Easiest to wrap
  • Affordable
  • Classic looks
  • Super light

Cons

  • Doesn't like to lay perfectly flat
  • Cork/foam can tear more easily

Ergon BT Allroad

Specs

  • MSRP $37.95
  • Material EVA foam, Polyurethane
  • Thickness 2.5mm
  • Length per roll 2,100mm
  • Color options Black, Merlot Red, White Speed, Wilderness Green, Space Blue
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Customizable wrapping options
  • Nicely damped 
  • Easy to wrap

Cons

  • Moderately expensive
A Touch of Bling at a Fair Price

HiFi Precision Premium Bar Tape

Specs

  • MSRP $30.00
  • Material Polyurethane, foam
  • Thickness 2mm (measured)
  • Length per roll not specified
  • Color options Black/Gold
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Grippy
  • Durable
  • Rich visual texture
  • Modest price

Cons

  • Doesn’t like to be re-wrapped

Fizik Vento Microtex Tacky

Specs

  • MSRP $35.00
  • Material Microtex
  • Thickness 2mm
  • Length per roll 2,350mm
  • Color options Solid: White, Black, Red, Celeste Bianchi, Lilia Fluo, Yellow Fluo, Pink Fluo, Orange Fluo. Bi-color: Black/Grey, Black/White, Black/Red, Black/Orange, Black/Celeste, Black/Pink, Black/Yellow
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Light
  • Grippy
  • Low bulk
  • Easy to wrap
  • Lots of colors

Cons

  • Doesn't dampen much vibration

Arundel Gecko Grip

Specs

  • MSRP $22.95
  • Material Ventilated polyurethane, EVA foam
  • Thickness not specified
  • Length per roll 2,200mm
  • Color options Red, Blue, Yellow, Black, Gray, White
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Natural feeling grip
  • Easy to wrap
  • Low bulk
  • Lies flat
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Doesn't provide much vibration dampening

Easton Microfiber Tape

Specs

  • MSRP $30.00
  • Material Microfiber, anti-shock foam
  • Thickness not specified
  • Length per roll not specified
  • Color options Black, Blue, Green, Red, White, Yellow
The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024

Pros

  • Grippy texture
  • Durable
  • Easy to wrap
  • Good dampening

Cons

  • Gel adhesive isn't that sticky (pro or con depending on preference)

Comparison Chart

Handlebar Tape ModelMSRPThicknessLength per roll (claimed)# of Colors
Supacaz Super Sticky Kush $453mm 2,160mm8 Star Fade, plus Classic and Galaxy options
Zipp Service Course Bar tape – Road$273.5mm1,900mm3
Silca Nastro Cuscino 2.5$502.5mm (tested), 3.75mmnot specified6
ENVE Handlebar Tape$403mm2,500mm3
Fizik Tempo Bondcush 3mm Soft$453mm2,350mm (+/- 20mm)5
Arundel Wraptor Wrap$27.953.3mmnot specified5
FSA PowerTouch $333mm2,000mm8
Camp and Go Slow Western Rattler$441.9mm (measured)3,300mm2
Cinelli Cork Ribbon Bar Tape$20Variable with stretch“fits bars up to 46cm”12
Lizard Skins DSP Bar Tape$451.8, 2.5 (tested), 3.2, 4.6mm2,080mm (varies slightly by thickness)16
Ergon BT Allroad$37.952.5mm2,100mm5
HiFi Precision Premium Bar Tape$302mmnot specified1
Fizik Vento Microtex Tacky$352mm2,350mm (+/- 20mm)15
Arundel Gecko Grip$22.95not specified, but relatively thin2,200mm6
Easton Microfiber Tape$30not specifiednot specified6

Why Should You Trust Us?

The team at Bikerumor takes cycling very seriously and we are fortunate to get to spend lots of time riding bikes and trying different products. Spending as much time riding as we do, we’ve learned that the touchpoints on our bikes are of critical importance when it comes to our comfort. And in the case of handlebar tape, it also plays a major role in our control. As such, we’re always looking for and testing out the best products that can enhance our experience and improve our performance on the bike, handlebar tape included. And, this isn’t a list we’ve just thrown together, instead, we’ve actually tested all of these bar tapes ourselves to see how they perform in the real world.

For our handlebar tape buyer’s guide, we leaned on the expertise of Bennett Shane to test the majority of the options in this review and sprinkled in a couple of options that are favorites of our staff writers. Bennett is a committed road, and sometimes gravel, cyclist who lives in the Portland, OR area and rides year-round for fun, fitness, and product testing. While he has a racing background, Bennett has shifted his focus in recent years to personal challenges, vertical goals, and long rides through the countryside and mountains of the Pacific Northwest. With over two decades of riding experience, Bennett is very meticulous about bike setup and maintenance and takes pleasure in dialing in his cockpit to perfection with perfectly wrapped handlebar tape. He’s also spent years working for numerous prominent brands in the cycling industry and has an uncanny depth of knowledge and experience using, or at least tinkering with, nearly every product on the market. Spending as much time riding as he does, Bennett deeply understands the importance of the touch points on his bicycles and the role they play in his comfort, control, and enjoyment on every ride. Additionally, Bennett has contributed to our buyer’s guide of the best road bike saddles, bib tights, cycling shoe covers, road bike tires, handlebar bags, and several other categories of accessories and gear.

The majority of these handlebar tapes were tested by Bennett over the course of several months during the fall and early winter in the Pacific Northwest. Each tape was wrapped on the handlebars of one of his road machines, ranging from carbon superbikes to boutique steel custom builds, and ridden for hundreds of miles in the wildly variable weather of the PNW. In the home workshop, we analyzed the ease of wrapping each tape, and on the road, we considered the grip (gloved and gloveless) in both wet and dry conditions, feedback, cushioning, thickness, and the overall feel of each tape while riding in the real world. Tapes that were not tested by Bennett were tested by one of our staff writers and used for several months or more. After extensive testing, we compiled this list of our favorites and those that excel in specific ways compared to the rest.

Bennett Shane testing handlebar tape
Review author Bennett Shane spent months testing the best handlebar tapes on the market, seen here riding with the Supacaz Super Sticky Kush. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Buying Advice: How to Choose Handlebar Tape

There are literally hundreds of options for handlebar tape on the market. So many options that figuring out what you need can be confusing and downright frustrating. It’s important to consider what you want from a handlebar tape, whether that’s cushioning, a super direct/high feedback feel, wet weather grip, or even a fun and funky style. There are lots of variables to consider in choosing tape including thickness, surface texture, stretch, color or pattern options, and, of course, cost. And, comfort on the bike doesn’t stop at the handlebar, so it’s important to consider other contact points like a quality saddle, well-fitting bib shorts, and the right pair of road bike shoes too.

A closer look at the Cinelli Cork Ribbon handlebar tape
Handlebar tapes come in a wide range of materials and textures. Cinelli’s Cork Ribbon tape has been around for decades and has a decidedly classic look and feel. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Material/Texture

While handlebar tape comes in rolls and often has sticky backing, “tape” is a bit of a misnomer since we are talking about a multi-layered wrap designed to provide grip and cushioning with only the minimal adhesive properties needed to stay secure once it is tightly wrapped. Traditionally, bar tapes were made of leather, cloth, or simple cork-infused foam. Other options used gel inserts to provide cushioning, but tended to be quite heavy. Like all things in the bike world, handlebar tapes have undergone steady marginal improvements over the years and are now being touted as performance upgrades, with claims of reducing rider fatigue. 

The Zipp Service Course bar tape wrapped on a handlebar
Many modern tapes feature foam cushioning with different surfaces like polyurethane, often embossed with a logo or texture, as seen on the Zipp Service Course bar tape. Different materials provide different feels and grip levels. (photo/Bennett Shane)

These days, handlebar tapes come in a variety of materials, often consisting of a cushioning layer bonded to a surface layer where the hands make contact with the tape/handlebar, while some still take a simpler approach with a single material throughout. Each tape will have a surface texture inherent to the material, like Microfiber/synthetic leather, polyurethane, or Microtex, or that has been added during the manufacturing process. Different materials, textured or not, provide varying levels of grip or tackiness for gloved or gloveless hands and in wet or dry conditions. Textures can add tactility and grip, and for riders who tend to perspire or who ride in wet conditions, more texture usually can’t hurt. 

Riding with the Fizik Tempo Bondcush 3mm Soft handlebar tape
Fizik’s Tempo Bondcush 3mm Soft handlebar tape adds a little girth to the bar, some nice cushioning, and has a soft, perforated surface that adds texture and has great grip in wet conditions or with sweaty hands. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Thickness/Cushioning

Handlebar tapes come in a range of different thicknesses to suit varying needs and preferences. These days, you can find handlebar tapes in thicknesses ranging from around 1.5mm up to roughly 5mm, with the vast majority of tapes falling between around 2mm and 3.5mm. Some tapes are even offered in several thicknesses, like the Lizard Skins DSP which comes in 1.8mm, 2.5mm, 3.2mm, and 4.6mm, so you can choose which is best for your needs. What works best for you typically depends on the size of your hands, the type of riding you do, the surfaces you encounter, and how much (or little) cushioning you like.

Lizard Skins DSP Bar Tape wrapped on a handlebar
The ever-popular Lizard Skins DSP bar tape comes in 4 thickness options so riders can choose what works best for their needs. We tested it in the 2.5mm thickness. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Generally speaking, the thicker the tape, the more cushioning and vibration-dampening it provides. Most tapes have a cushioning layer of foam that is largely responsible for its thickness, and the more there is, the more it can absorb road buzz and vibration over rough surfaces. Of course, thickness isn’t the only determining factor, as the density of said foam also plays a role in its cushioning capabilities. And, given recent advancements in foam technology, modern bar tapes can provide enhanced cushioning without adding excessive thickness, thus offering riders nicely balanced levels of comfort and control with thinner tapes as well.

The Silca Nastro Cuscino bar tape wrapped on a handlebar
We loved the 2.5mm thickness of the Silca Nastro Cuscino tape tested for our average-sized hands and its balanced properties of grip, cushioning, and control. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Tape thickness also impacts the effective diameter of the handlebar, making it adaptable for riders with different-sized hands. Riders with larger hands, for example, may prefer the feel and control provided by using a thicker tape that makes the handlebar fit more proportionally in their hands. Likewise, riders with smaller hands may find that a thinner tape helps them grip the handlebar and therefore control the front end of the bike a bit more easily. This mostly comes down to rider preference.

Easton Microfiber tape wrapped on a handlebar
The stretch of a handlebar tape, or lack thereof, impacts how easy it to wrap around tight bends and trickier areas like the hoods. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Stretch

Handlebar tapes have varying levels of stretch depending mostly on the materials and construction. Tapes with more stretch are typically a bit more forgiving during the wrapping process and make it a bit easier to get around tight bends and the hoods whereas tapes with little to no stretch require a bit more care to wrap perfectly. Additionally, one can also alter the thickness and/or cushiness of a stretchy tape depending on how tightly you wrap it. The tighter you pull it, the thinner and less cushy it becomes, and vice versa.  

Close up view of the logo pattern of the HiFi Precision Premium handlebar tape
Some handlebar tapes have cool patterns or logos that can lend a bit of flair to your cockpit. The HiFi logos on their Premium Bar Tape line up nicely for a unique look. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Style: Colors and Patterns

Your handlebar tape is one of the most cost-effective ways to express your personal style on your bike. Whether you’re looking for something subdued and classy or bright and flashy, there are options to suit virtually every taste and match any build. Some tapes come in only a few color options, while others come in a vast array of colors and/or patterns to choose from. While we wouldn’t necessarily recommend choosing a handlebar tape based solely on the color, you should be able to find something that meets both your performance needs and style too.

Riding with the Supacaz Super Sticky Kush bar tape
While expensive, the Supacaz Super Sticky Kush tape adds a subtle pop of color in the drops and performs well enough that it’s one of our favorite all-around bar tapes. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Value

Bar tapes have increased significantly in cost recently, with most rolls costing over $30 and some upwards of $50. Tapes at the more expensive end of the spectrum, like the Supacaz, Silca Nastro Cuscino, and Lizard Sins DSP, typically will provide low weight and bulk, supreme comfort, and hard-wearing durability. Mid-price point tapes can also provide all three of these but often lack in one of these areas. The least expensive tapes, like Cinelli Cork Ribbon, can perform well but may degrade faster, either by tearing, compressing, or losing stickiness due to surface erosion, but they are affordable to replace. Of course, regularly cleaning most tapes with mild soap and water will greatly extend their lifespan and usability. Depending on how much you ride, it’s reasonable to expect to get a full season, or possibly several, out of your handlebar tape, even with less expensive options.

Hand on the Fizik Tempo Bondcush Soft handlebar tape.
Whatever handlebar tape you choose, a fresh wrap can have your bike looking and feeling like new. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Frequently Asked Questions

There are lots of tapes on this list, which one should I buy?

Finding the perfect tape is a matter of personal preference and it should meet your performance demands. There isn’t really any single handlebar tape that will be the perfect option for every single rider. Consider what you want from your handlebar tape and factors like material, thickness, cushioning, price, and even color, and you should be able to narrow down the options to find a good choice.

Can I use these handlebar tapes on my gravel bike?

Any of the handlebar tapes we tested can be used on gravel bikes, or any bike with a drop bar for that matter. Generally speaking, however, many gravel riders will opt for tapes that provide a good level of cushioning to take the edge off of the impacts and high-frequency vibrations experienced on gravel roads. Again, whether you’re riding pavement, gravel, or both, the right tape generally comes down to balancing your personal preferences for comfort and control.

Thick or thin handlebar tape, which is better?

Riders typically choose the thickness of their bar tape based on personal preference. As mentioned above, you can change the effective diameter of your handlebar with different thicknesses of bar tape to get a more proportional fit for the size of your hands. The feel of the bars is another factor that influences this choice as some riders want the super precise feel that a thinner tape can provide, while others may prefer the enhanced comfort that a thicker tape offers. We typically gravitate toward handlebar tapes that provide the best balance of control, grip, and cushioning, and these tend to be in the 2.5mm to 3mm thick range.

Why are some of these handlebar tapes so expensive?

With prices of the models we tested ranging from $20 to $50, bar tape is one of the least expensive things you can buy in cycling, but it’s fair to wonder what makes some tapes so much more expensive than others. The least expensive handlebar tapes, like the Cinelli Cork Ribbon, for example, have the simplest material and construction, so it stands to reason that a basic roll of cork/foam costs less. As materials and constructions get more advanced, however, the price goes up as well. Once you start bonding layers together and adding embossed, textured patterns and logos, it makes sense that some tapes are a bit more expensive. In our testing, we’ve also found that the more expensive options tend to provide the highest level of performance. These higher-end tapes also seem to be a bit more durable in our experience, making the price a little easier to justify.

I’ve never replaced my own handlebar tape before, how do I do it?

Wrapping your handlebars is among the easier tasks in cycling, but if you’ve never done it before, it can be a little tricky. If you’re not the DIY type, that’s okay too, your local bike shop will be happy to take care of it for you. If you are willing to take it upon yourself, there are lots of helpful articles and videos online that explain it well and show you how it’s done. It would take a separate short article to explain how to do it properly, so we’ll skip the quick and dirty explanation here and hopefully bring you a “how-to” article in the near future.

How do I know when to replace my handlebar tape?

Like any consumable part on a bike, your handlebar tape will wear out eventually and needs to be replaced. The rate at which this happens varies depending on how much you ride, the conditions you ride in, and how well you maintain your tape. Fortunately, it’s fairly inexpensive compared to other bike parts, so keeping your bike’s handlebar looking and feeling fresh is relatively easy on the wallet. Over time, the foam can get compressed and the tape surface degrades from friction and sweat. A crash or even your bike tipping over can also cause premature damage to your handlebar tape. Signs that your handlebar tape has reached the end of its usable lifespan include rips, tears, abrasion, or the edges of the tape curling. If your cushy tape no longer feels cushy or you notice the texture of your tape is worn away or the grip is reduced, those are also indicators of worn-out tape. Some tapes may also get loose as they stretch out over time, a sure sign that it’s ready for fresh wrap.

How do I clean and maintain my handlebar tape?

If you’ve ever ridden with white or lightly colored handlebar tape, then you know it gets dirty pretty quickly. Since it’s in constant contact with our hands, gloved or not, it takes a fair amount of abuse in the form of friction, sweat, dust, rain, and road spray. Taking a little time to clean your handlebar tape every once in a while can not only help keep it looking fresh but also help to extend its lifespan. Removing the buildup of sweat and road grime also makes it feel nicer on the hands. Most tapes, especially those with smooth or less porous surfaces, can be wiped clean fairly easily with mild soap and water and a towel. Tapes that are less smooth and more absorbent, like cork, aren’t as easy to wipe off, but they can be sprayed off and patted dry with a towel to help remove sweat stains and the associated salts.

The post The Best Handlebar Tape of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
350542
The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024 https://bikerumor.com/best-womens-mountain-bike-shoes/ Thu, 11 Jan 2024 20:56:31 +0000 https://bikerumor.com/?p=349454 Our shoes serve as the important connection between our feet and the pedals and they are critical when it comes to our comfort, control, and…

The post The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
Lead image for women's mountain bike shoes

Our shoes serve as the important connection between our feet and the pedals and they are critical when it comes to our comfort, control, and efficiency on the bike. While they can easily be overlooked, the right pair of women’s mountain bike shoes can enhance our enjoyment and performance every time we ride.

Whether you clip in or ride flat pedals, your shoes need to interface well with your pedals and provide support, stability, foot protection, and comfort for long and short rides. Of course, the performance characteristics you look for in a shoe can vary as widely as the different styles of mountain biking, and there are options designed to meet the range of needs across the spectrum. But with so many models on the market, we know that finding the right mountain bike shoes can be a challenge.

To help, we gathered up 9 of the best clipless and flat pedal women’s mountain bike shoes on the market and tested them for months to see how they perform, and most importantly, how they compare to each other. Whether you’re looking for a lightweight clipless shoe to maximize your efficiency or a grippy flat pedal shoe to keep your feet glued to the pedals, we’ve got recommendations to take your rides to the next level.

Our favorite flat pedal and clipless women’s mountain bike shoes are listed below. To see the models we tested at a glance, check out our comparison chart. If you need help deciding what’s right for you, our buying advice goes over important considerations and our FAQ section provides answers to common questions. And, if you’d like to see more options, we’ve tested the best unisex and men’s clipless mountain bike shoes and flat pedal mountain bike shoes too.

The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024


Best Overall Flat Pedal Women's Mountain Bike Shoes

Giro Latch Women’s

Specs

  • MSRP $150
  • Weight (per shoe) 319.5 grams (42 EU/ 9.5 US Women's)
  • Pedal Type Clip
  • Outsole Material Tack Rubber
  • Upper Material Microfiber
  • Midsole Mute Foam
  • Closure Laces with elasticized lace keeper
  • Sizes Available 36 – 43 EU (whole sizes only)
The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Grippy sole
  • Relatively lightweight
  • Balanced sole stiffness
  • Mute Foam midsole dampens vibration

Cons

  • None
Best Budget Flat Pedal Women's Mountain Bike Shoes

Ride Concepts Livewire Women’s

Specs

  • MSRP $110
  • Weight (per shoe) 340 grams (41 EU/ 9.5 US Women's)
  • Pedal Type Clip
  • Outsole Material DST 6.0 Max Grip
  • Upper Material Synthetic with anti-abrasion mesh
  • Midsole EVA
  • Closure Laces with elasticized lace keeper
  • Available Sizes 5 – 10 US Women's (whole and half sizes)
The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Solid pedal grip
  • Good toe protection
  • Breathable
  • Reasonable price

Cons

  • Sizing runs a little small – size up a half size
  • Low-volume fit may not work for all riders
  • Not very water-resistant
Runner-Up Best Flat Pedal Women's Mountain Bike Shoes

Five Ten Freerider Pro Women’s

Specs

  • MSRP $160
  • Weight (per shoe) 334 grams (9 US Women's/41.5 EU)
  • Pedal Type Clip
  • Outsole Stealth S1 rubber
  • Upper Material Synthetic
  • Midsole EVA
  • Closure Laces
  • Sizes Available 5 – 11 US Women's (whole and half sizes)
The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Grippy Stealth rubber soles
  • Tough and weather resistant synthetic uppers
  • Well balanced sole stiffness
  • Slightly larger size range than some other brands

Cons

  • Not the best traction for hike a bikes in loose or slippery conditions
  • Roomier toe box – runs a little large – check size chart
  • Soles show wear more quickly than others
Best Overall Clipless XC Women's Mountain Bike Shoes

Giro Sector Women’s

Specs

  • MSRP $240
  • Weight (per shoe) 325 grams (9.5 US Women's/41.5 EU)
  • Pedal Type Clip
  • Outsole Dual-injected rubber tread knobs
  • Upper Material One-piece Synchwire upper with thermo-bonded exo-structure
  • Midsole Carbon composite plate
  • Closure Dual Boa L6 dials
  • Sizes Available 36 – 43 EU (half sizes 37.5 – 42.5)
The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Excellent breathability
  • Stiff soles – efficient pedaling
  • Versatile – would be great for gravel riding too
  • Boa dials make for easy on/off ad adjustments

Cons

  • Virtually no water resistance
  • Limited foot protection
  • More expensive
Best Budget XC Clipless Women's Mountain Bike Shoes

Shimano XC3 Women’s

Specs

  • MSRP $125
  • Weight (per shoe) 311 grams (9.5 US Women's/42 EU)
  • Pedal Type Clip
  • Outsole Rubber
  • Upper Material Seamless, perforated synthetic leather composite
  • Midsole Lightweight glass fiber reinforced nylon
  • Closure Boa L6 dial
  • Sizes Available 36 – 44 EU (whole sizes only)
The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Glove-like fit
  • Lightweight
  • Reasonable price

Cons

  • Low volume may not work for everyone
  • No half sizes
Best Clipless Women's Mountain Bike Shoes for Aggressive Riding

Ride Concepts Hellion Clip Women’s

Specs

  • MSRP $150
  • Weight (per shoe) 427 grams (9.5 US Women's/41 EU)
  • Pedal Type Clip
  • Outsole Clip Grip
  • Upper Material Microfiber
  • Midsole EVA foam with RC PowerDrive nylon shank
  • Closure Laces and upper velcro strap
  • Sizes Available 5 – 10 US Women's (whole and half sizes)
The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Flat pedal shoe style in a clipless shoe
  • Good foot protection
  • Fairly weather resistant
  • Durable soles and uppers

Cons

  • Heaver weight
  • Not super breathable
  • Soles don't have the best hiking grip
Best Clipless Women's Mountain Bike Shoes for Adventure Riding

Pearl Izumi X-Alp Summit Women’s

Specs

  • MSRP $150
  • Weight (per shoe) 369 grams (42 EU)
  • Pedal Type Clip
  • Outsole Vibram ECOSTEP rubber
  • Upper Material Seamless, perforated synthetic
  • Midsole Nylon composite
  • Closure L6 Boa dial with lower velcro strap
  • Sizes Available 36 – 43 EU (whole sizes only)
The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Good hiking grip
  • Good for adventurous riding with lots of walking
  • Comfy fit

Cons

  • Forefoot may be a little roomy for those with narrow feet
  • Middle of the road sole stiffness
Another Good Value Clipless XC Women's Mountain Bike Shoe

Scott MTB Comp Boa Women’s

Specs

  • MSRP $120
  • Weight (per shoe) 358 grams (9.5 US Women's/41.5 EU)
  • Pedal Type Clip
  • Outsole Sticki rubber
  • Upper Material Lightweight Polyurethane – Polyester
  • Midsole Nylon Composite – Glass Fiber Composite
  • Closure Boa L6 dial and lower velcro strap
  • Sizes Available 36 – 42 EU (whole sizes only)
The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Good power transfer
  • Breathable
  • Large range of cleat adjustability
  • Reasonable price

Cons

  • "Sport" fit is high volume in the toe box

Shimano GR5 Women’s

Specs

  • MSRP $115
  • Weight (per shoe) 363 grams (42 EU/ 9.5 US Women's)
  • Pedal Type Flat
  • Outsole Shimano rubber
  • Upper Material Synthetic
  • Midsole not specified
  • Closure Laces with elastic lace retainer
  • Sizes Available 36 – 44 EU (whole sizes only)
The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Reasonable price
  • "Volume last" is good for those with wider feet
  • Good off-the-bike traction and walkability
  • Toe and ankle protection

Cons

  • Rubber sole is not as grippy as other brands
  • May be too voluminous for those with narrower feet

Comparison Chart

Shoe ModelMSRPWeight (per shoe)Pedal TypeOutsoleUpper MaterialClosure
Giro Latch W’s$150319 grams (42 EU/9.5 US W’s)FlatTack RubberMicrofiberLaces
Ride Concepts Livewire W’s$110340 grams (41 EU/9.5 US W’s)FlatDST 6.0 Max GripSynthetic/meshLaces
Five Ten Freerider Pro W’s$160334 grams (41.5 EU/9 US W’s)FlatStealth S1SyntheticLaces
Giro Sector W’s$240325 grams (41.5 EU/9.5 US W’s)ClipDual-injected rubberSynchwireDual Boa L6 dials
Shimano XC3 W’s$125311 grams (42 UE/9.5 US W’s)ClipRubberSyntheticBoa L6 dial
Ride Concepts Hellion Clip W’s$150427 grams (41 EU/9.5 US W’s)ClipClip GripMicrofiberLaces and Velcro strap
Pearl Izumi X-Alp Summit W’s$150369 grams (42 EU/9.5 US W’s)ClipVibram ECOSTEPSyntheticBoa L6 and Velcro strap
Scott MTB Comp Boa W’s$120358 grams (42 EU/9.5 US W’s)ClipSticki rubberSyntheticBoa L6 and Velcro strap
Shimano GR5 W’s$115363 grams (42 EU/9.5 US W’s)FlatShimano rubberSyntheticLaces

Why You Should Trust Us

It’s fair to say that we’re a little obsessed with gear at Bikerumor. For well over a decade we’ve been reporting on the latest news, tech, and products in cycling. And, in addition to being bike nerds, we’re also avid cyclists who love riding bikes as much as we like writing about them. As such, we also know the difference that having the right gear can make for our comfort, performance, and enjoyment while we ride. Mountain bike shoes are of particular importance because they are one of two connections to our bike that we use to propel ourselves uphill and control our bikes on the way back down.

For our women’s mountain bike shoes buyer’s guide, we recruited Kira Deschaux to test and compare nine different models of clipless and flat pedal models. Kira is a skilled mountain biker and mountain bike coach based in the Lake Tahoe/Reno, NV area. She has a racing background but recently has gravitated towards steep, aggressive, technical trails. Kira has been mountain biking for 13+ years and enjoys all types of riding from lapping the lifts all day at the bike park to going out for long gravel grinds. She has worked in the outdoor industry for 20 years including in retail soft and hard goods in the snowboard and mountain bike industries in the western US and New Zealand. Kira’s riding and work experience combine to give her unique insight into product quality, technical features, and design from the inside out, and her ongoing search for the best and highest quality mountain bike gear to perform at her best means that she loves to try new brands and products as much as possible. As a coach with a background in retail, she also understands the range of needs of people from a variety of backgrounds, skill levels, and riding styles. Additionally, Kira has lent her expertise in testing and review of the best women’s mountain bike shorts.

After researching the best women’s mountain bike shoes on the market, we gathered a diverse selection of 9 models, 4 flat pedal, and 5 clipless, for side-by-side testing. Kira spent the summer and fall putting these shoes through their paces on a huge variety of trails and in varying weather conditions. From strenuous hike-a-bikes to steep downhills, casual trail rides to long gravel grinds, and everything in between, these shoes were tested for months to determine their strengths and weaknesses and how they compare to each other. While testing, Kira focused on important performance characteristics and took copious notes before making her recommendations.

Kira Deschaux testing women's mountain bike shoes
Kira Deschaux spent months testing the shoes in this review, seen here riding in the Ride Concepts Hellion Livewire. (photo/Kira Deschaux)

Buying Advice: How To Choose Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes

In the women’s mountain bike shoe market, we’ve got quite a few options to choose from. Getting shoes that fit properly is obviously an incredibly important piece of the puzzle, and beyond that, finding shoes that work well for your riding style (or styles) and work with your pedals of choice (clipless or flats) will help you narrow down the options to find what you need.

What Type of Pedals Do You Use?

This is pretty obvious, but it’s critical to get shoes that are designed to work with the pedals you use or intend to use. In mountain biking, these are either flat pedals or clipless (clip-in) pedals, and shoes are specifically designed to work with one or the other. Pedal choice is typically based on personal preference with most riders choosing one or the other and some people using both depending on the type of riding they’re doing. We go into a little more detail about the pros and cons of both pedal styles in the FAQ section below.

Using flat pedal shoes with flat pedals
If you ride flat pedals you’ll want to be sure to get some flat pedal shoes to work with them. (photo/Kira Deschaux)

Flat pedal shoes are made to work with flat, or platform, pedals and they typically feature flat soles covered edge to edge with a grippy rubber compound and a shallow tread design intended to interface well with the platforms and traction pins of modern flat pedals. Flat pedals and the accompanying shoes are chosen by many riders, from beginners to professionals, for a variety of reasons and they are suitable for everything from trail riding to downhill, enduro, and dirt jumping. Some people even ride with flat pedals on gravel and XC bikes. The four flat pedal shoes we tested are the Giro Latch, Ride Concepts Livewire, Five Ten Freerider Pro, and the Shimano GR5. Additionally, we’ve tested and reviewed unisex and men’s flat pedal shoes if you’re interested in learning more about other options.

Riding in clipless pedal shoes with clipless pedals
If you ride clipless pedals, you’ll need to clipless pedal shoes that can accept metal cleats on the soles like the Pearl Izumi X-Alp Summit pictured here. (photo/Kira Deschaux)

Clipless mountain bike pedals require shoes that are specially designed to accept a metal cleat that attaches to the sole of the shoe and clips into the retention mechanism on the pedal. This provides a mechanical connection to the pedal that keeps your feet in place and can help maximize your pedaling power throughout the whole pedal stroke. The soles of clipless shoes are generally a little bit stiffer than those on flat pedal shoes which can help to enhance pedaling efficiency further. For these reasons, clipless shoes are typically the choice of XC and gravel riders looking to get the most out of their pedaling effort. They are also popular among trail and gravity riders who prefer a “locked-in” connection feel to their pedals. The clipless shoes we tested are the Giro Sector, Shimano XC3, Scott MTB Comp Boa, Pearl Izumi X-Alp Summit, and Ride Concepts Hellion Clip. There are also lots of other unisex and men’s clipless mountain bike shoes for those interested in other options.

What Type of Riding Do You Do?

Equally important to matching your shoes with your pedals is getting shoes that suit the type of riding you do. It stands to reason that the needs of someone riding downhill at the bike park are much different than someone who is cranking out miles on a lightweight short-travel bike, and there are shoes made to suit the performance needs of different riding styles.

Riding a gravel bike in the Giro Sector women's mountain bike shoes
If you’re an efficiency-minded rider who likes XC or even gravel riding, then a clipless shoe like the Giro Sector might be a great fit. (photo/Kira Deschaux)

If you’re a trail, XC, or gravel rider who prioritizes efficiency on the bike, then a clipless shoe with a relatively stiff sole is likely the best bet. These types of shoes are typically lightweight, have sleek designs for a secure fit, and relatively rigid soles that help maximize your pedaling energy throughout the pedal stroke since you are clipped in. They sacrifice a bit in terms of foot protection and walkability, but they still do okay in both departments. Shoes like the Giro Sector, Shimano XC3, and the Scott MTB Comp Boa are geared toward this type of riding.

Riding aggressive terrain in women's mountain bike shoes
Aggressive riders or those more focused on the descents may prefer flat pedal shoes or more protective clipless all-mountain shoes. (photo/Kira Deschaux)

If you’re an aggressive trail rider, enduro racer, or downhiller, then you might prefer something with a bit more of a downhill focus like a versatile flat pedal shoe or clipless all-mountain shoe. These shoes tend to put more of an emphasis on foot protection with thicker upper materials and reinforced areas along with vibration-dampening midsoles made of EVA foam or similar materials. The soles of these types of shoes tend to be a bit softer flexing, though still supportive enough for pedaling and descending. Flat pedals and flat pedal shoes are preferred by many for these styles of riding, although there are lots of clipless shoes on the market with similar looks and performance characteristics for those who prefer to clip in.

Smiling while riding downhill in shoes that fit well
Shoes that fit well will put a smile on your face and allow you to ride at your best. (photo/Kira Deschaux)

Fit

Like any athletic footwear, ensuring that your mountain bike shoes fit well is important for both comfort and performance. Ideally, we want that “just right” fit that is snug and secure and avoids being either too tight or too loose. Too tight and they can restrict blood flow, cause hot spots, and generally cause discomfort that can be distracting. Too loose and your feet can move around resulting in a reduction of control and/or pedaling efficiency as well as discomfort caused by the foot moving and rubbing against parts of the shoe. But get the fit just right, and your shoe should feel like an extension of your foot and go virtually unnoticed while riding.

Finding shoes that fit perfectly isn’t always easy since everyone’s feet are shaped differently and sizing isn’t necessarily consistent between brands. Most brands provide size charts on their websites that are typically fairly accurate and can steer you in the right direction, and taking a few quick measurements can be helpful in determining your correct mountain bike shoe size. Whenever possible, trying shoes on at your local bike shop before you buy is the best way to make sure they’ll fit properly, just be sure to wear your biking socks when you do as sock thickness can have a significant effect on the way a shoe fits. They may be able to provide assistance and suggestions and they’ll probably appreciate your business. If ordering online, make sure there’s a good return or exchange policy in case you need to send them back or swap them for a different size.

Comparison shot of different closure style on clipless women's mountain bike shoes
Shoe manufacturers use a variety of different systems for tightening shoes on your feet with Boa dials and laces being the most popular. (photo/Kira Deschaux)

Closures

Modern mountain bike shoes go about tightening the shoes around your feet in different ways. Traditional laces and Boa dials are among the most popular, and they are often used in conjunction with a velcro/hook and loop strap. Laces are the most common on flat pedal shoes, although many clipless models use them as well, and allow for a relatively customizable fit. Laces have classic looks and are cheap and easy to replace if damaged, but they are a little more time-consuming to use when putting shoes on, taking them off, or adjusting the tension mid-ride. Boa dials are more common on clipless pedal shoes, although they are gaining popularity on flat shoes as well, and they use thin wires and ratcheting dials to pull tension over the feet. Boa closures make it very quick and easy to get shoes on and off and make mid-ride tension adjustments but they can be damaged (reliability and durability is improving, however) and they can increase the cost of a pair of shoes, comparatively speaking.

Outsole

The outsoles of your mountain bike shoes are also an important consideration. This is especially true for flat pedal shoes where we depend on the rubber compound and tread to provide grip on our pedals, but it matters on clipless shoes as well.

Comaprison shot of the soles of 4 flat pedal shoes
The soles of the 4 flat pedal models we tested, from left to right: the Giro Latch, Five Ten Freerider Pro, Ride concepts Livewire, and the Shimano GR5. (photo/Kira Deschaux)

Flat pedal shoes usually have a broad, flat sole that is completely covered in rubber and typically features a relatively shallow tread pattern. One of the main goals of these soles is to interface with your pedals and provide grip both when pedaling and descending. Different brands use different rubber compounds with the same goal allowing the pins to sink in slightly to provide a good, consistent connection with the pedal to keep your feet in place. Generally speaking, the softer the rubber, the tackier or grippier it feels. Five Ten set the standard by which all other flat pedal shoes were judged many years ago with their Stealth rubber compounds, and other brands have been slow to catch up. Recently, however, other brands have cracked the code and we feel that the Tack rubber on the Giro Latch W’s and the Ride Concepts Max Grip compound on the Livewire W’s are competitively grippy. Most flat pedal shoes are relatively easy to walk around in and provide good grip on firm surfaces, although most tend to be a little slippery in mud, snow, and loose dirt given the shallow tread designs.

Comparison shot of the soles of the clipless women's mountain bike shoe models we tested
You can see there’s much greater variation in the soles of clipless mountain bike shoes. From left to right, the Giro Sector, Shimano XC3, Scott MTB Comp Boa, Pearl Izumi X-Alp Summit, and the Ride Concepts Hellion Clip. (photo/Kira Deschaux)

Outsole designs on clipless shoes vary more dramatically as the sole isn’t as critical for keeping the foot in place on the pedal. XC-style shoes typically have a lugged sole with more defined rubber tread blocks under the heels and on the sides of the cleat box. These designs tend to walk reasonably well off the bike and bite into loose soils but the comparatively stiffer soles aren’t the best for extended periods of walking or hiking. Clipless all-mountain or gravity shoes, like the Ride Concepts Hellion Clip, often have similar soles to their flat pedal counterparts with full coverage rubber except for the open cleat box. Adventure riding shoes often have a more hike-friendly outsole like the Vibram rubber and aggressively lugged sole on the Pearl Izumi X-Alp Summit.

Value

Mountain bike shoes come at a range of prices with higher performance shoes made with fancier materials, more advanced constructions, and the latest and greatest features typically commanding a higher price. The most expensive model we tested, the Giro Sector, is a great example. These shoes are made from a unique Synchwire material and feature stiff, carbon composite soles and dual Boa dials. The Sector is a performance shoe that’s made to provide a high level of comfort while maximizing efficiency and is suitable for everyone from XC enthusiasts to racers. In that same category of shoe but on the other end of the price spectrum, the Shimano XC3 has similar looks but a toned-down sole stiffness that’s not quite race-ready but still plenty adequate for mode recreational riding, and that’s reflected in the lower price.

Among flat pedal shoes, the price differences aren’t quite as extreme with the models we tested ranging in price between $110 and $160. In general, flat pedal shoes are a little simpler in terms of design and construction and that is reflected in the price. We think the Giro Latch and the Five Ten Freerider Pro offer the best all-around performance, but even the $110 Ride Concepts Livewire does a great job and will save you some cash (assuming they fit you right).

Frequently Asked Questions

Why should I get women’s specific mountain bike shoes?

There aren’t huge differences between men’s and women’s mountain bike footwear, but there are some. One of the biggest considerations is sizing as women’s feet are generally smaller than men’s, on average. As such, women’s shoes typically come in a size range that is comparatively smaller than men’s. For example, the Scott MTB Team Boa Women’s shoe comes in sizes 36 – 42 EU, whereas the Men’s version is offered in sizes 40 – 48 EU. Likewise, the women’s version of the Five Ten Freerider Pro comes in sizes 5 – 11 US Women’s, while the Men’s version comes in sizes 6 – 15 US Men’s. For those with feet smaller than a size 5 US Women’s, a few brands, like Ride Concepts and Five Ten, thankfully make Youth versions of some of their models.

Some women’s shoes also have a “women’s” fit or last. Generally speaking, women’s feet may be more slender and slightly narrower in the heels compared to men’s, and some shoes are designed to fit that foot shape better. Again, this is a generalization that certainly doesn’t apply to all.

Lastly, colors. Many women’s shoes are offered in several color options that include both muted tones and more feminine options like shades of pink or purple that are generally not found in men’s models.

Can I just wear unisex or men’s shoes?

Absolutely. Assuming they fit you well, of course. Not too long ago, the bike industry made a major push towards women’s specific products with many brands making women’s models of bikes, helmets, shoes, and other accessories. Over the past several years, however, many brands have consolidated their product lines and done away with women’s shoe models in favor of unisex options with a broader size range to fit those with smaller feet. Since the primary differentiating factors between men’s and women’s models of shoes are usually size range and color options, the shift towards unisex models and sizing isn’t a huge surprise. And, since one of the most important aspects of a shoe is that it fits well, a unisex, men’s, or women’s model should all provide a similar level of performance and comfort assuming they are the right length, width, and volume for your feet.

Not all brands have jumped on the unisex bandwagon, however, as all of the shoes in this review are, in fact, women’s models. Ride Concepts, Five Ten, Giro, Shimano, and others, still make women’s models with the primary differences being that shoes come in smaller sizes, more feminine colorways, and some have a “women’s” fit. That said, we have tested lots of the best men’s and unisex clipless mountain bike shoes and flat pedal mountain bike shoes if you’re interested in learning more about models that are not included in this buyer’s guide.

Do I need to wear mountain bike shoes when mountain biking?

While you can mountain bike in just about any pair of shoes that you like, we prefer riding in shoes that are purpose-built for the task. Mountain bike shoes for both flat and clipless pedals are made with features, constructions, and materials that make them much better suited to riding a mountain bike than any pair of running sneakers or hiking boots.

How the shoes interface with your pedals is one of the main benefits of mountain bike shoes whether you clip in or ride flats. For flat pedals, shoes have outsoles that are designed to have a broad platform underfoot where they contact the pedal body and pins along with grippy rubber to provide a solid connection between the sole and pedal. Shoes designed for clipless pedals feature a range of outsole designs but they always have a channel in the sole with two small tracks backed by a cleat plate where you mount the cleat used to clip into a clipless pedal.

Support is another of the primary benefits of mountain bike shoes. While the soles of mountain bike shoes vary in stiffness depending on their type and intended use, they are typically much stiffer, and therefore more supportive, than a pair of running shoes, for example. These soles support the feet more both when pedaling and descending, helping to prevent the feet and calves from getting fatigued. In general, shoes designed for XC-style riding and efficiency tend to have stiffer soles while shoes designed for use with flat pedals are a bit softer flexing for added grip and pedal feel. Similarly, the uppers are designed to provide support for the feet which is critical for both comfort and control.

Mountain bike shoes are also made with robust materials and constructions so they can take the abuse associated with being attached to your feet while riding a bike through the forest. This includes tough, seamless synthetic leather and similar materials, rugged rubber soles, quality craftsmanship, and refined designs. Additionally, most mountain bike shoes make an attempt to provide a bit of added protection for the feet in the form of reinforced heel cups, toe boxes, strategically placed padding, and cushioned midsoles. Protective features vary depending on the model and intended use, of course.

Clipless or flat pedals, which is better?

The age-old debate between clipless and flat pedals is one that will likely rage on forever. The thing is, there is no right or wrong pedal type to use. You should choose whatever works best for you and you’re most comfortable using. Most people choose one or the other and some people ride both, switching between pedal types depending on the type of riding they are doing. There are, however, benefits and drawbacks to the different types of pedals which we will detail below.

Clipless pedals:

Clipless pedals provide a mechanical connection between your shoe and the pedal with a small cleat attached to the bottom of your shoe and a clip/retention mechanism on the pedal itself. They come in a range of styles including small lightweight options with no cage/platform, “trail” pedals with a mid-sized cage/platform, and “gravity” models with larger cages/platforms surrounding the clip mechanism. The benefits of clipless pedals are that when set up properly, they keep your foot on the pedal in the optimal position and are claimed to be more efficient for pedaling as you maximize your pedaling power on both the up and downstrokes of each rotation. Since your foot is attached to the pedal, it is also much less likely to come off the pedal unexpectedly over rough terrain or while jumping, etc. Being connected to the pedal can also be a handling benefit for some riders as it allows them to pull up on the bike with their feet to jump over obstacles or climb up over ledges, etc.

The drawbacks to clipless pedals are that they take some getting used to when clipping in and out, and when learning it can result in some pretty awkward crashes. It becomes second nature over time, but there is definitely a learning curve. It is also less convenient to put a foot out and back on the pedal through corners or technical sections given the need to clip in and out of the pedal. Walking in shoes with cleats can also be a little less pleasant given that there is a piece of metal attached to the sole and the soles themselves are typically quite stiff, though walkability varies depending on the model and style. Many people will also argue that riding clipless pedals teaches you poor technique given that you can rely on your connection to the pedals for certain things.

Flat Pedals:

Flat pedals, or platform pedals, provide support for the foot with a larger pedal platform/body and grip the soles with strategically placed pins. While they all share the same basic shape and design, flat pedal models differ with varying platform sizes, profiles, thicknesses, pin layouts, etc, to provide different performance characteristics out on the trail. Flat pedal shoes generally have wide, flat soles with fairly shallow treads and grippy rubber intended to provide a friction-based connection to the pedal and its pins. The benefits of flat pedals are that it’s very easy to place your foot on and remove it from the pedal. You also have more freedom and mobility so you can shift your feet around into different positions more freely should you like to adjust them for different situations. It is also claimed that riding flat pedals forces you to learn better riding technique since you can’t rely on the crutch of being attached to your pedals all the time.

The drawbacks to flat pedals are that they are claimed to be slightly less efficient for pedaling than clipless pedals because they don’t allow you to pull up on the pedals in the same way during the pedal stroke. Since your feet are not mechanically connected to the pedals, it is also possible to unexpectedly “slip” a pedal or get bounced off the pedals over rough terrain (depending on your technique and shoe/pedal combo, of course). Pedal pins are also quite sharp, so a pedal to the shin or calf can be incredibly dangerous and painful. We’ve got friends who look like their lower legs have been attacked by bears…

Why do they call it clipless when you clip in?

The term clipless is a bit of a misnomer, but it goes back a few decades. Before clipless pedals existed and properly grippy flat pedals came about, mountain bike pedals often had toe clips or cages, that extended from the front of the pedal and up over the toe of your shoes to keep your feet connected to the pedals and to prevent them from slipping off the front. When the first clip-in SPD pedals came about, they didn’t have a toe clip and became known as “clipless” as a result. So, the term clipless is undoubtedly confusing given that you clip in to a clipless pedal. These days, many shoes have the words “clip” or “clip-in” added to the name, which is a little more clear.

Related Content

The post The Best Women’s Mountain Bike Shoes of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
349454
The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024 https://bikerumor.com/best-mountain-bike-hip-packs/ Thu, 21 Dec 2023 01:10:06 +0000 https://bikerumor.com/?p=348008 These days, we’ve got a lot of options for carrying the necessities with us on our rides, but mountain bike hip packs are easily one…

The post The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
MTB hip packs lead image

These days, we’ve got a lot of options for carrying the necessities with us on our rides, but mountain bike hip packs are easily one of the best. Tools, tubes, water, food, first aid, layers, keys, and even our phones all need to go somewhere, and hip packs are an excellent way to hold it all conveniently strapped around your waist.

Hip packs have steadily evolved over the years into a specialized accessory for the modern mountain biker. Whether you prefer to carry water in hydration bladders or bottles, you carry the bare minimum of tools and gear, or bring everything but the kitchen sink, there are hip packs designed to suit every need and preference. From minimalist packs for quick backyard laps to cavernous models for all-day epics, and everything in between, there are more great options than ever before.

With so many mountain bike hip packs to choose from, finding the right one can be a challenge. To help navigate the choices, we rounded up a diverse selection of 11 models for side-by-side testing and comparison. We loaded each pack up with water, tools, and gear to assess their cargo capacity, hydration capabilities, and organizational layouts before hitting the trails to analyze their comfort, stability, and performance while riding.

Our top mountain bike hip pack recommendations are listed below, followed by the best of the rest which are also great options that are worthy of consideration. You can check our comparison chart to see all the models we tested and their specs at a glance. Our buying advice has helpful information that can help you decide what you need, and our FAQ section provides answers to some common questions.

The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024


Best Overall Mountain Bike Hip Pack (with bladder)

Evoc Hip Pack Pro 3L + 1.5L Bladder

Specs

  • MSRP $135
  • Weight 431 grams (w/o bladder) 562 grams (w/ bladder)
  • Capacity 3 liters
  • Water Bladder Yes, 1.5L
  • Water Bottles Yes, up to 2
  • Waist Sizes 31" to 43"
Product Badge The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024

Pros

  • Excellent stability
  • Stretch waist belt is comfortable
  • Well ventilated back panel
  • Great organization
  • Medium volume is great for most rides
  • Options to carry water in bladder or bottle (or both)

Cons

  • Expensive
  • 3 liter storage capacity may be too small for longer rides or people who like to carry lots of gear
Best Budget Mountain Bike Hip Pack (no bladder)

Patagonia Dirt Roamer Bike Waist Pack 3L

Specs

  • MSRP $69
  • Weight 245 grams
  • Capacity 3 liters
  • Water Bladder No
  • Water Bottles Yes, 2
  • Waist Sizes 27" to 46"
The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024

Pros

  • Lightweight
  • Secure and stable with or without bottles
  • Comfortable
  • External straps allow easy mounting of bulkier items
  • Surprisingly large capacity from smart layout

Cons

  • No water bladder (could be a pro depending on preference)
Best Budget Mountain Bike Hip Pack (with bladder)

Osprey Seral 4

Specs

  • MSRP $90
  • Weight 442 grams (w/ bladder)
  • Capacity 4 liters
  • Water Bladder Yes, 1.5L
  • Water Bottles No
  • Waist Size 27” to 42”
The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024

Pros

  • Great airflow through mesh hips and “Airscape” back panel
  • Simple bladder and routing makes refills quick
  • Adjustable nozzle speed
  • Bladder “handle” is a nice touch, makes filling and installing the bladder very easy.
  • Easy to find old colors on sale at a discount

Cons

  • Simple layout – there is really only one main section with a zippered internal pocket
  • No hip pockets
Runner-Up Best Mountain Bike Hip Pack (with bladder)

USWE Zulo 6

Specs

  • Price $145
  • Weight 510 grams (w/ bladder)
  • Capacity 6 liters
  • Water Bladder Yes, 1.5L
  • Water Bottles No
  • Waist Sizes 31” to 40”
The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024

Pros

  • Full length padded belt
  • Zip pockets on waist belt for easy access while riding
  • Comfortable
  • Excellent stability while riding

Cons

  • More expensive
  • Bladder is a tight fit to get into pack when full
  • Heavy branding
Best Minimalist Mountain Bike Hip Pack (no bladder)

Bontrager Rapid Pack

Specs

  • MSRP $68
  • Weight 216 grams
  • Capacity 1.64 liters
  • Water Bladder No (bladder version available)
  • Water Bottles Yes, 1
  • Waist Sizes 24" to 42"
The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024

Pros

  • Effective minimalist approach, enough room for the essentials
  • Tightening strap by pulling forward makes extra waist webbing management easy
  • Incredibly stable and comfortable – you hardly notice you’re wearing it
  • Lightweight

Cons

  • Not great for carrying larger, bulkier, or longer items
  • Lower overall capacity – not the best for longer rides or large items
Most Organized Mountain Bike Hip Pack (with bladder)

Thule Rail 4

Specs

  • MSRP $100
  • Weight 532g (w/ bladder)
  • Capacity 4 liters
  • Water Bladder Yes, 1.5L
  • Water Bottles No, not securely
  • Waist Size 31” to 40”
The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024

Pros

  • Thick, comfortable waistband
  • Long magnetic strip catches hydration hose and nozzle well
  • Good organizational strategy, if you use it as intended
  • Very streamlined and tidy look

Cons

  • Layout and low profile design makes capacity feel smaller than it is, very structured and not very flexible
  • Friction fitting on hose/bladder connection – challenging to remove bladder from pack
Best Mountain Bike Hip Pack for Carrying Capacity

Deuter Pulse Pro 5

Specs

  • MSRP $125
  • Weight 710 grams (w/ bladder)
  • Capacity 5 liters
  • Water Bladder Yes, 1.5L
  • Water Bottles Yes, 1
  • Waist Size 25” to 42”
The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024

Pros

  • High usable volume
  • Stowable strap included for attaching items externally
  • Comfortable back contact and wide hip band
  • Quick connect hose makes filling/cleaning bladder easy
  • Rotational nozzle lock works very well

Cons

  • Not the most stable hip pack for aggressive riding or rough terrain
  • Not the easiest pack to put on/take off quickly with the mesh/velcro belt
  • Heavier weight

Best of the Rest

EVOC Hip Pack 3L + 1.5L Bladder

Specs

  • MSRP $120
  • Weight 495 grams (w/ bladder)
  • Capacity 3 liters
  • Water Bladder Yes, 1.5L
  • Water Bottles No
  • Waist Size 30” to 48”
The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024

Pros

  • Well ventilated back panel
  • Stable
  • Great bladder management and quick release bladder/hose connection
  • Well organized

Cons

  • Small hip pockets
  • No water bottle carry option
  • Difficult to tighten straps when the pack is on

PNW Rover Hip Pack

Specs

  • MSRP $79
  • Weight 387 grams
  • Capacity 2.72 liters
  • Water Bladder No
  • Water Bottles Yes, with detachable bottle holder (up to 2)
  • Waist Sizes 24" to 48"
The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024

Pros

  • Middle of the road capacity, large compartment is roomy enough for everything we usually needed
  • Good main pocket compartmentalization
  • Fairly water resistant with neoprene lined phone pocket
  • Soft backing, comfortable and secure
  • Good value

Cons

  • Detachable water bottle pockets are not the most stable while riding

Dakine Hot Laps 5L

Specs

  • MSRP $100
  • Weight 460 grams (w/ bladder)
  • Capacity 5 liters
  • Water Bladder Yes, 2L
  • Water Bottles No
  • Waist Sizes Not specified
The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024

Pros

  • 2 liters of water storage
  • External straps for knee pads or extra layer
  • Lots of color options
  • Fleece lined pocket on belt fits phone
  • Less expensive than many other models that come with bladders

Cons

  • Doesn't hold shape well when fully packed
  • Full water bladder takes up quite a bit of the storage space

Fox Standard Hip Pack

Specs

  • MSRP $70
  • Weight 370 grams
  • Capacity 2 liters
  • Water Bladder No
  • Water Bottles Yes, up to 2
  • Waist Sizes Not specified
The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024

Pros

  • Minimal design for carrying just the essentials
  • Good waist strap management
  • Bottle sleeves compress when not in use for streamlined look
  • Stable – even with 2 full bottles

Cons

  • No pockets on waist band
  • Small capacity – best for shorter rides and warmer temps
  • Only comes in black

Comparison Chart

Hip Pack ModelMSRPWeightStorage CapacityBladderBottlesWaist Size Range
Evoc Hip Pack Pro 3L + 1.5L Bladder$135562g (w/ bladder)3 litersYes, 1.5L (also sold without)231″ to 43″
Patagonia Dirt Roamer Waist Pack 3L$69245g3 litersNo227″ to 46″
Osprey Seral 4$90442g (w/ bladder)4 litersYes, 1.5LNo27″ to 42″
USWE Zulo 6$145510g (w/ bladder)6 litersYes, 1.5LNo31″ to 40″
Bontrager Rapid Pack$68216g1.64 litersNo (bladder version offered)124″ to 42″
Thule Rail 4$100532g (w/bladder)4 litersYes, 1.5LNo31″ to 40″
Deuter Pulse Pro 5$125710g (w/ bladder)5 litersYes, 1.5L125″ to 42″
Evoc Hip Pack 3L + 15L Bladder$120495g (w/ bladder)3 litersYes, 1.5LNo30″ to 48″
PNW Rover Hip Pack$79387g2.72 litersNo1 (up to 2)24″ to 48″
Dakine Hot Laps 5L$100460g (w/ bladder)5 litersYes, 2LNoNot specified
Fox Standard Hip Pack$70370g2 litersNo2Not specified

Why You Should Trust Us

At Bikerumor, we love riding bikes, and one of the key elements of enjoyable bike rides is being prepared. Carrying the necessary tools to handle mid-ride mechanicals, enough water for the duration of the ride, adequate food to keep the energy up, and the appropriate layers for the weather, are all important things that can make or break the experience. Hip packs are one of our favorite ways to carry all the necessities, and we’ve been riding in them for years. While there are now more ways than ever to stash gear on our bikes, in cargo bibs, or backpacks, we still gravitate towards hip packs for their comfort, stability, convenience, and ease of use.

For this buyer’s guide, review authors Paul Clauss and Jeremy Benson personally tested the 11 hip pack models chosen for this review. Clauss is an avid trail rider, mountain bike coach, and trail builder who lives in northern Vermont. He’s been riding for many years and has a great appreciation for any gear that helps to enhance his performance and elevate his experience out on the trails. A mechanical engineer by trade, Clauss is particularly critical of the design and construction and he brings a very measured and logical approach to product testing. In addition to testing hip packs, Paul has tested and reviewed numerous other categories of gear including dropper posts, bike pumps, flat pedals, and the best flat pedal shoes.

Benson has been professionally testing and reviewing mountain bikes, components, apparel, and accessories for over seven years. He is an obsessive rider who spends an inordinate amount of time on mountain and gravel bikes training for races, riding for fun, and testing new gear. He’s been riding in mountain bike hip packs for the past decade and has seen them evolve from their humble beginnings into their more advanced forms. In that time, he’s personally owned five different hip packs and tested over 20 different models. As a full-time product tester, he is constantly scrutinizing every piece of gear he touches to tease out the performance differences that separate the best from the rest, whether that’s hip packs, the latest mountain bike shoes, or a hitch bike rack.

How We Tested

After researching the best mountain bike hip packs on the market, we rounded up 11 models to test and compare. Each model was weighed before examining their design, materials, and construction to assess the build quality and storage layout. Then, we loaded them up with all of the tools, gear, water, and food we could fit and hit the trails. While riding, we considered the fit, comfort, stability, and ventilation of each model when used with a full load on trails ranging from smooth and flowy to rough and rowdy. On rides ranging from quick laps at the local trail centers to all-day suffer-fests, we used and abused each model just like anyone else would. We got familiar with each model’s storage capabilities and hydration systems by filling and cleaning bladders and drinking from hoses and bottles. After months of testing, we compared notes and zeroed in on our favorites and those that perform well in specific ways compared to the rest.

Paul Clauss testing the USWE Zulo 6 hip pack
Tester Paul Clauss taking a break while out testing the USWE Zulo 6 hip pack. (photo/Paul Clauss)

Buying Advice: How to Choose a Mountain Bike Hip Pack

Hip packs, also known as fanny packs, lumbar packs, and waist bags, have had a resurgence in popularity in the mountain bike world in the past decade or so. What was previously a fairly non-technical accessory used primarily by tourists on vacation has developed into a relatively specialized piece of equipment that many riders rely on to carry the necessary tools, snacks, water, and other gear out on the trail. Hip packs represent a happy middle ground between the minimalist on-bike and body approach and a larger backpack, the latter of which can be sweaty, uncomfortable, and bounce around when riding technical terrain. And, if you’re looking for other ways to carry essentials on your rides, we’ve tested and reviewed the best handlebar bags too.

Carrying the hydration, food, and tools you need to keep riding in the event of a mechanical and to meet your basic human needs in a way that does not interfere with cycling movement is a classic challenge for mountain bikers and one that hip packs aim to overcome. Compared to most backpacks, hip packs are generally more stable, relatively small so they cover less of your back, and are worn around the waist so weight is lower on your body. They can also usually carry more water and gear than most people are able to strap to their bikes or stuff into pockets.

With so many hip packs on the market these days with different styles, designs, cargo capacities, and hydration systems, finding the right one to suit your needs can be a challenge. For such a seemingly simple product, there’s a lot to consider when deciding what’s right for you. We’ll break down the important factors to consider when making a purchase decision.

Cargo capacities vary from sleek, low-volume packs like the Bontrager Rapid Pack, or even smaller, to much larger bladder equipped models. (photo/Paul Clauss)

Cargo Capacity

Mountain bike hip packs vary pretty dramatically in their cargo-carrying capacity with models made to suit just about every need or preference. The capacity is typically measured in liters with super slim, minimalist, race-belt style packs starting around 1 liter, and high-volume models topping out around 7 liters plus a 1.5 or 2-liter water bladder. We tested 11 different hip packs ranging from 1.6 to 6-liter capacity, with the Bontrager Rapid Pack as the smallest and the USWE Zulo 6L as the largest. The right capacity for you depends on what you plan to carry.

If you just need the essentials – your keys, phone, wallet, a tube, multi-tool, water (in a bottle or bladder), and some CO2 – any of these packs will work with space to spare, with the Bontrager Rapid Pack being the most streamlined option at 1.64-liter capacity, followed closely by the 2-liter Fox Standard Pack. If you’d like a little more flexibility to carry additional food and some bulkier items like a mini-pump or a super-packable layer, models in the 3 to 4-liter range, like the PNW Rover, Evoc Hip Pack Pro 3L, Osprey Seral 4, Thule Rail 4, or Patagonia Dirt Roamer are good choices. And, if you’re a heavy packer, going for a long ride, or heading out in variable weather, packs with 5+ liters of capacity will be easier to stuff with packable jackets and larger food items. The largest packs we tested are the Deuter Pulse Pro 5, the USWE Zulo 6, and the Dakine Hot Laps 5L.

The Deuter Pulse Pro 5 loaded up to show its capacity
Larger capacity packs like the Deuter Pulse Pro 5 are much easier to load with more gear along with the 1.5-liter bladder and even an extra bottle. (photo/Paul Clauss)

It’s also important to note that most of the packs we tested feature highly usable compression straps, allowing the pack to be compressed when not fully loaded or to keep the load compact to prevent the contents from bouncing around inside. Compression straps can effectively decrease the volume of a larger pack, making it usable for rides when you need a lot of gear and those when you don’t.

And, despite our high priase of hip packs, sometimes even the largest models aren’t quite big enough for some people’s needs. Perhaps you’re going out for a huge adventure into the alpine where you need to bring a jacket, layers, and extra food, or maybe an overnight bikepacking trip? Situations like these may require significantly more cargo capacity, and backpacks might simply be a better option. Bike specific backpacks come in a huge range of sizes and designs to meet vary needs, far more even than hip packs. Deuter, for example, makes 12 different models of bike backpacks ranging in cargo capacity from 8 up to 30 liters.

Looking inside the storage compartment of the Osprey Seral 4
Storage layouts vary from super simple designs like the Osprey Seral 4 seen here to those with multiple compartments and organizational pockets. (photo/Paul Clauss)

Storage Layout

Nearly as important as the capacity, the storage layout of a pack dictates the organization of your gear and how you can use the space. Some packs, like the Osprey Seral 4, take a very simple approach, with a single large compartment with a zippered pocket within. Others, like the Deuter Pulse Pro 5 and Thule Rail 4, are highly compartmentalized, with separate zippered and open organization pockets and larger open sections. The split design of the Bontrager Rapid Pack, and its small capacity, make it difficult to carry larger items in, while the more open designs of packs like the Patagonia Dirt Roamer or PNW Rover make it easier to stuff bulkier items into them. 

If you want to separate your food from your tools or keep your phone screen safe from scratches while riding, a more compartmentalized design might work for you. Some of the more organization-heavy designs rely on the user storing tools and other items in their separate pockets to get the most out of the space. It may take some getting used to, but once you’ve got your system, everything can have its place and be quick and easy to find when you need it. If you want a bag to toss the essentials into, zip up, and forget it, simpler layouts may suit you just fine. Like capacity, layout depends on what you need to carry and how you prefer to organize it.

Some of the storage layout and organizational pockets of the USWE Zulo 6
Packs like the Zulo 6 and many others feature organizational pockets to keep your items separated and easy to find. (photo/Paul Clauss)

Pockets on the hip wings of the waist belt are another factor to consider. Many packs have them, and they can be very handy to keep smaller items that you want to access on the fly without having to spin the bag around to the front. These vary in size, but most are good for smaller items like keys, gels, chapstick, or credit card/ID, while a few are capable of fitting a smartphone. Additionally, a few models, like the Dakine Hot Laps 5L, Deuter Pulse Pro 5, and the Patagonia Dirt Roamer, have external strap systems that can be used to attach bulkier items like knee pads or a jacket to the outside of the pack for extra carrying capacity.

Hydration Style

Most mountain bike hip packs provide the ability to carry extra water in additional water bottles, water bladders, and sometimes both. Like the overall capacity of the pack, the right water capacity depends on how much you drink and the duration of your ride. Having more water than you need is always better than not having enough. Of the packs we tested, 4 of them carry water in bottles only, 7 of them carry water in water bladders, and 2 of the models with bladders can carry an additional bottle or two. What works best for you is typically a matter of personal preference.

The Patagonia Dirt Roamer hip pack with 2 bottles
Some packs, like the Patagonia Dirt Roamer shown here, carry water comfortably and securely in bottles. (photo/Paul Clauss)

Bottles

The bottle-carry models can usually handle one or two 20 to 25-oz bottles, which may be more than enough for your needs, especially if you’ve already got a bottle on the bike. Both the Fox Standard Hip Pack and the Patagonia Dirt Roamer can carry two bottles in sleeves on either side of the storage compartment. The PNW Rover comes with one detachable bottle holder, and you can add a second if you need to. The Bontrager Rapid Pack can only carry one bottle, but it does so very securely in the center of the pack between the storage pockets.

Compared to hydration bladders, bottles are super easy to fill and clean. For those packs that can carry two bottles, you can almost get the same amount of water capacity as a pack with a 1.5-liter bladder. For most of these packs, it’s also pretty easy to reach back and pull the bottles out of the pack for drinking, but not quite as easy as reaching a hose up to your mouth while riding. And, while most bottle holders are quite secure, there is the chance they could bounce out over super rough terrain or in a crash.

The winged water bladder of the Deuter Pulse Pro 5 hip pack
Many packs carry water conveniently in a hydration bladder inside the pack with a hose and nozzle for easy drinking, like the Deuter Pulse Pro 5. (photo/Paul Clauss)

Bladder

Of the bladder-equipped packs we tested, six of them, the USWE Zulo 6, both Evoc models, the Deuter Pulse Pro 5, Thule Rail 4, and the Osprey Seral 4, come with a 1.5-liter bladder (50.7 oz). The Dakine Hot Laps 5L comes with a 2-liter (70 oz) bladder. Additionally, the Evoc Hip Pack Pro 3L can carry two bottles and the Deuter Pulse Pro 5 can carry one. Any of these packs should carry enough water for 2-3 hour long rides, or longer, depending on the temperature and your personal rate of consumption.

the magnetic hose connection on the Thule Rail 4
The convenience of drinking from a hose is one of the biggest advantages of hydration bladders. The Thule Rail 4 has a unique magnetic strip connection that works super well. (photo/Paul Clauss)

There are some advantages to bladder-style hip packs. Drinking from them is super easy and convenient. The hoses and nozzles are located on the waist belt, and reaching down and grabbing it to drink is quick and easy and can usually be done while riding on smooth sections of trail. The bladders are also soft and squishy, so they conform to the shape of your back and other contents in your pack and can distribute water weight more evenly, which can enhance pack stability. Bladders are carried internally, so they should never fall out on a rough trail, and you’re unlikely to set it down and forget it on the side of the trail like you could with a bottle. The disadvantages of bladders are that they are slightly more cumbersome to fill and clean, and bacteria and mold can grow in the bladder/hose/nozzle if neglected. Some people just don’t like drinking from a hose, and the hoses can occasionally pop loose while riding, which can be annoying and potentially dangerous.

Waist Belts

While they all perform the task of securing a hip pack around the waist, there are two main styles of waist belts on the packs we tested. Most packs come with a more basic, adjustable, static webbing belt with a plastic clasp to secure it. The PNW Rover, Patagonia Dirt Roamer, Fox Standard, Bontrager Rapid Pack, Evo Hip Pack 3L, and Dakine Hot Laps 5L, all use this style of waist belt.

The waist belt on the PNW Rover hip pack
Most hip packs, like the PNW Rover pictured here, have a relatively standard style of waist belt with a broad, static webbing strap and large plastic buckle. (photo/Paul Clauss)

Other packs, typically the more expensive ones, have wide, overlapping velcro belts that also have a webbing strap and clasp over the top to secure it. This style of waist belt is found on packs like the Deuter Pulse Pro 5, Evoc Hip Pack Pro 3L, Thule Rail 4, and USWE Zulo 6. Realistically, both styles work quite well and give little to complain about, but the softer, wider, overlapping models tend to be a little more comfortable, stable, and they distribute the weight of a loaded pack a little more evenly around the waist. The flip side is that they are a bit more finicky to put on, as you have to line up the overlapping straps before securing the buckle on top. Regardless, it isn’t that much of a hassle, and the added comfort and stability are generally worth the few extra seconds it takes to put them on.

The wide, overlapping waist belt of the USWE Zulo 6 hip pack
Several models of hip packs, like the USWE Zulo 6 and others, feature an extra wide, overlapping waist belt which is super comfortable and makes for a very stable pack. (photo/Paul Clauss)

Both styles of belts are adjustable to fit a range of waist sizes and keep them snug when in use. The designs vary somewhat, of course, but most are reasonably easy to adjust and stay secure while riding. The recommended waist size ranges also vary among the models we tested with some models like the Thule Rail 4 and USWE Zulo 6 fitting waists between 31 and 40 inches compared to the PNW Rover which is claimed to work for waists between 24 and 48 inches.

Ventilation

Compared to hydration backpacks, hip packs cover only a small portion of your back and are inherently better for staying cool and managing sweat. That said, they still make contact with your lower back where it can become quite hot and sweaty. Almost every hip pack makes some attempt at managing moisture where the pack makes contact with your body through the use of breathable mesh materials or more advanced ventilation systems, but they are not created equal.

The two Evoc packs, the Hip Pack Pro 3L and the Hip Pack 3L have by far the best ventilation among the models we tested with their Air Flow Contact System. The back panels feature raised, channeled foam blocks that are covered in an open mesh material that allows for superior breathability. Additionally, the Venti-Flap system allows the user to quickly loosen the upper part of the pack and create a gap between your back during climbs or other times you want to increase airflow, then quickly cinch it back down for the descents. The rest of the models we tested do a commendable job of promoting breathability and are generally much cooler and less sweaty than wearing a full-on backpack.

Group shot of many of the packs we tested for the mtb packs buyers guide
The packs we tested vary in retail price from $68 up to $145, and all of them are solid options to carry your essentials out on the trails. (photo/Paul Clauss)

Value

Like anything else in mountain biking, hip packs vary pretty widely in terms of price. The more basic designs and those that carry bottles tend to cost a bit less. When you add a water bladder or fancier waist belt, the price goes up a bit. Of the models we tested, the $69 Patagonia Dirt Roamer strikes us as the best value, and it happens to be our favorite bottle-carry pack too. Other models at the low end of our price range are the Bontrager Rapid Pack ($68), the Fox Standard Hip Pack ($70), and the PNW Rover ($79). That said, we also highly recommend the more expensive models, like the Evo Hip Pack Pro 3L and the USWE Zulo 6, for their excellent comfort, stability, and ease of drinking while riding. Even though they are more expensive, you should expect to get several years of use out of them, assuming you don’t shred them in a crash or something. In fact, all of these packs should deliver years of faithful service under normal use.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why should I get a hip pack for mountain biking?

Hip packs are one of several ways to bring your hydration and gear with you while you ride, and arguably one of the best. They allow you to bring more water, tools, and other gear than you can typically carry on your bike and in your pockets, so you can be well prepared for whatever you’ve got planned and most mechanicals that may happen along the way. They also keep everything in arms reach for convenient access, and most feature organizational pockets so your tools and other items are quick and easy to find when you need them.

Depending on what you need to carry while you ride, you can choose from hip packs with varying storage and water-carrying capacities to suit your specific needs. Many hip packs are also fairly adaptable and can carry lighter or heavier loads depending on the length of ride. Some of them can even fit about as much as many hydration backpacks. Compared to backpacks, however, hydration packs sit just above the waist on your lower back for a lower center of gravity, better weight distribution, and stability. They also cover significantly less of your back, allowing for better breathability and sweat management.

What size mountain bike hip pack should I get?

It really depends on what you want to bring with you on a ride. Taking stock of all the things you need to carry – water, tools (multi-tool, pump/CO2, tube, tire levers, tubeless plugs, etc), food, phone, wallet (or money/card and ID), extra layers, pads, etc. – should give you a rough idea of the size pack you’ll need to fit it all into. And, it’s also important to consider that what you carry on rides may vary based on the length of ride or the season.

Those who carry a water bottle on the bike and bring the bare minimum with them on rides may prefer a low-volume and low-profile option like the Bontrager Rapid Pack or Fox Standard Hip Pack. Most people will likely find the sweet spot in the medium-volume packs in the 3 to 4-liter capacity range, like the Evoc Hip Pack Pro 3L, the Thule Rail 4, and the Patagonia Dirt Roamer. Others who like to bring more on their rides, or who just like the option to do so, will be well served by looking at some of the larger capacity packs like the USWE Zulo 6L or the Deuter Pulse Pro 5. Again, it really just depends on the length of your rides and what you want to have with you out on the trail.

What’s better, a water bladder or water bottles?

With the variety of hip packs on the market today, you can choose between models that carry water in a bladder, bottles, or both, or some that don’t carry any water at all. What works best for you really comes down to personal preference or your water-carrying needs, as both systems work quite well. Water bladders carry up to 1.5 or 2 liters of water, have a clean look inside of the pack, conform to shape easily for comfort against the back or cramming things in a pack around them, and allow for easy drinking (even while riding) from a hose. That said, water bladders are a little more annoying to clean.

Bottles are also quite easy to drink from and far easier to clean than bladders. Their storage location varies on the hip packs we tested with some being super stable while riding and others moving around a bit on the back, but you’ve almost always got to reach around to grab them which is less convenient than the bladder systems. Either way, you can’t really go wrong, but considering your drinking preference and water-carrying capacity needs will likely steer you in one direction or the other.

How do I clean/care for my mountain bike hip pack?

Hip packs tend to get dirty from sweat or when riding in dusty or wet conditions. Their location on the lower back means they are placed right in line of fire from tire spray and they can get caked with mud. In general, they don’t need to be cleaned very often, and you can typically wipe off dirt or mud and let them dry out between rides. Eventually, though, you’ll need to wash them, and it is quite easy to spray them down with a hose or hand wash them in the kitchen sink and let them air dry. Some packs can also be washed in a washing machine, but you definitely want to look up and follow any manufacturer’s recommendations when washing your hip pack.

Even more important is cleaning the hydration system. Bacteria and mold can and do grow in the moist environment inside the bladder, hose, and nozzle, so keeping it clean is important for your health and the taste of your water. You can use dish soap, brushes, and/or cleaning tablets to get through the hose and inside the bladder. You can also use baking soda, lemon juice, bleach, or even denture cleaning tablets to kill bacteria. And, be sure to let everything dry before using it again. There are lots of helpful tips that can be found online if you are unsure how to go about cleaning your hydration system. Whatever technique you use, be sure to clean your water bladder, hose, and nozzle regularly. Most bladders are not dishwasher safe – again, check with the manufacturer before using the dishwasher.

Can I shorten the hose on water bladder packs?

Yes! Pretty much any hydration hose can be shortened to your desired length. You can do this by pulling out the nozzle piece, cutting the hose to length with a sharp pair of scissors or a knife, and pressing the nozzle piece back in.

Related Content

The post The Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
348008
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024 https://bikerumor.com/best-winter-cycling-gloves/ Mon, 11 Dec 2023 20:56:32 +0000 https://bikerumor.com/?p=347798 When the temperatures drop or the weather is foul, the right pair of winter cycling gloves are an essential piece of riding kit to keep…

The post The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
Winter cycling gloves lead image

When the temperatures drop or the weather is foul, the right pair of winter cycling gloves are an essential piece of riding kit to keep your hands warm and comfortable. Thankfully, there is an enormous variety of options on the market to suit needs and preferences that vary as wildly as the fall, winter, and spring weather they are designed for.

Gloves for winter cycling vary dramatically in material, thickness, padding, and complexity of design. Depending on the climate, riding intensity and style, and sensitivity to cold, it can be challenging to find one pair of gloves that can protect the hands well on every ride throughout the colder months. Fortunately, there are models made to suit every temperature range, weather condition, and specific need. In fact, for something as simple as a glove, the amount of variety on the market is incredible.

To help navigate the choices, review author Bennett Shane spent months testing a diverse selection of 15 winter cycling gloves in a wide range of temperatures and weather conditions. From chilly autumn morning starts to drizzly and cold mountaintop summits, each pair was put through its paces to see how they perform in the real world, and most importantly, how they compare to each other.

Whether you need something thin and lightweight for riding in mild conditions, something insulated and waterproof for frigid training rides, or anything in between, our top recommendations are listed below, followed by the best of the rest which are all worthy options in their own right. You can check our comparison chart to see all of the models we tested at a glance, and our buying advice and FAQ section can help you decide what you need and provide answers to common questions.

Editor’s Note: This buyer’s guide was originally published on our sister site, GearJunkie.com, and was relocated to Bikerumor on Dec. 11, 2023.

The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024


Best Overall Winter Cycling Gloves

Castelli Espresso GT Glove

Specs

  • MSRP $120
  • Materials Gore-Tex liner, Primaloft Gold insulation
  • Waterproof Yes
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes XS – XXL
  • Works With Touchscreens No
  • Nose Wipe No
Product Badge The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Luxurious Interior
  • Balanced performance
  • Easy in/out
  • Excellent fit

Cons

  • More expensive
  • No nose wipe or touchscreen compatibility
Best Budget Winter Cycling Gloves

Showers Pass Crosspoint Knit Waterproof Gloves

Specs

  • MSRP $47
  • Material Knit exterior, waterproof-breathable Artex membrane, Coolmax moisture-wicking antibacterial knit lining
  • Waterproof Yes
  • Colors Black, Ice Blue, Neon Green, Safety Orange
  • Available Sizes S – XL
  • Works With Touchscreen No
  • Nose Wipe Not specifically, but the whole glove is basically a nose wipe
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • Light
  • Great for rain
  • Excellent grip
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Knit exterior can take on water over time
Best Winter Cycling Gloves For Mild Conditions

Ornot Merino Gloves

Specs

  • MSRP $39
  • Material 52% Nylon, 20% Merino, 20% Recycled Polyester, 7% Lycra, 1% Silver Ag
  • Waterproof No
  • Colors Bluebird, Charcoal
  • Available Sizes S – XL
  • Works With Touchscreens Yes
  • Nose Wipe Not technically, but the whole glove is basically a nose wipe
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Excellent fit
  • Grippy
  • Soft, not itchy
  • Smartphone-friendly fingers and thumb
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Not for wet conditions
  • Don't completely block wind
Best Cycling Gloves For Wet And Cold Days

Rapha Deep Winter Gloves

Specs

  • MSRP $190
  • Material Windproof nylon outer, breathable OutDry® membrane; Primaloft® insulation; Synthetic brushed suede
  • Waterproof Yes
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes XS – XL
  • Works With Touchscreens No
  • Nose Wipe Yes
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • Ready for the harshest days of winter
  • Built to last
  • Great interface with jacket cuffs to seal out the elements
  • Nose wipes on both thumbs

Cons

  • Can get clammy in warmer conditions
  • Expensive
Best Winter Cycling Gloves For Extreme Cold

Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lobster Evo

Specs

  • MSRP $95
  • Material AmFIB softshell fabric, Ax Suede Laredo palm, Primaloft Gold insulation
  • Waterproof No, highly water-resistant
  • Colors Black, Phantom/Olive
  • Available Sizes S – XXL
  • Works With Touchscreen Yes
  • Nose Wipe Yes
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Impenetrable cold weather protection
  • Excellent grip
  • Built to last
  • Affordable for what they are

Cons

  • Dexterity is quite limited
  • Only for use in cold conditions
Most Comfortable Winter Cycling Gloves

Sportful No Rain Gloves

Specs

  • MSRP $50
  • Material Back: 84% polyamide 16% elastane, Palm: 60% polyamide 40% polyurethane
  • Waterproof No, highly water resistant
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes XS – XXL
  • Works With Touchscreens No
  • Nose Wipe No
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Supremely comfortable
  • Work well in temperate winter conditions
  • Excellent grip on bars and hoods

Cons

  • Not completely waterproof
Best Winter Cycling Gloves For Dexterity

Rapha Merino Gloves

Specs

  • MSRP $75
  • Material Back: 38% merino wool, 62% nylon, Palm: polyester
  • Waterproof No
  • Colors Black/Carbon Grey, Dark Navy/Teal
  • Available Sizes XS – XL
  • Works With Touchscreen Yes
  • Nose Wipe Not technically, but the whole glove is basically a nose wipe
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Excellent fit
  • Grippy
  • Nice breathability
  • Not itchy
  • Smartphone-friendly fingers and thumb

Cons

  • Not for nasty conditions
  • Comparable options available for less

Best of the Rest

Assos Ultraz Winter Gloves

Specs

  • MSRP $135
  • Material Back: 85% Polyamide 15% Elastane Palm: 100% Polyamide
  • Waterproof No, highly water-resistant
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes XS – XL
  • Works With Touchscreen No
  • Nose Wipe No
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • Super warm
  • Handles light rains admirably

Cons

  • Sizing runs small
  • Expensive
  • Not great for steady rains

Sportful WS Essential 2 Gloves

Specs

  • MSRP $70
  • Material Gore-Tex Infinium back, synthetic palm, ThermoDrytex Plus wrist
  • Waterproof No
  • Colors Black, Cedar/Black, Beetle/Black, Blue Denim/Black, Black/Red
  • Available Sizes XS – XXL
  • Works With Touchscreens No
  • Nose Wipe Yes
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Versatile
  • Light
  • Warm

Cons

  • Doesn't work with touchscreens

Castelli Perfetto Light Glove

Specs

  • MSRP $60
  • Material 100% polyester
  • Waterproof No
  • Colors Black
  • Available sizes XS-XXL
  • Works With Touchscreens Yes
  • Nose Wipe No
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • Light
  • Handles light rain/spray well
  • Excellent grip

Cons

  • Cuff could be more substantial
  • Limited temperature bandwidth

Rapha Pro Team Winter Gloves

Specs

  • MSRP $110
  • Material 100% polyester
  • Waterproof No
  • Colors Black
  • Available sizes XS-XL
  • Works With Touchscreens Yes
  • Nose Wipe No
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • Great in cold conditions
  • Breathable
  • Excellent grip

Cons

  • Expensive
  • DWR treatment only good for light rain/spray

Pearl Izumi Cyclone Gel Gloves

Specs

  • MSRP $45
  • Material 3-layer softshell, Ax Suede palm
  • Waterproof No, water-resistant
  • Colors Black, Screaming Yellow
  • Available Sizes S-XXL
  • Works With Touchscreen Yes
  • Nose Wipe Yes
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • Light
  • Excellent grip
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Gel padding on palm may not be for everyone

Sportful Giara Thermal Gloves

Specs

  • MSRP $50
  • Material Back: 100% Polyester; Palm: 60% polyamide 40% polyurethane
  • Waterproof No, water-resistant
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes XS – XXL
  • Works With Touchscreen Yes
  • Nose Wipe Yes
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • Light
  • Excellent grip
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Not as warm as "thermal" suggests

Assos Spring Fall Gloves Evo

Specs

  • MSRP $80
  • Material Brushed textile, microfiber palm, foam padding
  • Waterproof No
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes XS – XXL
  • Works With Touchscreens Yes
  • Nose Wipe No
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Light
  • Great dexterity
  • Durable
  • Works with touchscreens

Cons

  • Not warm enough for proper cold conditions
  • Kinda expensive

Pearl Izumi Thermal Gloves

Specs

  • MSRP $30
  • Material Brushed thermal fabric, synthetic leather palm
  • Waterproof No
  • Colors Black, Arctic
  • Available Sizes XS – XXL
  • Works With Touchscreen Yes
  • Nose Wipe No
The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • Light
  • Excellent grip
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Not all that warm

Comparison Chart

Cycling Glove ModelMSRPMaterialsWaterproof?Best ForWorks with Touchscreens?
Castelli Espresso GT Glove$120Gore-Tex liner, PrimaLoft Gold insulationYesCold, WetNo
Showers Pass Crosspoint Knit Waterproof$47Knit exterior, Artex membrane, Coolmax liningYesCool, WetNo
Ornot Merino Gloves$3952% Nylon, 20% Merino, 20% Recycled Polyester, 7% Lycra, 1% Silver AgNoCoolYes
Rapha Deep Winter Gloves$190Nylon outer, Outdry membrane, PrimaLoft insulationYesCold, Very Cold, WetNo
Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lobster Evo$95AmFIB softshell fabric, Ax Suede palm, PrimaLoft GoldNo, highly water-resistantExtreme ColdYes
Sportful No Rain Gloves$50No Rain fabric: 84% polyamide 16% elastaneNo, highly water-resistantCool, WetYes
Rapha Merino Gloves$75Back: 38% merino wool, 62% nylon, Palm: polyesterNoCoolYes
Assos Ultraz Winter Gloves$135Back: 85% Polyamide/15% Elastane, Palm: 100% PolyamideNo, water-resistantColdNo
Sportful WS Essential 2 Gloves$70Gore-Tex Infinium, synthetic palm, ThermoDrytex Plus wristNo, water-resistantCoolYes
Castelli Perfetto Light Glove$60100% PolyesterNoCoolYes
Rapha Pro Team Winter Gloves$110100% PolyesterNoCool, ColdYes
Pearl Izumi Cyclone Gel Gloves$453-layer softshell, Ax Suede palmNoCoolYes
Sportful Giara Thermal Gloves$50100% Polyester back, 60% PA/40% PU palmNoCoolYes
Assos Spring Fall Gloves Evo$80Brushed textile, microfiber palm, foam paddingNo, water-resistantCoolYes
Pearl Izumi Thermal Gloves$30Brushed thermal fabric, synthetic leather palmNoCoolYes

Why You Should Trust Us

At Bikerumor, we truly enjoy riding outside and we don’t stop when the days get shorter, the temperature drops and the weather is less than ideal. Instead, we know that having the right gear can make riding through the fall, winter, and spring just as enjoyable as the warmer months of the year. In addition to gloves, other gear like bib tights, jackets, and cycling shoe covers can help you stay comfortable and elevate your ride experience while keeping you off the indoor trainer. We’re also very passionate about gear, and we’ve been reporting on and testing the latest and greatest products for well over a decade while providing trustworthy reviews to our readers.

For our winter cycling gloves buyer’s guide, we tapped review author Bennett Shane to test all of the gloves in this review. Bennett has been cycling for over 20 years, and while his racing days are behind him, he still rides obsessively for fitness, fun, and, of course, testing gear. Bennett is a year-round outdoor road cyclist who lives in Portland, Ore., where he experiences every weather condition imaginable and knows the importance of having the appropriate apparel and accessories to enhance his comfort and enjoyment on the bike when it’s cold and wet, which it often is.

Bennett also spent many years working for numerous prominent brands in the cycling industry which has given him a unique insight into materials, designs, constructions, and technologies across the spectrum of cycling products. His depth of knowledge is uncanny. His cycling, product testing, and industry experience combine to give him a keen ability to analyze the often subtle performance differences in the products he tests.

How We Tested Winter Cycling Gloves

After researching the best winter cycling gloves on the market, we rounded up a diverse selection of 15 models for side-by-side testing. Bennett closely examined the fit, materials, construction, design, and features before testing them for months in the highly variable fall weather of the Pacific Northwest. From crisp morning and evening rides to freezing cold and wet rides through the mountains, each pair was put through its paces in a range of temperatures and weather conditions.

While testing, Bennett carefully considered fit, comfort, bar feel, and warmth, along with wind and weather protection. Noses were wiped, touchscreens were touched, and wrist cuffs were analyzed for how well they interface with the best cycling jackets. When testing concluded, we chose our favorites overall and those that stood out for specific reasons compared to the rest.

Review author Bennett Shane testing winter cucling gloves
Review author Bennett Shane spent months testing winter cycling gloves in the variable weather of the Pacific Northwest; (photo/Bennett Shane)

Buying Advice: How to Choose Winter Cycling Gloves

With so many different winter cycling gloves on the market, finding the right pair to suit your needs perfectly can be a daunting task. One of the most important things to consider is the conditions you expect to encounter most often, as that will dictate what level of weather protection or insulation you will need. An individual’s sensitivity to cold and/or typical riding intensity are also important factors that may influence this decision.

Types of Winter Cycling Gloves

With so much variability in the weather and temperatures where cyclists live or choose to ride in, there are just as many different styles of winter cycling gloves to match. Of course, depending on the climate where you live, what you consider to be cold temperatures or miserable weather may vary as well. Sometimes a single model may have you covered, although for some people it may be necessary to invest in more than one pair to cover all your needs.

Close up image of the Castelli Perfetto Light winter cycling gloves
Sometimes it’s in the name. The Castelli Perfetto Light gloves are indeed a thin and light option for cool temperatures; (photo/Bennett Shane)

Cool Weather

Let’s face it, the vast majority of cyclists are heading out for fall, winter, and spring rides when the temperatures are cool, but not downright frigid. For cool but relatively mild temperatures in the 40° to 55° F range, there are lots of options to take the edge off the wind and provide a tiny bit of insulation to keep your digits warm while providing better dexterity, bar feel, and breathability than heavier, bulkier models. If you’re used to riding gloveless or in summer-weight gloves, it can be shocking just how much warmer a pair cool weather gloves can be.

Generally speaking, cool-weather gloves are thinner and lighter than beefier cold-weather options and typically consist of a light wind-blocking shell or possibly even have a knit construction. Some cool-weather gloves also feature water-resistant or waterproof membranes to keep rain or road spray from soaking your hands.

Wearing the Showers Pass Crosspoint Waterproof Knit winter cycling gloves
The Showers Pass Crosspoint Waterproof Knit gloves magically combine a super comfortable knit construction with a waterproof membrane; (photo/Bennett Shane)

Spring and fall rides and early mornings or brisk evenings are typically when these gloves are the most effective. Not surprisingly, gloves with Spring Fall or Light in the name usually fall into this category like the Assos Spring Fall Gloves Evo and the Castelli Perfetto Light. Similarly, gloves with knit constructions like the Ornot Merino, Rapha Merino, and the Shower Pass Crosspoint Knit Waterproof Gloves are light, dexterous, tactile, and very comfortable.

Wearing the Castelli Espresso GT winter cycling gloves
When temperatures are right around or just below freezing, an insulated glove like the Castelli Espresso GT keeps your hands warm and dry; (photo/Bennett Shane)

Cold Weather

When temperatures are hovering just above or just below freezing, it’s officially cold. For these conditions, gloves with insulation and wind-blocking materials are needed to fight the chill of the wind and maintain warmth around your hands. These gloves typically work well in the 20-40-degree range and some will also be waterproof or highly water resistant to protect against rain showers and road spray.

In general, cold weather gloves work well within their temperature range, though they can quickly become too warm if/when used in temperatures above that. While they typically try to balance warmth with breathability, the addition of insulation can sometimes make them trap moisture more than thinner cool weather models.

PrimaLoft is a commonly used type of insulation that is often found in cold-weather cycling gloves. The Castelli Espresso GT Glove is one such example that includes PrimaLoft Gold insulation along with a GORE-TEX membrane that aims to keep you both warm and dry in properly cold winter conditions.

Likewise, the Assos Ultraz Winter Gloves are warm enough for temperatures around the freezing mark without being bulky. They don’t pack the same level of weather protection as the aforementioned Castelli Espresso GT, but they work very well in the cold, dry conditions they’re designed for.

Close-up view of the Rapha Deep Winter winter cycling gloves
When it gets really cold, a glove like the Rapha Deep Winter, pictured here, or the Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lobster Evo is key to keeping the cold, wind, and wet from ruining your ride; (photo/Bennett Shane)

Extreme Cold

When it’s really cold and you absolutely must ride outside, having gloves that can keep your hands from freezing is absolutely critical for comfort and control. Gloves designed for extreme cold include insulation, wind- and weather-blocking material, and often have designs to enhance warmth or seal out the elements.

Though we didn’t test any two-piece gloves, some winter gloves will have a liner and outer glove that are separate pieces so you can layer up for extra protection or adjust as needed. Additionally, a separate, thin-liner glove can often be used with bulkier outer gloves to increase their warmth.

When it gets really cold, the Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lobster Evo is one of the gloves we’re happy to be wearing. With Primaloft insulation, a windproof and water-resistant AmFIB membrane, and the lobster-style design, these gloves keep your hands and fingers happy on bitterly cold days. S

imilarly, the Rapha Deep Winter Gloves are made to stand up to harsh conditions. With a wind and weatherproof Outdry membrane, Primaloft insulation, and a double cuff to seal around your jacket sleeve, these gloves keep both the cold and water at bay to keep you spinning when everyone is still at home.

Wearing the Sportful No Rain winter cycling gloves
For lots of riders, a highly water-resistant glove like the Sportful No Rain is a great option for handling light to moderate amounts of precipitation and road spray; (photo/Benett Shane)

Wet Weather

While most of us try to avoid riding in the rain, some people seem to revel in it or simply can’t avoid it if they want to ride outside. For most riders, however, rain is usually in the form of passing showers on unsettled weather days and the resulting road spray from wet roads. Either way, when you factor in cold temperatures with wet conditions, you’ve got a recipe for some very cold hands.

Keeping your hands dry will significantly increase your comfort and your hands’ ability to stay warm. There are many gloves designed to handle wet weather on the market, and they span across all of the above-mentioned temperature ranges. How brands approach this varies, however, with different materials and levels of water protection.

Some gloves are highly water-resistant, but not fully waterproof, and aim to balance breathability with enough weather protection for most wet situations short of riding in full-on rainstorms. These gloves will often use a wind-blocking and highly water-resistant membrane, like GORE-TEX Infinium, in their construction, like the Sportful Essential WS 2 gloves. Similarly, the Sportful No Rain Gloves use the brand’s No Rain water-repellent fabric to effectively defend against light to moderate rain and road spray.

Some gloves go all-in on wet weather protection with fully waterproof membranes to keep the water out. The Castelli Espresso GT Gloves are one such example that uses a Gore-Tex waterproof membrane to seal out water while still providing admirable breathability. Similarly, the Rapha Deep Winter Gloves employ an Outdry wind and waterproof membrane that works in roughly the same way.

Knit gloves are not typically associated with robust wet weather protection, but the Showers Pass Crosspoint Waterproof Knit Gloves turn that notion on its head. With a waterproof Artex membrane sandwiched between the knit outer and Coolmax liner, these gloves provide the comfort and fit of a knit glove with full protection from the rain.

Wearing the Rapha Merino winter cycling gloves
In addition to choosing the right gloves for the conditions, a good fit is critical for comfort and performance. Knit gloves, like the Rapha Merino, have a nice amount of stretch and a very accommodating and comfortable fit; (photo/Bennett Shane)

Fit

Like any other cycling apparel or accessory, getting gloves that fit well is important for comfort and performance. Gloves that fit well feel like an extension of our body and avoid being too tight and restrictive or too big and loose. Too big and there can be excess material that can bunch and irritate the skin or your hands can move around inside resulting in a reduction of control.

Having too much space inside an insulated glove can also have a negative impact on its ability to maintain warmth. Too small and gloves glove can feel constricting, potentially impacting dexterity, or worse, restricting blood flow that is critical to keeping your hands warm in cool conditions. We want our gloves to fit just right.

Most of us already know our glove size, so this is typically a fairly easy step in the process. For most gloves, you’ll simply want to go with your regular summer-weight gloves size and it should be a good fit. If you’re considering wearing a liner glove underneath a heavier glove, however, you may want to size up slightly to ensure there’s room to fit comfortably.

If you’re unsure of your size, most brands have detailed size charts that should help you figure it out with a few measurements. Of course, heading to a shop and trying gloves on is a surefire way to ensure you get the right fit.

Wearing the Assos Ultraz Winter cycling gloves
Extended cuffs, like those on the Assos Ultraz Winter Gloves, add protection for the wrists and fit nicely under the cuffs of cycling jacket sleeves to help seal out the elements; (photo/Bennett Shane)

Wrist Cuffs

When wearing winter cycling gloves, it often means that we’re also wearing a cycling jacket of some kind, and the wrist cuffs of most gloves are designed to integrate well with jackets. Most gloves have relatively low-profile wrist cuffs, and many are extended slightly up the wrist so that they slide under the cuff of a jacket sleeve to provide protection for the wrist where they meet. The wrist cuffs of the models we tested vary in design, however, with some being simple, stretchy, pull-on affairs while others may use a Velcro tab or zipper to open the cuff further to ease entry and exit.

What works best for you is often a matter of personal preference. A design that we really liked is the Castelli Espresso GT with a back-of-hand zipper that allows the gloves to open wide and get warm hands in and out super easily. Another is the Rapha Deep Winter Gloves with their double cuff design. A sung cuff wraps around the wrist with an outer shell cuff that can be used to sandwich the cuff of the jacket sleeve between them for a great seal.

Close up view of the silicone textured palms on the Sportful No Rain cycling gloves
Silicone texture on the palms of some gloves, such as the Sportful No Rain gloves pictured here, works to provide extra grip in the hoods and bars; (photo/Bennett Shane)

Palm

The palm of a cycling glove is important because it serves as the interface between our hands and our handlebars. Not only is this interface important for our control of the bike, but it also plays a role in our comfort. In general, we look for palms that provide excellent grip and a very direct, connected feel to the bars that is as similar as possible to the feel of not wearing gloves at all.

Good palm designs are articulated to the hand in the riding position and avoid bunching while being as thin as possible (within reason depending on the intended use) to transmit feedback and bar feel. Most palms are made from synthetic materials that mimic suede providing comfort for the hands and a good grip on the hoods or bars, and many models also feature silicone strips or patterns to add additional grip which may be welcome in wet conditions.

Some gloves also feature strategically placed padding with the goal of increasing comfort. Padding is a personal preference, and some riders seem to like it while others would rather have gloves without.

Close up of the touchscreen compatible fingertip of the Pearl Izumi Cyclone Gel gloves
The small panel of conductive material on the pointer finger of the Pearl Izumi Cyclone Gel Gloves allows you to do simple tasks on touchscreens; (photo/Bennett Shane)

Touchscreen Compatibility

Like it or not, touchscreens have become a major part of our lives. Whether on our smartphones or our cycling computers, touchscreens are everywhere and we can’t even seem to get away from them while we ride. Whether for navigation, responding to a text, taking a scenic or riding shot, or answering work emails mid-ride, being able to use a touchscreen without taking your gloves off is pretty nice.

Many gloves, but certainly not all, are designed to work with touchscreens through the use of conductive threads or conductive materials used on the tips of the pointer finger and thumb. How well these features actually work varies slightly, but most will allow you to perform simple tasks on screens with some performing better than others. One of the primary factors that influences the functionality is the thickness of the gloves themselves. The slimmer fitting and less bulky the fingers are, the easier it is to do things on a touchscreen, generally speaking.

The large, soft, nose wipe panels on the thumbs of the Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lobster Evo gloves is great when riding in the cold conditions these gloves are designed for; (photo/Bennett Shane)

Nose Wipe

When it’s cold outside, our noses are more likely to be runny and we still produce sweat when we’re putting in some effort, so a soft wipe for your nose and/or sweat is a nice feature on many models of gloves. These wipes are typically on the thumb of the gloves and are made from a soft, absorbent material. While a nose wipe isn’t a make-or-break feature, it is something that we’ve come to appreciate and prefer to have for riding in cool weather if possible.

Value

In the grand scheme of things, cycling gloves are relatively affordable compared to many of the other parts, apparel, and accessories we buy for this sport. Given the fact that riding in the cold, wet, or both can be miserable without a good pair of winter cycling gloves, we feel that it is generally money well spent.

Like anything else, you can spend a lot on a pair of cycling gloves, but you certainly don’t have to find something that will help enhance your cool weather or winter riding experience. Of course, more advanced materials, designs, and constructions drive the price up, and often the gloves made for the most extreme conditions cost the most. While some of our favorite models also happen to be the most expensive, like the Castelli Espresso GT and the Rapha Deep Winter gloves, there are other quality options that sell for a lot less and work quite well too.

Take, for example, the Showers Pass Crosspoint Waterproof Knit Gloves. These affordable gloves are not only super comfortable, but they’re waterproof and they retail for just $47. If you ride in relatively mild and dry conditions, then something like the Ornot Merino or the Pearl Izumi Thermal will do the trick for just $39 and $30, respectively.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need winter cycling gloves?

f you plan to ride in the fall, winter, and spring, or even brisk morning and evening rides in the summer, the answer is yes. As soon as you encounter temperatures below around 55° F, a good pair of winter cycling gloves will help to keep you warm, dry, or both, and keep you more comfortable while you ride.

And, while you can ride in any gloves you choose, we recommend cycling-specific gloves because they are designed for the task. Cycling gloves have special cuts, materials, and features that simply make them work better for road or gravel riding than other options.

Which winter cycling gloves are best for me?

The winter cycling gloves that are best for you depends entirely on the temperature and weather conditions that you’ll be experiencing. This depends on your tolerance for cold, climate, willingness to ride in wet conditions, and ride intensity. No single glove will be the ideal glove for everyone, so its important to be realistic about your fall, winter, and spring riding and find the glove (or gloves) that are best suited to your needs.

For some people, it may be a versatile option that hits the happy middle ground of warmth and weather protection, while for others it may be multiple gloves to cover the base for a wider range of conditions.

Should I get waterproof winter cycling gloves?

Whether or not you need fully waterproof gloves really depends on the conditions you expect to encounter while riding. If you intentionally go out and ride in steady rainstorms, then yes, absolutely, waterproof gloves are a necessity. If you’re like most people, however, who try to avoid that, then a water-resistant glove is often a better option that will handle the vast majority of light to moderate rains that we’re likely to encounter when the weather is unpredictable.

Do I need multiple pairs of winter cycling gloves?

For many people, having multiple pairs of winter cycling gloves is necessary to cover all of the different conditions they will encounter during the fall, winter, and spring. Cool-weather gloves for shoulder season rides, cold-weather gloves for the deep of winter, and wet-weather gloves for those days you just can’t bear to ride the indoor trainer again.

Not everyone will need multiple pairs of gloves, it really just depends on the conditions that you’re willing to go outside and ride in. For many people, a versatile glove like the Showers Pass Crosspoint Waterproof Knit or the Sportful Essential WS 2 gloves will work great for 99% of the cool-to-cold weather riding they do.

How much should I spend on winter cycling gloves?

Everyone’s budget is different, so there’s no right answer to how much you should spend on winter cycling gloves. The gloves you can afford are much better than none at all and better than spending more than you’re comfortably able to. But, it depends on your needs, as some of the more protective and warmer options simply cost more than lighter-weight and simpler gloves.

Even in the more niche, and typically more expensive, categories, you’ll find a wide range of prices, and even the more budget-friendly models will help you stay comfortable when you need to get outside and ride.

What other gear should I consider for riding in cold weather?

A good pair of cycling gloves is just one element of the cold-weather riding kit. For anyone dedicated to riding outside when the temperatures are cool or cold and the weather is unstable, there are several other pieces of apparel or accessories you may want to consider. Full-length cycling bib tights provide full leg coverage along with wind and weather protection and insulation in some cases. Cycling shoe covers are a great way to keep the cold, wind, and water from chilling the feet and a good cycling jacket can do the same for the upper body. Insulating base layers and mid-layers are also great for developing a layering system to handle your specific needs for warmth. A huge range of cycling caps are offered to protect your head and ears from the elements, and face covers and/or balaclavas are helpful to protect your face as well.

Related Content

The post The Best Winter Cycling Gloves of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
347798
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024 https://bikerumor.com/best-cycling-jackets/ Mon, 11 Dec 2023 20:20:56 +0000 https://bikerumor.com/?p=347576 A good road cycling jacket is a critical piece of kit for riding in cold or wet weather. Staying warm and dry while riding in…

The post The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
Cycling jackets lead image

A good road cycling jacket is a critical piece of kit for riding in cold or wet weather. Staying warm and dry while riding in the variable temperatures and weather conditions of the fall, winter, and spring can be tricky, but is essential for your comfort and enjoyment on the bike.

Keeping the upper body comfortable and functioning well in foul weather is a complex problem with many possible solutions. Looking at the diversity of cycling jackets available today, it’s clear that a number of variables must be weighed in order to find the best option for your riding. Rain and road spray, wind, and cold, as well as your own riding style and layering preferences all factor into how well any jacket will suit your needs.

To help, we gathered a diverse selection of 16 of the best cycling jackets on the market to test and compare. Review author, Bennett Shane, personally tested each model in the highly variable weather and temperatures of the Pacific Northwest while analyzing their fit, comfort, features, and performance in the real world.

Whether you need a light layer to block the wind, a waterproof jacket for rainy days, or something insulated to fight the cold, we’ve got recommendations to keep you rolling on the road. Our favorite cycling jackets are listed below, followed by the best of the rest which are also great options that are worthy of consideration. To see all the models we tested at a glance, check out our comparison chart. Our detailed buying advice covers important product considerations if you need help deciding what you need, and our FAQ section provides answers to common questions. And, if you’re a mountain biker, we’ve tested and reviewed the best mountain bike jackets too.

Editor’s Note: This review originally appeared on our sister site, GearJunkie.com, and was relocated to Bikerumor on Dec. 11, 2023.

The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024


Best Overall Winter Cycling Jacket

MAAP Training Winter Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $345.00
  • Materials DryTex TPU Membrane. Backing: 94% Polyester, 6% Spandex. Face: 78% Polyamide, 22% Spandex
  • Sizes Available XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL,
  • Weight 348g (M)
  • Waterproof Yes
Product Badge The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Uncompromised warmth
  • Looks great
  • Versatile enough for fall and spring, too

Cons

  • Expensive
Best Budget Cycling Wind Jacket

Castelli Squadra Stretch Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $70
  • Materials Ripstop Nylon
  • Sizes Available XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXXL
  • Weight 148g (M)
  • Waterproof No
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Aero fit
  • Very affordable
  • Lightweight
  • Packable

Cons

  • Super minimal
Best Cycling Jacket For Rain

Gorewear C5 Gore-Tex Shakedry 1985 Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $300
  • Materials 100% Polyamide with Gore-Tex Shakedry membrane
  • Sizes Available S, M, L, XL, XXL,
  • Weight 120g (M)
  • Waterproof Yes
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • 100% wind and waterpoof
  • Lightweight
  • Excellent breathability
  • Easy packability

Cons

  • Relatively expensive
Best Budget Cycling Jacket For Rain

Sportful Hot Pack No Rain Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $170
  • Materials MAIN FABRIC: 100% Polyamide with lightweight membrane
  • Sizes Available S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXXL
  • Weight 110g (M)
  • Waterproof Yes
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Excellent fit
  • No excess material to flap in the wind
  • Robust protection for all but the worst conditions
  • Easy packability

Cons

  • Not the most breathable
Best Insulated Cycling Jacket

7Mesh Freeflow Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $220
  • Materials 20d 100% nylon ripstop, Polartec® Alpha 60gsm
  • Sizes Available XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL,
  • Weight 157g (M)
  • Waterproof No
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Dialed fit
  • Luxurious warmth
  • Lightweight
  • Beautiful
  • Packable

Cons

  • Not designed for constant or heavy rainfall
  • Should have a two-way zipper
  • Pocket zipper requires a bit of finesse
Best Lightweight Cycling Jacket

Velocio Ultralight Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $209
  • Materials 100% Polyamide
  • Sizes Available XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXXL, XXXXL
  • Weight 70g (M)
  • Waterproof No
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Close-fitting
  • Breathable
  • Great color options
  • Durable surface

Cons

  • Expensive
Most Versatile Cycling Jacket

Ornot Magic Shell

Specs

  • MSRP $268
  • Materials Polartec® NeoShell®
  • Sizes Available S, M, L, XL, XXL,
  • Weight 255g (small)
  • Waterproof Yes (99%)
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Unrestricted freedom of movement
  • Lightweight
  • Versatile

Cons

  • None

Best of the Rest

Best Waterproof And Insulated Cycling Jacket

Rapha Pro Team Insulated Gore-Tex Rain Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $450
  • Materials Gore-Tex Paclite shell, 65gsm synthetic insulation
  • Sizes Available XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL,
  • Weight 275g (M)
  • Waterproof Yes
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Lightweight
  • Warm
  • Waterproof

Cons

  • Expensive is an understatement
Best Cycling Jacket For Mild And Dry Conditions

Assos Mille GTS Spring Fall Jacket C2

Specs

  • MSRP $290
  • Materials AIRBLOCK.88, RX EVO Light, 85% Polyester, 15% Elastane
  • Sizes Available XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXXL
  • Weight 230g (M)
  • Waterproof No
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Great freedom of movement
  • Lightweight
  • Versatile
  • Fits like a jersey

Cons

  • Not designed for moderate to heavy rainfall
  • Not intended for super cold temperatures
Most Comfortable Cycling Jacket

Castelli Alpha Doppio RoS Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $400
  • Materials Gore-Tex Infinium Windstopper 150, Polartec Alpha Direct insulating layer
  • Sizes Available XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXXL
  • Weight 415g (M)
  • Waterproof No, highly water-resistant
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Luxurious freedom of movement
  • Lightweight
  • Uncompromised warmth
  • Versatile

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Not built for constant rain or road spray
Breathable, Versatile, And A Solid value

Showers Pass Cloudburst Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $199
  • Materials 3-layer eliteAIR
  • Sizes Available XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXL
  • Weight 277g (M)
  • Waterproof Yes
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Exceptional breathability
  • Legitimately waterproof
  • Nice fit
  • Can be worn off the bike

Cons

  • None
Best Cycling Jacket For Racing

Castelli Perfetto RoS 2 Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $280
  • Materials Gore-Tex Infinium Windstopper
  • Sizes Available XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXL
  • Weight 278g (M)
  • Waterproof No, highly water-resistant
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Race-ready fit
  • Breathable
  • Ready for nasty conditions

Cons

  • Heat-bonded logos will eventually chip and peel
Another Great Waterproof Jacket

Pearl Izumi Pro Neoshell WxB Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $325
  • Materials Polartec NeoShell membrane, 100% polyester
  • Sizes available S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXL
  • Weight 278g (M)
  • Waterproof Yes
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Race-ready fit
  • Breathable
  • Ready for nasty conditions

Cons

  • No rear pocket
Insulated and Packable

POC Pro Thermal Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $200
  • Materials Lightweight windbreaking material with insulating panels
  • Sizes Available XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXL
  • Weight 331g (M)
  • Waterproof No
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Luxurious warmth
  • Easy packability

Cons

  • Fits a bit loose
  • Pocket zippers a bit tricky to operate

Sportful Total Comfort Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $300
  • Materials Polartec NeoShell®, Polartec Alpha®
  • Sizes Available S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXXL
  • Weight 304g (M)
  • Waterproof Yes
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Great freedom of movement
  • Lightweight
  • Super warm warmth
  • Surprisingly versatile

Cons

  • None

Pearl Izumi Attack Barrier Jacket

Specs

  • MSRP $90
  • Materials 100% recycled polyester
  • Sizes available S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXL
  • Weight 46 g (M)
  • Waterproof No
The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024

Pros

  • Light
  • Breathable
  • Reasonable price

Cons

  • Materials flaps a bit in the wind
  • Super basic

Comparison Chart

Cycling Jacket ModelMSRPMaterialsWeightWaterproof?Insulated?
MAAP Training Winter Jacket$345Polyester, polyamide, spandex w/ DryTex TPU membrane348g (M)YesLightly
Castelli Squadra Stretch Jacket$70Ripstop Nylon148g (M)NoNo
Gorewear C5 Gore-Tex Shakedry 1985$300100% Polyamide w/ Gore-Tex Shakedry membrane120g (M)YesNo
Sportful Hot Pack No Rain Jacket$170100% Polyamide with lightweight membrane110g (M)YesNo
7Mesh Freeflow Jacket$220Nylon ripstop shell, Polartec Alpha insulation157g (M)NoYes
Velocio Ultralight Jacket$209100% Polyamide70g (M)NoNo
Ornot Magic Shell$268Polartec NeoShell255g (S)Yes (99%)No
Rapha Pro Team Insulated Gore-Tex Rain Jacket$420Gore-Tex Paclite shell, 65gsm synthetic insulation275g (M)YesYes
Assos Mille GTS Spring Fall Jacket C2$290AIRBLOCK.88, RX EVO Light, 85% Polyester, 15% Elastane230g (M)NoNo
Castelli Alpha Doppio RoS Jacket$400Gore-Tex Infinium Windstopper, Polartec Alpha Direct415g (M)No, highly water-resistantYes
Showers Pass Cloudburst Jacket$1993-layer eliteAIR277g (M)YesNo
Castelli Perfetto RoS 2 Jacket$280Gore-Tex Infinium Windstopper278g (M)No, highly water-resistantNo
Pearl Izumi Pro Neoshell WxB Jacket$325Polartec NeoShell, 100% Polyester278g (M)YesNo
POC Pro Thermal Jacket
$200Lightweight windbreaking w/ insulating panels331g (M)NoYes
Sportful Total Comfort Jacket$300Polartec NeoShell, Polartec Alpha304g (M)YesYes
Pearl Izumi Attack Barrier Jacket$90100% recycled polyester46g (M)NoNo

Why You Should Trust Us

At Bikerumor, we don’t stop riding because the seasons change or the weather turns. Instead, we gear up and get out there. Whether we’re riding road, gravel, or mountain bikes, we know that having the right tools for the job is essential for our comfort and enjoyment while riding through the fall, winter, and spring. For road riding in particular, we’ve learned that the right cycling jacket can make the difference between a miserable ride and finishing with a smile on your face. And, a good jacket can keep us off the indoor trainer for longer, which is a huge plus.

For our cycling jackets buyer’s guide, we recruited Bennett Shane to test and compare all of the models in this review. Bennett has been road cycling for over two decades, and although his racing days are behind him, he still spends an inordinate amount of time on the bike for fitness, fun, and, of course, product testing. In addition to being an obsessive cyclist, Bennett has worked for numerous prominent brands in the cycling industry. This experience has given him unique insight into the design, materials, construction, and even the marketing of all types of road cycling gear. He has an impressive depth of cycling knowledge, and he stays abreast of the latest and greatest products and technology across all aspects of the sport. His knowledge of gear combined with his cycling and industry experience make him particularly adept at analyzing and identifying performance differences in the products he tests. In the past year, Bennett has been testing and reviewing a wide range of road cycling products for in-depth buyer’s guides including road bike shoes, road bike helmets, cycling bib tights, cycling bib shorts, pedals, saddles, and more.

After researching virtually every cycling jacket on the market, we rounded up a diverse selection of 16 models for side-by-side testing and comparison. After weighing each model for consistency and comparison to the manufacturer’s specs, we carefully examined their design, materials, construction, and features before hitting the road. The only way to truly test cycling jackets is by riding in them, so ride we did. Living near Portland, OR, Bennett is accustomed to riding in the full spectrum of weather conditions, and he spent months riding in these jackets on crisp fall mornings, misty and cold mountain rides, and full-on downpours. While riding he assessed the fit and comfort of each model along with how well they performed in varying temperature and weather conditions in the real world.

Testing cycling jackets in cold and damp conditions
Cool fall temperatures and wet roads make for some pretty ideal cycling jacket testing conditions. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Buying Advice: How to Choose a Cycling Jacket

With cycling jackets made for riding in different weather conditions, and temperatures with a range of different fits and features, finding the right one to suit your needs can be a challenge. Fortunately, with so many models to choose from, you should be able to find a model that has you covered for the vast majority of your off-season rides. One of the most important considerations is the weather and temperature conditions you expect to encounter as that will dictate whether you need a wind layer, waterproof jacket, insulation, or a combination of all three. Of course, you’ll also want to get the right fit, and factors like pockets and packability may also play a role. It is also worth mentioning that other cycling apparel like winter bib tights or accessories like winter cycling gloves and cycling shoe covers are critical components of the cool weather riding kit.

Types of Cycling Jackets

Considering the weather conditions and temperatures that you expect to encounter while riding will help you narrow down your choices when looking for a cycling jacket. Depending on where you live and ride, fall, winter, spring, and even crisp morning or evening rides in the summer, present a wide range of temperatures and weather, and there isn’t necessarily a one-jacket-fits-all solution. This is why there are literally hundreds of cycling jackets on the market ranging from light, packable wind shells to fully waterproof and insulated jackets, and everything in between. It is also worth noting that this review is specific to jackets that we’d recommend for road cycling, and we have tested and reviewed mountain bike jackets as well.

Wearing the lightweight and packable Castelli Squadra Stretch cycling jacket
While super simple, even lightweight and packable wind jackets like the Castelli Squadra Stretch Jacket do wonders to keep you warm by blocking the chill of the wind. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Wind

Wind is one of the main culprits that can cause you to get cold or uncomfortable while riding in cool conditions, no matter the season. Whether it’s a blustery day or from self-generated wind riding downhill, the chill of the wind will almost always make it feel colder than it is. They call it wind chill for a reason, after all. Virtually all cycling jackets, regardless of type, block the wind as one of their primary functions. For wind specifically, however, the lowly, but oh-so-functional, wind jacket is a critical piece of gear for most riders to keep you comfortable in dry conditions whether it’s a chilly ride in the fall, winter, or spring, or a mountain descent in the middle of summer.

Riding in damp and cool fall conditions in the Velocio Ultralight cycling jacket
Velocio’s apparel isn’t cheap, but it is consistently some of the best gear we test and the Ultralight Jacket quickly became a favorite. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Wind layers are typically relatively basic, consisting of a thin wind-blocking shell that creates a barrier between you and the moving air. Given the thin materials, they are often very lightweight and easily packable, making them easy to stash in a jersey pocket so you can be prepared for changing conditions and adjust your layering as needed throughout your ride. Wind jackets can also be surprisingly versatile and can keep you warm in temperatures ranging from mild to freezing depending on how you layer beneath them. Sometimes the materials used in wind jackets are treated with a DWR to repel very light amounts of moisture, and they are also typically very fast-drying should you sweat in them or ride through a light shower. We tested several wind jackets including the Castelli Squadra Stretch Jacket, the Pearl Izumi Attack Barrier Jacket, and the Velocio Ultralight Jacket.

Gore-Tex Infinium windproof and highly water resistant material
Many jackets, like the Castelli Perfetto RoS pictured here, use wind-blocking materials that are highly water-resistant, like Gore-Tex Infinium. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Water-Resistant

Most of us avoid riding in proper rainstorms, and it is much more likely that we’ll be caught in a passing storm, light showers, or mist when the weather is tolerable but unstable. For conditions like these, a water-resistant jacket is often a more comfortable choice than a fully waterproof model because fully waterproof materials often have limited stretch and breathability compared to water-resistant options. There are a number of materials and membranes on the market that are highly water resistant, though perhaps not fully waterproof, that do a wonderful job of blocking wind and repelling water from light to moderate showers and road spray.

Riding in the Ornot Magic Shell cycling jacket
It honestly feels like magic the way the Ornot Magic Shell adapts to changing conditions. This jacket really impressed us with its versatility. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Gore-Tex Infinium used in the Castelli Perfetto RoS 2 and Polartec Neoshell in the Ornot Magic Shell are two such membranes that are often used in cycling jackets that aim to provide a high level of water resistance to keep you dry in all but the most miserable of conditions. Generally speaking, the water repellency of water-resistant materials is aided by a durable water repellant (DWR) treatment to make water bead and shed at the surface.

Wearing the Rapha Pro Team Insulated Gore-Tex Rain Jacket
Expensive? Yes. Will it keep you dry and warm in the nastiest of conditions? Yes. The Rapha Pro Team Insulated Gore-Tex Rain Jacket is worth the price if you ride when it’s both cold and wet. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Waterproof

For riding in rainstorms, a fully waterproof jacket is key to keeping you dry and, therefore, warm. When you’re riding in steady rain, water-resistant materials can and will eventually be overwhelmed and water will make its way inside the jacket, so if you’re sure you’ll be encountering miserable conditions, then something completely waterproof is the way to go. In addition to a waterproof membrane, these types of jackets have taped seams and waterproof zippers to try and keep water from getting in anywhere as well as a DWR to bead and repel water at the surface. There are a variety of waterproof membranes and materials on the market like Gore-Tex Shakedry used on the Gorewear C5 Gore-Tex Shakedry 1985, Gore-Tex Paclite Plus for the Rapha Pro Team Insulated Gore-Tex Rain Jacket, and the DryTex TPU membrane incorporated in the MAAP Training Winter Jacket. Despite being different, they aim to block water while still allowing a reasonable level of breathability to help regulate moisture. In addition to the waterproof jackets included in this guide, our cycling rain jackets review has some other options.

Waterproof materials often come with ratings expressed in numbers like 10K/10K which refer to their water repellency and breathability, respectively. For water repellency, the rating refers to water column pressure, or how much water in pressure can be exerted on the fabric before it soaks through. So, for a 10K rating, this means that it can handle a column pressure of 10,000mm before it soaks through. The higher the number, the more waterproof the material, and vice versa. A 10K waterproof rating is typically the minimum we recommend. Breathability ratings measure a material’s ability to allow moisture vapor transmission and refer to the amount of moisture in grams that can pass through a square meter of material in a 24-hour period. Again, the higher the number, the better the breathability. For high-intensity activities, like cycling, the more breathable the material the better as moisture trapped within a jacket can be uncomfortable and cause you to get cold.

Riding in the Sportful Total Comfort insulated cycling jacket
Insulation in cycling jackets is often thin and used judiciously like the Polartec Alpha inside the Sportful Total Comfort Jacket. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Insulated

For riding in cold conditions, a jacket with some insulation will help to keep you warm. Insulation works by trapping air between your body and the outer shell and helps to maintain a more consistent temperature in the right conditions. Insulated jackets come in many flavors, with some being waterproof or water-resistant, and others not. Unlike sedentary activities where you want lots of insulation, cycling jackets typically have thinner insulating layers/materials than a jacket you would wear while ice fishing because you are generating significant body heat while you ride.

Wearing the 7Mesh Freeflow insulated cycling jacket
The 7Mesh Freeflow jacket is exceptionally comfortable thanks to a great fit, and warm with its soft Polartec Alpha insulation. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Insulating materials in cycling jackets include fleece, synthetic, down, etc. Polartec Alpha is a newer insulating material that is used in garments for people being active where there may be large variations in temperature, as there is in cycling. Some of the insulated models we tested include the POC Pro Thermal, Rapha Pro Team Insulated Gore-Tex Rain Jacket, and the 7Mesh Freeflow. While insulated jackets are a great choice for riding in cold conditions, a good layering system under a wind or rain shell can be just as effective as insulation built into a jacket.

Riding in the Castelli Alpha Doppio RoS jacket
Not only does the Castelli Alpha Doppio RoS jacket fit exactly how we like, but it also happens to be extremely comfortable. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Fit

The fit of cycling jackets is one of the main things that sets them apart from other jackets. Cycling is not only a dynamic sport, but one that also requires you to be in a forward leaning position with your arms reaching to the handlebar. Good cycling jackets are designed to accommodate this body position with cuts and paneling that allow for great freedom of movement and prevent bunching or restriction. Cycling jackets also tend to be slim and form-fitting for aerodynamics, and ideally stay close to the body for a tidy fit with little excess material flapping in the wind. Depending on how you like to layer, however, you may want to consider how much room you need inside the jacket to comfortably fit multiple layers underneath.

In general, your typical jersey size will probably be the correct size for a cycling jacket. If in doubt, take some measurements and reference size charts, or better yet, go and try some different jackets on to be sure you get the right fit.

Wearing the Sportful Hot Pack No Rain cycling jacket on a cool misty mountain top
The Sportful Hot Pack No Rain is a super packable wind and rain jacket that’s there when you need it and easy to stash in a jersey pocket when you don’t. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Packability

Packability is important for riders living in areas that see sudden changes in temperature or weather or for rides of varying intensity where you might be heating up and cooling down significantly. If you’re riding in the mountains, it might be much cooler at the top of a long climb than it was at the valley floor, so it’s nice to be able to pull on a jacket that’s stashed in your jersey pocket for the descent. Similarly, if you start your ride when it’s cool in the morning, you may need to ditch the jacket a short time later when the temperature has warmed up. Or, if the weather is unsettled, a lightweight packable shell can save you when you get caught out in an afternoon shower with many miles left to ride. Whatever the reason, packability is very important for many riders for the peace of mind that comes with knowing you’re prepared for whatever comes your way.

The jackets we tested vary somewhat in terms of packability, but many of them pack down small enough to stuff into a pocket. In general, the light wind layers are the most packable. Some waterproof jackets like the Gorewear C5 Gore-Tex Shakedry 1985 are also incredibly packable, which is particularly impressive given how waterproof it is. Generally speaking, when you add insulation to a jacket it adds bulk, but most of the modern insulating materials used in cycling jackets are lightweight and highly compressible. An insulated jacket that stands out for its packability is the 7Mesh Freeflow Jacket which not only stuffs into its own pocket, but it has straps to secure it to the bike when you’re not wearing it.

a look inside the Castelli Alpha Doppio RoS jacket to see the internal insulating layer
A good layering system can be just as effective as built-in insulation for maintaining warmth and comfort on cold rides. The Castelli Alpha Doppio RoS essentially handles the layering for you with a sewn-in Polartec Alpha vest inside. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Layering

Layering preferences also influence jacket choice. Some riders like to layer a jersey between their jacket and base layer, while others like to forgo the jersey, instead choosing between a few different base layers to pair with their jacket for a two-piece system based on the intensity of the ride and the weather conditions. Typically, the fewer layers a cyclist prefers to wear, the more robust their jacket will tend to be. These cyclists may have a mid-weight long-sleeve jersey that they can pair with a thicker base layer for cool and dry riding, reserving their jacket for bitterly cold and possibly wet conditions. Riders who like to layer will often be better served with a lightweight, packable jacket that they can remove and stow in a jersey pocket if conditions improve during their ride.

The pockets on the Sportful Total Comfort Jacket
Some cycling jackets, like the Sportful Total Comfort, are designed to be worn over baselayers and have pockets on the back. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Pockets

With different styles of jackets for different conditions and layering systems, pockets are a feature that some jackets have and others do not. A lightweight and super packable wind shell, for example, will often be worn over a jersey that already has pockets, so it stands to reason that many of them do not have additional pockets that would be redundant. Other jackets are intended to be worn over baselayers which typically do not have pockets, so often these jackets will have some configuration of rear pockets to carry essentials, such as winter cycling gloves, multi-tools, and snacks, and keep them at arm’s reach. Of course, this varies from model to model and brand to brand, so consider your needs for carrying items in your jacket when choosing the right jacket for you.

A look at the visibility color and reflective elements on a cycling jacket
This bright color may not be for everyone, but you’ve got to admit that it makes you more visible. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Visibility

When we’re riding in a jacket, it is often early or late in the day or during seasons or weather where visibility can be compromised. Since we want to be seen by motorists for our safety, we always appreciate reflective elements on jackets to give them a little pop and enhance our visibility on the road. These are typically in the form of reflective strips or logos bonded to the jacket fabric or panels or tabs that are sewn in. In addition to reflectives, many jackets also come in a range of colors, some of which are much brighter than others for increased visibility. Of course, a good set of bike lights is also a great way to add visibility and/or help you see where you’re going in challenging lighting conditions.

Value

Just like anything else in cycling, jackets can be expensive. The models we tested vary quite dramatically in price from $70 for a more basic wind layer up to $420 for a more advanced waterproof insulated jacket. In general, technical materials, advanced constructions, and quality craftsmanship command higher prices. Of course, there are certain brands that simply cost a bit more too. Realistically, if you’re willing and able to spend top dollar on the most expensive jacket, we doubt you’ll be disappointed. For those on a budget, however, there are solid options at lower prices that will absolutely get the job done for less. One thing we can say for sure, getting the right cycling jacket for your needs is a worthwhile investment that will pay dividends in comfort out on the road.

Riding in the MAAP Training Winter Jacket
When you’re prepared with the right cycling jacket, riding your bike in the fall, winter, and spring is much more enjoyable. (photo/Ben Guernsey)

Frequently Asked Questions About Cycling Jackets

Why should I buy a cycling jacket?

A good cycling jacket can dramatically enhance your comfort and enjoyment while riding in cool/cold conditions and unsettled or wet weather. While indoor trainers are great for training when conditions don’t allow you to get outside, it’s fair to say that most of us would rather be riding outdoors if possible, and the right cycling jacket, along with other apparel and accessories like bib tights and winter cycling gloves, can be the key to unlocking a longer outdoor riding season. Of course, you can ride in any old jacket you’d like, but we recommend cycling-specific jackets for several reasons.

Fit is one of the main factors, as cycling jackets are designed to accommodate the riding position with the arms forward without any restriction or binding. The arms and torso of cycling jackets are made to fit properly in the riding position and provide the appropriate level of coverage without bunching or, conversely, riding up. They are also generally slim and fit close to the body to reduce drag and material flapping in the wind at speed. Many jacket models are incredibly lightweight and pack down impressively small so they can be stashed in a jersey pocket until you need them and some have pockets to carry essentials while you ride. Strategic placement of wind-blocking materials, breathable panels, or insulation in some designs also works to provide protection or warmth where you need it, and not where you don’t.

What type of jacket is best for me?

Unfortunately, there is no one jacket that we’ve found that’s perfect for every temperature or weather condition, though there are some that come pretty close. To figure out what jacket is the best for you, you really need to consider the temperatures and weather that you expect to encounter and choose a jacket that is most appropriate. For some riders, a versatile option like the Ornot Magic Shell or the Castelli Perfetto RoS will be perfect to handle 99% of the fall, winter, and spring riding they do with the right layering. For others, having multiple jackets may be needed to cover the full spectrum of riding conditions they will experience. By being honest with yourself about the temperatures and conditions you’re actually going to suit up for and go riding in, you should be able to find the right jacket for you.

How do I take care of my cycling jacket?

Over time, your cycling jacket is bound to get dirty from sweat, road spray, etc., so, eventually, it will need to be washed. As with any garment made from technical fabrics, following the manufacturer’s recommendations is the best way to go to ensure a long lifespan. Some jackets can probably just be washed with cold water and a mild detergent, while other, more advanced materials should only be washed with tech wash type detergents. Also, the DWR coating on many jackets is prone to breaking down over time, and retreating may be needed to bring water-repellency to the surface fabric. Again, it’s important to follow the manufacturer’s recommendation for the best results.

Why do most road cycling jackets not have hoods?

Some cycling jackets have hoods, but the vast majority of models made for road riding do not for one simple reason. When not in use, a hood can act as a wind catch and fill up with air while you are riding which can be both uncomfortable and super annoying. For riding in super wet conditions, a hood may be a nice feature to have as long as you keep it up, or if it fits under your helmet. Otherwise, we recommend looking into a waterproof cycling cap to keep your head dry.

Why are some cycling jackets so expensive?

Materials, construction, design, and yes, even brand names are the primary reasons that some cycling jackets are so expensive. Making a jacket completely waterproof and insulated while still being incredibly lightweight and comfortable while riding is no easy task. It takes advanced materials, construction methods, and well-thought-out designs to make some of these jackets, and the price adds up. While the price of many cycling jackets is hard to swallow, when you consider the fact that you can pack a completely waterproof jacket into a jersey pocket, it starts to make a little more sense. Of course, not everyone needs, wants, or is willing to pay $400 for a jacket, but they are available if you’re able to justify the expense.

Related Content

The post The Best Cycling Jackets of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
347576
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024 https://bikerumor.com/best-cycling-shoe-covers/ Fri, 08 Dec 2023 23:06:35 +0000 https://bikerumor.com/?p=347654 Without proper protection, water, wind, and cold air will conspire to punish your feet and cut your ride short. Keeping your extremities, and especially your…

The post The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
Cycling shoe covers collage lead image

Without proper protection, water, wind, and cold air will conspire to punish your feet and cut your ride short. Keeping your extremities, and especially your feet comfortable while riding in the elements is a mysterious challenge for cyclists, but the right pair of cycling shoe covers can help keep them warm and dry.

Cycling shoe covers take a wide variety of approaches to solving this problem, and some are more effective than others. The ideal shoe cover for you will depend on the conditions you’ll be riding in, of course, with lightweight and aerodynamic options that excel in cold and dry conditions, to burly, multi-layer styles that can keep your feet warm after they get wet.

To help sort through the myriad shoe cover options on the market, review author Bennett Shane tested a diverse selection of 13 of the best models on the market for months in the highly variable weather of the Pacific Northwest. Important factors like wind and weather protection, warmth, fit, comfort, and ease of getting them on and off were considered while testing.

Our top cycling shoe recommendations are listed below, followed by the best of the rest which are all worthy options in their own right. To see the specs of all the models we tested at a glance, check out our comparison chart. If you’re unsure what you need, our buying advice is full of helpful information and our FAQ section has answers to some common questions.

The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024


Best Overall Cycling Shoe Covers

Velocio Signature Rain Bootie

Specs

  • MSRP $99
  • Weight 92g/pair
  • Material Waterproof softshell: 80% polyamide,20% elastane + membrane
  • Waterproof Yes
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes XS – XXL
Product Badge The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Lightweight
  • Sleek fitting
  • Waterproof
  • Highly versatile

Cons

  • Moderately expensive
  • Not for super cold conditions
Best Value Cycling Shoe Covers

Fizik Waterproof Winter Overshoe

Specs

  • MSRP $70
  • Weight 164g/pair
  • Material Neoprene + 3L waterproof/breathable fabric
  • Waterproof Yes
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes S – XL
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Warm
  • Waterproof
  • Reflective front and side
  • Fair price for waterproof protection

Cons

  • Shorter cuff height
  • Limited reflectives on rear
Best Cycling Shoe Covers For Maximum Coverage And Protection

Spatzwear Spatz Pro 2 Overshoes

Specs

  • MSRP $125
  • Weight 280g/pair
  • Material Neoprene with Kevlar, Thermal lining
  • Waterproof "Hydrophobic outer layer"
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes S, M-L, L-XL
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Bomber construction
  • Very Warm
  • Unrivaled shin and calf coverage

Cons

  • Heavy
  • Polarizing looks
Best Cycling Shoe Covers For Deep Winter

Castelli Estremo Shoe Cover

Specs

  • MSRP $170
  • Weight 196g/pair
  • Material GORE-TEX INFINIUM™ WINDSTOPPER® upper, Polartec Power Stretch Pro lining, Polyurethane sole
  • Waterproof No, highly water-resistant
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes S – XXL
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Super warm
  • Rugged construction
  • Sleek fit considering the warmth

Cons

  • Too warm for mild conditions
  • Expensive
Best Cycling Shoe Covers For Comfort

Assos GT Ultraz Winter Booties

Specs

  • MSRP $120
  • Weight 129g/pair
  • Material ThermoShell 3-layer softshell, PU-bonded membrane, dual-layer twinDeck construction
  • Waterproof No
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes 0, I, II (36-39, 40-43, 44-47 EU)
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Flexible material
  • Lightweight
  • Super-warm

Cons

  • Not suitable for wet conditions
  • Could use some more reflectives for visibility
Best Cycling Shoe Covers For Durability

Endura Road Overshoe

Specs

  • MSRP $70
  • Weight 197g/pair
  • Material Smooth Neoprene
  • Waterproof Yes
  • Colors Black, Hi-Viz Yellow
  • Available Sizes S – XXL
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Durable
  • Warm
  • Fair price
  • Neoprene maintains warmth when wet

Cons

  • Kinda heavy
  • Not super breathable
Best Cycling Toe Covers

VeloToze Toe Covers

Specs

  • MSRP $15
  • Weight 25g/pair
  • Material 100% Latex Rubber
  • Waterproof Yes
  • Colors Black, Blue, Red, White, Pink, Viz Yellow, Viz Orange, Viz Green
  • Available Sizes One Size
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Color options
  • Lightweight
  • No seams
  • Super affordable
  • Very basic but effective

Cons

  • Can tear around the cleat
  • Rubber material doesn't do well with sharp objects or abrasion

Best of the Rest

Best Cycling Shoe Covers On A Tight Budget

Showers Pass Crosspoint Waterproof Socks

Specs

  • MSRP $40
  • Weight 70g /pair
  • Material Crosspoint 3-layer construction: kint outer, Artex membrane, Coolmax lining
  • Waterproof Yes
  • Colors Black/Grey, Chili Pepper/Black
  • Available Sizes S/M, M/L, L/XL, XL/XXL
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Minimal construction
  • Maximal protection
  • Light
  • No seams
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Must make an incision for cleat
  • Looks may not be for everyone
Warm, Waterproof, and Aero

Castelli Pioggia 4 Shoecover

Specs

  • MSRP $80
  • Weight 130g/pair
  • Material Waterproof PU-coated stretch fabric with fleece lining
  • Waterproof Yes
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes S – XXL
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Light
  • Aero, provided size is correct
  • Warm

Cons

  • Hole for heel pad is a little small – easy to step on
Good For Road And Gravel

Sportful Infinium Bootie All Road

Specs

  • MSRP $95
  • Weight 134g/pair
  • Material GoreTex® Infinium
  • Waterproof No
  • Colors Black
  • Available Sizes S – XXL
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Burly construction
  • Great fit
  • Versatile in cold and wet conditions
  • Good for gravel too

Cons

  • Moderately expensive
Versatile For Road, Gravel, And MTB Shoes

Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lite Shoe Covers

Specs

  • MSRP $65
  • Weight 144g/pair
  • Material 3-layer AmFIB softshell
  • Waterproof No
  • Colors Black, Sunfire (orange)
  • Available Sizes S – XXL
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Warm
  • Light
  • Easy on/off

Cons

  • Run large
  • Fit is less precise
Good Value For Wet Conditions And Mild Temperatures

GripGrab RaceAqua Waterproof Road Shoe Covers

Specs

  • MSRP $55
  • Weight 125g/pair
  • Material Waterproof high-stretch material: 75% Polyester 20% Polyurethane 5% Elastane
  • Waterproof Yes
  • Colors Black, Yellow Hi-Vis
  • Available Sizes S – XXXL
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Light
  • Great for wet conditions and milder temperatures

Cons

  • Not all that warm
Affordable Toe Coverage

Pearl Izumi AmFIB Toe Covers

Specs

  • MSRP $20
  • Weight 28g/pair
  • Material AmFIB Softshell: 64% polyamide, 14% polyester, 14% polyurethane, 8% nylon
  • Waterproof No
  • Colors Black, Screaming Yellow
  • Available Sizes S/M, L/XL
The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024

Pros

  • Very affordable
  • Easy on and off
  • Keeps toes nice and warm

Cons

  • Toe covers provide less protection than full covers

Comparison Chart

Shoe Cover ModelMSRPWeight (pair)Waterproof?ColorsSizes
Velocio Signature Rain Bootie$9992 gramsYesBlackXS, S, M, L, XL, XXL
Fizik Waterproof Winter Overshoe$70164 gramsYesBlackS, M, L, XL
Spatzwear Spatz Pro 2 Overshoes$125280 gramsYesBlackS, M-L, L-XL
Castelli Estremo Shoe Covers$170196 gramsNoBlackS, M, L, XL, XXL
Assos GT Ultraz Winter Booties$120129 gramsNoBlack0, I, II (36-39, 40-43, 44-47)
Endura Road Overshoe$70197 gramsYes2S, M, L, XL, XXL
VeloToze Toe Covers$1525 gramsYes8One Size
Showers Pass Crosspoint Waterproof Socks$4070 grams
Yes

Yes
S/M, M/L, L/XL, XL/XXL
Castelli Pioggia 4 Shoecover$80130 gramsYesBlackS, M, L, XL, XXL
Sportful Infinium Bootie All Road$95134 gramsNoBlackS, M, L, XL, XXL
Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lite Shoe Covers$65144 gramsNo2S, M, L, XL, XXL
GripGrab RaceAqua Waterproof Road$55125 gramsYes2S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXXL
Pearl Izumi AmFIB Toe Covers$2028 gramsNo2S/M, L/XL

Why You Should Trust Us

At Bikerumor, we love riding outside and most of us will do whatever it takes to stay off the indoor trainer for as long as we possibly can. We know that riding in the colder temperatures and variable weather of the fall, winter, and spring is much more comfortable and enjoyable when we’re equipped with the right gear for the job. For road cycling, this includes a pair of cycling bib tights, a good cycling jacket, and some winter cycling gloves, and, of course, shoe covers to keep our feet happy in less-than-ideal conditions. And, of course, we’re passionate about cycling gear and providing trustworthy product recommendations based on side-by-side comparative testing by our experts.

For this buyer’s guide, we recruited our road cycling expert, Bennett Shane, to test each cycling shoe cover model over the course of several months. Bennett has been cycling seriously for over two decades, and while his racing days are behind him, he still spends an inordinate amount of time on the bike riding for fun, fitness, and lots of product testing. As a year-round outdoor cyclist based in the Portland, OR, area, Bennett is intimately familiar with riding in the highly variable weather conditions that are common in the Pacific Northwest through the fall, winter, and spring. He’s learned firsthand the importance of having the right gear to maintain his comfort and enhance his enjoyment on the bike. Bennett also spent many years working for various prominent brands in the cycling industry and has unique insight into products and technologies and he has an astounding depth of knowledge. His cycling and industry experience combine to make him particularly adept at analyzing the performance and comparative differences of the products he tests. In addition to cycling shoe covers, Bennett has tested a range of products including the best road bike shoes and our favorite cycling bib tights for keeping the legs warm.

After researching the best cycling shoe covers on the market, we rounded up a diverse selection of 13 models to test and compare side by side. Each model was sent to Bennett who carefully examined the design, materials, and construction of each model and weighed them all for consistency and comparison to manufacturers’ specs. For several months, he tested each pair on everything from brisk morning and evening rides to rainstorms and cold, misty mountain adventures. While riding, he carefully considered the fit, comfort, warmth, and weather protection of each model, and when testing concluded, zeroed in on his favorites and those that excel in specific ways compared to the rest.

Geared up for testing cycling shoe covers in some wet and cold PNW weather
Review author Bennett Shane kitted up to put the Endura Road Overshoes through their paces on some wet PNW roads. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Buying Advice: How to Choose Cycling Shoe Covers

With so many different styles and intended uses, finding the right set of cycling shoe covers isn’t the most straightforward thing in the world. Here we’ll break down the different types of shoe covers along with important considerations that play a role in deciding what shoe covers are best for you.

Wearing the Velocio Signature Rain Booties cycling shoe covers
Cycling shoe covers take many forms, from simple toe covers to full coverage models like the Velocio Signature Rain Booties pictured here. (photo/Bennett Shane)

What are Cycling Shoe Covers?

Overshoes, booties, shoe covers, and even toe covers are the various names that different brands use to refer to the covers you slip on over your cycling shoes to protect from cold, wind, and/or wet conditions while riding. Essentially, these are additional layers for the toes, feet, ankles, and lower leg that are intended to provide protection from the elements when riding in the cold temperatures and variable weather of the fall, winter, and spring, or any other time that conditions warrant.

Types of Cycling Shoe Covers

Like anything else in cycling, road shoe covers come in a huge range of different styles, materials, constructions, and designs to meet the demands of varying conditions and the needs of riders. From simple toe covers to take the edge off cold winds, insulated and waterproof models for riding in frigid temps and wet conditions, and everything in between, there are shoe covers specially made for every use case.

Toe covers, like the VeloToze, are a simple, effective, and affordable way to keep the chill and/or light road spray off your toes on cool days. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Toe Covers

Toe covers are the simplest form of shoe cover and they are exactly what they sound like. Toe covers are small sleeves that slip on over the toes and front portion of a cycling shoe and around the cleat to provide a barrier that blocks wind and moisture with the goal of keeping your toes warmer and drier than they would be without them. Given their simpler designs, constructions, and the amount of materials used, they are typically quite affordable compared to full coverage overshoes. They are also very lightweight and small, making them easy to stash in a jersey pocket or carry as an insurance policy if the conditions change while you’re out on a ride.

The primary drawback to toe covers is that they really only provide protection for the toes/front half of your feet, leaving your heel, ankle, and lower leg exposed to the elements. Still, they are great in the right conditions, and depending on your tolerance for cold, may be enough for many riders to make it through the majority of cool fall, winter, and spring riding in comfort without having to spend much money. In fact, the two models that we tested, the VeloToze Toe Covers and the Pearl Izumi AmFIB Toe Covers, cost just $15 and $20, respectively, making them the most cost-effective options in this review.

Wearing the Castelli Pioggia 4 cycling shoe covers
Full coverage shoe covers, overshoes, and booties, like the Castelli Pioggia 4 pictured here, cover the whole foot (minus holes on the bottom for the cleat and heel), extend slightly up the leg, and often have a zip up the back to get in and out of them more easily. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Overshoes, Booties, Full-Coverage Shoe Covers

Full-coverage shoe covers, overshoes, or booties are different from toe covers in that they cover the entirety of your shoe’s upper and typically extend part of the way up your lower leg to overlap your bib tights and provide protection for the ankle and sometimes the lower calf (or the entire calf in some cases). The soles of these shoe covers are generally made from a more abrasion-resistant material and have holes for the cleat and heel pad to stick through. Often, this style of shoe cover has a zipper on the back or side of the cuff to allow for easy entry and exit while others may slide on with the closure on the bottom of the foot. Overshoes like these come in every flavor imaginable, with thin and lightweight options for fending off wind and road spray in mild temperatures to insulated and “waterproof” models for riding in deep winter and/or full-on rainstorms.

Conditions

The temperatures and weather conditions are one of the most important factors to consider when choosing a pair of shoe covers. If you only ride in dry conditions, then your needs will obviously be different from those who venture out when there’s the potential for showers, the roads are super wet, or it’s a full-on rainstorm. Being realistic about the conditions you’ll encounter, or that you’re actually willing to go ride in, will help you narrow down the choices to find the shoe cover or covers that will serve you best.

Wind

No matter the temperature, the wind will almost always make it feel colder than it actually is. Even in the summer, bombing down a descent after you’ve sweat your way to the top can chill you to the core. This is especially true when it’s cool or cold outside as the chill of the wind effectively drops the temperature by around 10 degrees or more, and your extremities, the hands and feet, are the most susceptible to the effects. This is why one of the primary functions of all shoe covers is to block the wind, and virtually every model on the market does so relatively effectively, or at least much better than not wearing shoe covers at all.

If you ride in mild temperatures, around the 40s and 50s F, and dry conditions, then a light, wind-blocking toe cover or overshoe may be all you need to keep your toes and feet warm. Many lighter shoe covers can also be used in colder temperatures when worn with heavier socks or less ventilated shoes. Also, there are plenty of thinner, lightweight options that are also made from waterproof materials for wet days in cool conditions. Once you factor in cold temperatures, however, you’ll want to add some insulation to the mix.

Wearing the Castelli Estremo Shoe Covers
While they might not look it, the Castelli Estremo Shoe Covers are some of the warmest we tested and perfect for those really cold rides. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Cold

Once temperatures drop below around 40° or 45° F to freezing or below, it’s imperative to not only block the wind but also add some insulation to keep the feet warm. How much insulation you need depends on how cold of temperatures you’re willing to go ride in, but also other factors like sock choice, shoes, etc. Either way, brands go about insulating shoe covers in various ways. Many simply use softshell fabrics that have some thermal properties, while others may line their covers with soft fleece materials like Polartec Power Stretch Pro. Neoprene is another common material used in shoe covers because of its excellent insulating properties and its ability to maintain warmth even when wet.

Just like lighter-weight options for milder conditions, insulated shoe covers typically aim to provide some level of waterproofness or at least water resistance. Of the models we tested, the Castelli Estremo, Spatzwear Spatz Pro 2, and the Assos GT Ultraz Winter Booties are the best suited to properly cold conditions. One thing that commonly plagues more insulated shoe covers is that they can cause the feet to overheat once temperatures rise or you’re riding at high intensity.

Wearing the Endura Road Overshoes
Smooth-faced Neoprene is used in some shoe covers for wet weather, like the Endura Road Overshoes pictured here, as its smooth surface repels water effectively and they provide warmth even when wet. (photo/Benett Shane)

Wet

Keeping the feet dry when riding in wet conditions is a challenge and many shoe covers aim to do just that. While some use water-resistant materials to fend off passing showers and light road spray, others are constructed from “waterproof” materials with the goal of handling steady rains and significant amounts of moisture. Even with “waterproof” models, it’s important to understand that keeping your feet bone dry whilst riding in the rain is not a realistic objective. Road spray, sweat, and water migrating down your legs means that after enough time in steady rains, your feet are eventually going to get wet. The only unknown is whether they will go numb from loss of circulation, or stay comfortable thanks to a properly insulated pair of shoe covers.

Since most people avoid riding in proper rainstorms, it’s more likely that you’ll get caught out in passing showers when the weather is unsettled or you’ll end up riding on wet roads with light spray coming off your tires. For these situations, shoe covers made from materials like Gore-Tex Infinium, like the Castelli Estremo and the Sportful Infinium Bootie, provide good protection and water resistance along with admirable breathability. The shoe covers that aim to be waterproof use a variety of different materials with many incorporating waterproof membranes and taped seams in their constructions. These include the Artex membrane sandwiched in the layers of the Showers Pass Crosspoint Waterproof Socks, or the Waterproof PU-coated fabric of the Castelli Pioggia 4 that provides a barrier that water isn’t able to easily pass through. Neoprene, especially neoprene with a smooth outer finish, like that found on the Spatzwear Spatz Pro 2 and the Endura Road Overshoes, is also highly effective at shedding water and not getting soaked. When moisture eventually creeps in from the legs or from underneath, neoprene does a great job of staying warm even when wet.

Wearing the Sportful Infinium All Road Booties
Reflective accents, like the stripes on the back of the Sportful Infinium All Road Booties, add visibility for motorists in low light conditions. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Visibility

Riding in the fall, winter, and spring means that you may end up on the road in challenging light conditions or weather that may make you less visible than usual to motorists. For this reason, we like having reflective elements added to our cycling shoe covers or the option to get bright, high-visibility colors. While most other elements of the cool weather riding kit, like bib tights, cycling jackets, and even winter cycling gloves, will likely have some reflectives on them as well, often your shoe covers may end up obscuring those on the calf area of your tights, making them even more important for visibility. Nearly every shoe cover includes reflective patches or logos on them, though some brands prioritize it more than others.

A look at the sole of the Fizik Waterproof Winter booties cycling shoe covers
A close look at the soles on the Fizik Waterproof Winter Booties. The reinforced cutouts line up well with the cleat and heel pad and the solare material itself is more robust than the uppers. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Durability

Nothing lasts forever, and that’s particularly true of cycling shoe covers. Certain materials are simply more prone to wear and tear than others, especially when they are attached to your feet. Your shoe cover will be subject to stretching and pulling when getting them on and off, as well as moisture, dust, road grit, and more. And, of course, if you treat them carelessly or they are scraped against sharp objects or dragged across the pavement, they will wear out more quickly. When treated with care, however, it’s fair to expect to get a couple seasons or more of use out of them, depending on how much use they get.

One of the biggest factors that impact a shoe cover’s durability, however, is the sole. There are cutouts to allow the cleat and the heel to stick through, and usually, these are reinforced to prevent rips when pulling them on. Still, ensuring you have the correct size will make it so the heel pad and cleat line up with these holes properly to avoid over-stretching them and so you are less likely to step on the material when walking. Most models also employ a more robust material across the sole, sometimes a Kevlar material or something similar, that can stand up to occasional encounters with the ground when you clip out when stopped or are walking short distances in your shoes. Regardless, it is best to try and avoid walking around in your shoe covers as it will undoubtedly impact the soles and be one of the factors that play into their eventual demise.

Wearing the Spatzwear Spatz Pro 2 cycling shoe covers
If you’re serious about riding through miserable conditions, then the Spatzwear Spatz Pro 2 might be worth their weight in gold despite their higher price and funky looks. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Value

As with any other cycling accessory, the price of shoe covers varies pretty dramatically and you can spend a lot or a little on them depending on your specific needs and budget. Some brands just command higher prices while some of the more robust and protective models cost more due to more advanced materials, designs, and constructions. If you’re expecting your shoe covers to keep you both warm and dry while riding in near freezing temperatures and/or rain in the heart of winter, then you’ll probably want to spend a bit more for something like the Spatzwear Spatz Pro 2 Overshoes, $125, for maximum coverage and weather protection. If you just need to protect your toes from cooler temperatures and biting winds, you can spend as little as $15 on something like the VeloToze Toe Covers that will get the job done for lots of spring and fall rides.

That said, you can also find great value in between those extremes for models like the Fizik Waterproof Winter Booties, $70, that work, look, and feel great in a wide range of temperatures and conditions, or even the GripGrab Race Aqua Waterproof Road shoe covers, $55, for those wet days with milder temperatures. And, we have had great success modifying the Showers Pass Crosspoint Waterproof Socks, $40, to work over the shoes, providing warmth, wind, and water protection for a bargain price.

They might look a little different, bu
They might look a little different but a simple modification to the Showers Pass Crosspoint Waterproof Socks gets the job done for less, and they’re actually waterproof. (photo/Bennett Shane)

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need cycling shoe covers?

If your outdoor riding season doesn’t stop when the temperatures drop or the weather changes, then you will likely benefit from having some shoe covers to suit the conditions you’ll be encountering. Since your feet are very susceptible to the effects of cold, wind, and water, protecting them from the elements will help you stay more comfortable for longer and increase your enjoyment on the bike.

How do I know which cycling shoe covers will be best for me?

Finding the right shoe covers really comes down to the conditions you expect to encounter and then matching your needs for warmth and weather protection accordingly. When you consider your climate and take into account the conditions you’re willing to go out and ride in (tolerance for cold and wet), you should be able to narrow down the choices to find the right pair. And, as mentioned above, it might make sense to have more than one pair to cover all your needs.

Do I need multiple different pairs of cycling shoe covers?

It really depends on the range of conditions that you’ll be riding in. Many people will probably be fine with a versatile pair of shoe covers that handles the majority of their needs, while others may encounter conditions that vary so dramatically that multiple options are needed to keep them comfortable through all of it. For example, if you ride in mild and wet conditions, something like the Velocio Signature Rain Bootie will be a great fit, but if you’re heading out in properly freezing temperatures, it might not be. Similarly, if you have shoe covers for sub-freezing temperatures, like the Castelli Estremo, they won’t be great when temperatures climb above around 40° F.

Are there alternatives to cycling shoe covers?

Shoe covers are not the only choice when it comes to riding in cold or wet weather. Many brands make specialized cold and/or wet-weather shoes that are a good option for truly dedicated foul-weather cyclists. Waterproof socks, like the Showers Pass Crosspoint Waterproof Socks, are a low-cost option that can help to keep wind and water from reaching your feet, although your shoes can still get wet when wearing them.

What other gear should I consider for riding in cold or wet weather?

Keeping your extremities warm and dry in cold and/or wet weather is challenging, so in addition to shoe covers, the right pair of winter cycling gloves is critical for your hands to keep them comfortable and remain in control of your bike. For the body, we like wearing bib tights to keep the cold, winter, and water off our legs, along with a good cycling jacket to suit the conditions. Of course, cycling caps, face covers, and balaclavas are great for protecting the head and face, and there are tons of great base and mid-layers to dial in your layering system to suit your needs.

Related Content

The post The Best Cycling Shoe Covers of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
347654
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024 https://bikerumor.com/best-bike-multi-tool/ Fri, 08 Dec 2023 19:29:49 +0000 https://bikerumor.com/?p=347445 It’s hard to imagine a cycling accessory that is more essential, affordable, or portable than the bike multi-tool. Mechanical issues can and do happen, and…

The post The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
Group shot of bike multi-tools lead image for buyer's guide

It’s hard to imagine a cycling accessory that is more essential, affordable, or portable than the bike multi-tool. Mechanical issues can and do happen, and being prepared can mean the difference between a quick, easy adjustment in the middle of a ride or ending up stranded in the middle of nowhere.

Whether you ride road, gravel, mountain bikes, or all of the above, carrying a quality multi-tool is an absolute necessity. When you need to tighten a loose bolt, make a mid-ride adjustment, or fix a broken chain, a good multi-tool is a critical accessory to have when you’re miles from home or the trailhead. And, if you don’t have a full set of bike tools at home, they can be handy for use there as well.

Having owned a variety of multi-tools over the years, losing and finding a few (remember to zip up those saddlebags, people), and trying a wide range of the latest models, we gathered 12 of the best multi-tools on the market to test and compare. Each model was tested by review author Jim Graham or a member of the Bikerumor team for months, and in some cases, years, to help you find the perfect one to match your style of riding and bike repair know-how.

Our top bike multi-tool recommendations are listed below, followed by the best of the rest which are great options that we feel are also worthy of consideration. Our comparison chart shows all the models we tested and their specs at a glance, we provide helpful information in our buying advice if you need help deciding what you need, and the FAQ section provides answers to some common questions.

The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024


Best Overall Bike Multi-Tool

Silca Italian Army Knife – Venti

Specs

  • MSRP $55
  • Measured Weight 177g
  • Number of Functions 20
  • Hex Keys 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 8mm
  • Torx T8, T10, T20 and T25
  • Screwdrivers Phillips #2 and flat head
  • Other Tools Chain tool, master-link storage, 7mm box wrench, 8mm flare nut wrench, 10mm open wrench, disc pad spreader, Presta valve core remover; 13 gauge and 15 gauge spoke wrenches
Product Badge The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Steel tools coated with high-grip chrome
  • Hidden master-link storage in handle
  • 4 Torx bit sizes
  • 3 nut wrenches
  • Disc pad spreader
  • Italian good looks

Cons

  • Lacks master-link tool
  • Moderately expensive
Best Budget Bike Multi-Tool

Pro Bike Tool 20-in-1

Specs

  • MSRP $29
  • Measured Weight 118g
  • Number of Functions 20
  • Hex Keys 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 8mm
  • Torx T25 and T30
  • Screwdrivers Phillips and flathead
  • Other Tools Chain tool, Mavic M7 and M9 spoke wrenches, 8, 9 and 10 open wrenches, valve core tool, bottle opener.
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Compact
  • Lightweight
  • Sizes marked on bits
  • Covers the basics

Cons

  • Short tools limits reach for some tasks
  • Hard to grasp chain tool
Runner-Up Best Bike Multi-Tool

Unior Multitool Euro17

Specs

  • MSRP $50
  • Measured Weight 175g
  • Number of Functions 17
  • Hex Keys 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 8mm
  • Torx T10 and T25
  • Screwdrivers Phillips #1 and flathead
  • Other Tools Chain tool, Schrader and Presta valve tools, spoke wrenches for 3.3, 3.45, and DT nipples.
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Schrader and Presta valve tools
  • 3 spoke wrench sizes
  • Black oxide tips for durability, rust prevention
  • Red side bar for visibility
  • Bits are slightly longer than most

Cons

  • Limited Torx sizes
  • Moderately expensive
Best Bike Multi-Tool For Mountain Biking

ToPeak Mini PT30

Specs

  • Price $58.50
  • Measured Weight 173g (w/ case)
  • Hex Keys 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, and 10mm
  • Torx T10, T15, and T25
  • Screwdrivers Phillips #2 and flathead
  • Other Tools Chain tool, chain hook, master link tool and storage; 14 and 15 gauge, Mavic M7, and Shimano 4.5mm spoke wrenches; Presta valve core tool, disc pad spreader, knife blade, tubeless tire reamer, and plug insertion tool
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Huge range of features
  • Compact
  • Neoprene case
  • Tubeless plug tools
  • Master link tool and holder

Cons

  • Bits are on the short side
  • L-shaped 2mm hex is awkward to use
  • Moderately expensive
Best Bike Multi-Tool For On-Bike Storage

Blackburn Switch Wrap Tool Kit

Specs

  • MSRP $50
  • Measured Weight 176g
  • Number of Functions 16 (including carrying other things)
  • Hex Keys 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 8
  • Torx T25 and T30
  • Screwdrivers Flathead
  • Other Tools Chain tool, 0, 1, and 2 spoke wrenches, valve core tool, disc pad spreader
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Frame or saddle mount option
  • Can carry tube, CO2s, and other essentials
  • Eliminates need for saddlebag
  • Ergonomic handle
  • Lots of leverage if needed

Cons

  • Separate bits
  • Limited tools
  • More time-consuming to deploy tools
Best Bike Multi-Tool For Durability

Crankbrothers M19

Specs

  • MSRP $33 to $37 (depending on color)
  • Measured Weight 175g (215g total with metal storage case)
  • Number of Functions 19
  • Hex Keys 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 8mm
  • Torx T10 and T25
  • Screwdrivers Phillips #1 and #2, flathead
  • Other Tools Chain tool, 8mm and 10mm open wrenches, and 0, 1, 2, 3 spoke wrenches.
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Durable construction – lasts forever
  • Fair price
  • Good leverage

Cons

  • Heavier weight, especially when used with metal case
  • No tubeless tools (check out the M20)
Best Bike Multi-Tool With Tubeless Plugs

Cannondale 18-in-1 with Dynaplug

Specs

  • MSRP $80
  • Measured Weight 125g
  • Number of Functions 18
  • Hex Keys 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 8mm
  • Torx T25
  • Screwdrivers Phillips #2 and flathead
  • Other Tools Chain tool, Dynaplug w/ 2 plugs, disc pad spreader, master-link storage, 3 spoke wrench sizes, presta valve core remover, bottle opener
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Lightweight
  • Contains most of the tools you need and tubeless plugs in one
  • Dynaplugs work great
  • Compact size

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Short bits

Best of the Rest

A Great Tool With Individual Hex Keys

Blackburn Wayside

Specs

  • MSRP $40
  • Measured Weight 195g
  • Number of Functions 19
  • Hex Keys 2, 2.5, 3, 4, and 5mm removable L-bend ball-end wrenches and 6 and 8mm hex wrenches
  • Torx T25 and T30
  • Screwdrivers Flathead
  • Other Tools Chain tool, 0, 1, and 2 spoke wrenches, Presta valve core tool, disc pad spreader, serrated knife blade, breaker bar function
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Removable ball-end hex wrenches
  • Chain tool with assembly hook
  • Disc brake pad spreader
  • Sharp knife

Cons

  • No Phillips head screwdriver
  • Limited Torx sizes
  • A little heavier than some
A Comprehensive Bike Multi-Tool For Far-Flung Adventures

Wolf Tooth 8-Bit Kit Two

Specs

  • MSRP $140
  • Measured Weight 172g
  • Number of Functions 26
  • Hex Keys 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 8mm
  • Torx T10 and T25
  • Screwdrivers Phillips #2 and flat head
  • Other Tools Chain tool, master link/valve stem pliers, rasp for clearing tire sealant, spoke/valve core wrench, tire plug tools; 16mm hex on chain tool; storage for tire plugs/master link/valve core, tire lever, disc rotor truing tool, 8mm flare wrench
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Very comprehensive tool selection
  • Master link/valve stem pliers and storage
  • Disc rotor truing tool
  • Tubeless tools and 5 plugs
  • Valve core rasp

Cons

  • Pricey
  • Separate bits are black and can be hard to see if dropped
  • Not as quick and easy to use as other options
A Ratcheting Bike Multi-Tool That's Great For Travel

ToPeak Ratchet Rocket Lite DX+

Specs

  • MSRP $53
  • Measured Weight 195g
  • Number of Functions 20
  • Hex Keys 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 8mm
  • Torx T10, T15, and T25
  • Screwdrivers Phillips
  • Other Tools Chain tool, 2 tire levers, reversing ratchet, magnetized bit holder/extender, nylon case with patch pocket
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Reversing ratchet
  • Access into tight spaces
  • Tire levers
  • Patch/cash pocket
  • Replaceable bits

Cons

  • No flathead screwdriver
  • Separate bits
  • Bigger size
Lightweight With Tubeless Repair Tools

Lezyne SV Pro-17

Specs

  • MSRP $50
  • Measured Weight 119g
  • Number of Functions 17
  • Hex Keys 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6mm
  • Torx T10 and T25
  • Screwdrivers Phillips
  • Other Tools Chain tool, 1, 2, and 3 spoke wrenches, 8 and 10 open wrenches, valve core tool, tubeless needle and plug carrier with plugs.
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Lightweight
  • Small size
  • Covers the basics
  • Includes plugs and plugger

Cons

  • No flathead screwdriver or 8mm hex
  • Compact size limits leverage
A Nice Compact Package

Bontrager Pro Multi-Tool

Specs

  • MSRP $52
  • Measured Weight 162g
  • Number of Functions 15
  • Hex Keys 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 8mm
  • Torx T25
  • Screwdrivers Phillips and flathead
  • Other Tools Chain tool, 0, 1, 2, 3 spoke wrenches, case doubles as handle, integrated bottle opener
The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024

Pros

  • Compact design
  • Smooth carrying case
  • Case provides extra leverage
  • Covers the basics
  • Bottle opener!

Cons

  • Limited tools
  • Black color can be easily lost

Comparison Chart

Multi-Tool ModelMSRPMeasured Weight# of FunctionsHex KeysTorxScrewdriversChain ToolTubeless Repair Tools
Silca Italian Army Knife – Venti$55177g202, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8T8, T10, T20, T25Phillips #2, flatheadYesNo
Pro Bike Tool 20-in-1$29118g202, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8T25, T30Phillips, flatheadYesNo
Unior Multitool Euro17$50175g172, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8T10, T25Phillips #1, flatheadYesNo
ToPeak Mini PT30$58.50171g302, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10T10, T15, T25Phillips #2, flatheadYesYes
Blackburn Switch Wrap$50176g162.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8T25, T30flat headYesNo
Crankbrothers M19$37175g (215g w/ case)192, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8T10, T25Phillips #1 and #2, flatheadYesNo (M20 comes with)
Cannondale 18-in-1 w/ Dynaplug$80125g182, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8T25Phillips #2, flatheadYesYes
Blackburn Wayside$40195g192, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8T25, T30flat headYesNo
Wolf Tooth 8-Bit Kit Two$140172g262, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8T10, T25Phillips #2, flatheadYesYes
ToPeak Ratchet Rocket Lite DX+$53195g202, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8T10, T15, T25PhillipsYesNo
Lezyne SV Pro-17$50119g172, 3, 4, 5, 6T10, T25PhillipsYesYes
Bontrager Pro Multi-Tool$52162g152, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8T25Phillips, flat headYesNo
Scroll to the right to see more specs.

Why You Should Trust Us

At Bikerumor, we know that having a good multi-tool can make the difference between continuing your ride or cutting it short, so we always carry one with us no matter where we’re going or what type of bike we’re riding. We can’t even count the number of times our multi-tools have been used over the years for everything from simple comfort adjustments, fixing chains, or tightening bolts that mysteriously came loose during a ride. And, we’re always seeking the best tool for the job, whether that’s a super lightweight option for races or a more comprehensive model for heading way off the grid on overnight adventures. Thankfully, we get to try out a lot of different multi-tools, so we can share our experience with you.

For our bike multi-tools buyer’s guide, review authors Jim Graham and Jeremy Benson personally tested each of the 12 models included. Jim is an avid gravel rider who spends lots of time exploring the backroads of New England and knows the importance of having the right multi-tool while riding through remote forests on rough roads. He’s been cycling for many years and has used many different multi-tools in that time. He’s semi-retired from a career in journalism, but he’s keeping himself busy testing and reviewing gear including the best gravel bike tires. Jeremy has been professionally testing and reviewing bike gear for over seven years. He’s a gravel and mountain bike racer who spends an inordinate time on the bike testing products, training, and riding for fun. In addition to testing over 30 multi-tools in the past few years, he’s constantly making mid-ride adjustments while testing everything from complete bikes, pedals, and shoes, and has come to appreciate the quality multi-tools that help to make his life easier. Jeremy has also provided his expertise in testing and reviewing the best hitch bike racks, protective mountain bike helmets, and our favorite mountain bike shoes.

After researching the best bike multi-tools on the market, we rounded up a diverse selection of 12 models for side-by-side testing and comparison. Each tool was weighed for consistency and comparison to manufacturers’ specs and examined to check the design and build quality. We shoved each multi-tool into jersey pockets, saddle bags, and fanny packs to analyze their portability, and took them out on rides of varying lengths in the off chance we might need to use them in the field. We also ran each model through a series of tests in the home workshop to test their ergonomics, the functionality and durability of all the tools, and to use features like chain tools, quick link storage, quick link tools, disc pad spreaders, and, of course, bottle openers. When testing concluded, we zeroed in on our favorites and those that excel in specific ways compared to the rest.

Using the Cannondale 18-in-1 with Dynaplug to tighten a thru-axle on a mountain bike
There’s no substitute for real-world testing, so we ran each model through a series of tests to see how well they work and compare to each other. (photo/Jeremy Benson)

Buying Advice: How to Choose a Bike Multi-Tool

With so many multi-tools offering a dizzying array of functions and features, it’s easy to get lost while comparing all the specs. But answering this question will go miles toward simplifying your search: How will you actually use a multi-tool?

Almost every multi-tool we’ve ever tried will handle the most common, basic repairs and tweaks on a road, gravel, mountain, or e-bike – adjusting a saddle or handlebars or tightening a loose bolt. So, think about your bike mechanic skills before you buy. In addition to the basics, do you know how to adjust a derailleur? Re-center your disc brakes? Fix a broken chain? True a warped wheel?

Knowing how to use the tools is just as important as having them, so taking a bike maintenance or repair course could be a great way to learn new skills that may come in handy down the road or trail. There are also great tutorial videos you can find online to figure out how to fix certain things (Park Tool has great how-to videos).

Group shot of bike multi-tools
There are a lot of options when it comes to multi-tools. Thankfully, there’s something out there that will be suited to your specific needs, even if finding it might be a challenge. (photo/Jim Graham)

What Tools Do You Need?

Taking some time to familiarize yourself with your bike(s) and all the parts can give you a good idea of what tools you need to make adjustments out on a ride. It pays to know the specific hex sizes, Torx bits, and screw heads your particular bike requires. For instance, some derailleurs, such as the Shimano GRX, take a small, 2mm hex wrench – not included on some multi-tools – to adjust the limit screws. And, depending on the tools your bike needs, know that many brands make several versions with varying tools included so you should be able to find one that suits your needs.

It may sound obvious, but your multi-tool should suit the adjustments and fixes you’re comfortable making. If you’ll use it only to make occasional, quick, and easy repairs during a ride, then look for these common features:

  • Hex (aka Allen) wrenches in 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 8mm
  • A Phillips and/or flathead screwdriver
  • Torx wrenches that fit your bike (the most common are T10 and T25)
  • A chain tool (assuming you know how to use it)

The above selection of hex, Torx, and screwdrivers should be able to handle most of the simple adjustments and fixes that most well-maintained bikes will require on a ride. There’s a reason that every model in this review has a chain tool, and that is because it is pretty critical in the off chance you break a chain during a ride, but you have to know how to use it for it to be effective. While breaking your chain doesn’t happen that often, it does happen, and even if you carry a quick link (or master link) to rejoin your broken chain, the broken section of the chain almost always needs to be removed to install it. Again, watching an instructional video and/or practicing at home on an old chain can be the difference between making a fix in the field and continuing your ride, walking out of the woods, or calling your significant other for a roadside pickup. Of course, proper drivetrain maintenance and choosing the right chain lube can help prevent it from happening in the first place.

The chain tool on the Silca Italian Army Knife Venti
Broken chains don’t happen that often, but you need a chain tool to fix one. The large handle on the Slica Venti’s chain tool makes it easier to grasp than many of the smaller models. (photo/Jim Graham)

Depending on the duration of your rides or the remoteness of your adventures, additional tools may be helpful to keep you from having an epic bike breakdown many miles down a gravel road with no cell service. Lots of bike multi-tools include other functions than the essentials listed above including things like quick-link storage, valve core tools, spoke wrenches, disc pad spreaders, disc rotor truing tools, knife blades, tubeless repair tools, plugs, and more. To be self-sufficient, it’s important to have the tools you need to keep your bike rolling. One of the most comprehensive tools we tested is the Wolf Tooth 8-Bit Kit Two which would be our pick for extended bikepacking trips where you might not see people for days.

A closer look at the components of the Wolf Tooth 8-bit kit two including the tire plugs
The super comprehensive Wolf Tooth 8-Bit Kit Two includes a pack of bacon strips and a tire plug insertion tool. (photo/Jim Graham)

Tubeless Tire Repair

With the proliferation of tubeless tires across all types of cycling, carrying tubeless repair tools is necessary for many riders. While tubeless plug and plug tools have traditionally been something we carry independently of our multi-tools, many models are now coming with them integrated into their designs for an all-in-one tool and tubeless repair kit. Not every multi-tool comes with tubeless tools or plugs, of course, but many do and some brands offer multiple models that come with or without to suit varying needs and preferences. These features often consist of a tubeless needle/plugger that can be used to push a “bacon strip” into a puncture and storage space for some tubeless plugs.

The Dynaplug feature on the Cannondale 18-in-1 with Dynaplug bike mutli-tool
Dynaplugs work great in our experience, so having them integrated into a tool like the Cannondale 18-in-1 with Dynaplug means there’s one less thing we need to carry. (photo/Jeremy Benson)

The models we tested that include tubeless repair tools are the ToPeak Mini PT30, the Lezyne SV Pro-17, Wolf Tooth 8-Bit Kit Two, and the Cannondale 18-in-1 with Dynaplug. The ToPeak, Lezyne, and Wolf Tooth all have plug insertion tools for “bacon strip” type plugs and the latter two models even come with some. The Cannondale tool comes with a dual-head Dynaplug tool and their easy-to-use pointed metal tip plugs. Plug preferences vary, of course, with some riders swearing by bacon strips and others preferring Dynaplug or other options.

Using the ToPeak Mini PT30 to tighten a bolt
The length of the bits and size of many folding tools can impact their ergonomics and your ability to reach certain bolts with them. (photo/Jeremy Benson)

Ergonomics

Compared to regular workshop tools, most multi-tools sacrifice a bit in ergonomics for the compact form that they need to take to pack many tools into a portable and lightweight unit. This is particularly true of most folding tools that have short, folding bits and rectangular shapes. They typically feel pretty good in your hands and provide adequate torque for simple fixes or adjustments, but the length of the bits and the shape of the tool itself can often mean that accessing hard-to-reach bolts is awkward. Still, they can get the job done most of the time.

The tools inside the Blackburn Switch Wrap Tool Kit
They may be a little slower to deploy, but the tools in the Blackburn Switch Wrap Tool Kit have excellent ergonomics compared to more traditional folding multi-tools. (photo/Jim Graham)

Some tools go out of their way to try and have ergonomics that mimic regular shop tools. The Blackburn Switch Wrap Tool Kit, for example, has a great handle that can extend the removable bits or be used straight on or in a T-shape. Similarly, the ToPeak Ratchet Rocket Lite DX+ not only has ratcheting capability but it can be used in multiple configurations to reach certain bolts. Also, the Wolf Tooth 8-Bit Kit Two has a swiveling head for its removable bits that can be used at various angles. Going a step further, the Blackburn Wayside has individual hex keys for sizes 2, 2.5, 3, 4, and 5mm, that make them super easy to use.

comparing the size of the ToPeak Mini PT30 and the Cannondale 18-in-1 with Dynaplug
Tools like the Topeak Mini PT30 and the Cannondale 18-in-1 with Dynaplug are nice and small to easily fit in your pocket, saddle bag, or pack. (photo/Jeremy Benson)

Portability: How Are You Going to Carry It?

A bike multi-tool only works if you have it with you, so it’s important to consider how you intend to carry it while riding when choosing the right one for your needs. Fortunately, they are typically relatively lightweight and compact, so most will be easy to stash in a jersey or cargo bib pocket, saddle bag, hydration backpack, hip pack, bottle mount tool canister, or in-frame storage compartment. But, some are smaller and lighter than others, making them easier to squeeze into a small saddle bag or be less noticeable in your pocket. Some even have storage cases to keep them tidy and feeling pleasant against your lower back or keep them from snagging on other things in your pack.

A bike multi-tool being carried in a saddle bag
Saddle bags are a common spot to carry a multi-tool on road and gravel bikes. The ToPeak Mini PT30 fits easily into this one along with a tube, tire lever, and 2 CO2 canisters (not pictured). (photo/Jeremy Benson)

The differences in weight among the models we tested aren’t incredibly significant with only about 80 grams separating the lightest, 118 grams, and the heaviest, 195 grams, though it is certainly notable and may make a difference to those who are particularly weight-conscious. Not surprisingly, however, the two lightest models we tested, the Pro Bike Tool 20-in-1 and the Lezyne SV Pro-17, also happen to be a couple of the slimmest and most compact, making them quite easy to fit into small spaces. Also not surprisingly, a few of the heaviest models we tested, like the Blackburn Wayside and the Wolf Tooth 8-Bit Kit Two, are some of the largest. The added weight and size, however, is a tradeoff for extra or specialized tools and better ergonomics and leverage.

The Blackburn Switch Wrap Tool Kit mounted on a mountain bike on a mountaintop
This Blackburn Switch Wrap has been in use for 3+ years and it attaches neatly to the frame holding a spare tube, two CO2 canisters, and a tire lever. It can also be attached to the saddle in place of a saddle bag. (photo/Jeremy Benson)

While there are many ways to store tools on bikes themselves these days, one of the best we’ve found is the Blackburn Switch Wrap Tool Kit. Not only does it include a solid tool selection, but the wrap can hold additional items like a tube, CO2 canisters, tire plugs, and tire levers and be strapped to your frame or saddle. This can help get weight off your body, eliminate the need for a saddle bag, and always ensure that you’ve got your repair kit ready and with you while you ride.

Other Things to Carry

We feel that a good multi-tool is an absolute necessity to bring with you on any type of bike ride whether that’s road, gravel, mountain, or even a daily commute. It’s not the only thing you should bring with you, of course, as a multi-tool can only do so much. What else you should bring with you depends on what type of riding you’re doing, how far you’re going, and may also be specific to the bike you’re riding.

No matter the type of bike, we always recommend bringing a tube (that is the correct size for your tires) or possibly two if you’re prone to flatting, tire levers, and tubeless tire plugs (if you run tubeless). You’ll also want some way to inflate your tires like a mini pump or CO2 canisters and a CO2 inflator. A quick link (that is the right size and brand to match your chain) can speed up chain repair, and zip ties and/or some duct tape can often come in handy too. Of course, it’s always good to bring a first-aid kit for unexpected emergencies, possibly some toilet paper, some cash or a card, and, of course, snacks and water.

A close-up look at the Pro Bike Tool 20-in-1 bike multi-tool and all its functions
The Pro Bike Tool 20-in-1 is super slim and lightweight, and it costs the least of any model we tested. We think it’s a great value. (photo/Jim Graham)

Value

It’s hard to put a price on something as important as a bike multi-tool that can potentially save your rides and from frustration. Still, these things cost money, but when you have the tools to make quick fixes and adjustments on a ride, it’s money well spent. The models we tested range in price from $29 for the Pro Bike Tool 20-in-1 up to a whopping $140 for the Wolf Tooth 8-Bit Kit Two (which is essentially 3 separate tools in one). Special features, tools, and fancier designs certainly add to the price.

Nearly all of the other tools we tested fall in the $40 to $60 range, with the Cannondale 18-in-1 with Dynaplug going for $80. How much you’re willing to spend depends on your budget, of course, but know that even the least expensive option is probably going to have you covered 99% of the time. It’s also important to note that multi-tools typically last for many years when treated with a reasonable amount of care, making even the more expensive options a good value over time. A great example is the Crankbrothers M-series tools that can last for decades.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a bike multi-tool?

Do you own a bike? Then yes, absolutely! We feel that a bike multi-tool is a must-have for any ride. Whether you need to make a comfort adjustment, tighten a loose bolt, adjust a derailleur, fix a broken chain, or any other variety of things, a good multi-tool should be able to get you back rolling instead of doing the walk of shame. If you don’t have a set of tools at home, a good multi-tool could also be super helpful for doing simple maintenance and repairs on your bike around the house. Either way, the answer is yes, we don’t ride without one and you shouldn’t either.

Which bike multi-tool should I buy?

Determining which tools are most important to have with you can help you narrow down the choices to find the right multi-tool. Assessing which hex, Torx, and screwdriver sizes your bike requires is a good first step, along with weighing the usefulness of other features like chain tools, tubeless repair, quick/master link storage, etc. It’s also important to consider how you intend to carry the tool as that may steer you in the direction of smaller and lighter options. The duration of your rides and/or the distance you’re traveling from civilization may also be a factor that sways you towards something more basic for shorter rides or something comprehensive to keep you rolling when you haven’t seen a person or had cell service for several hours.

For rides, your home workshop, or both?

In an ideal world, you’d have a multi-tool for mid-ride adjustments that lives in your saddle bag or riding kit year-round — one that you won’t take out to work on your bike in your home shop and then, inevitably, forget to put back in your saddlebag before your next ride. (We’ve all done it). You’d also have a selection of high-quality shop tools for every need in your bike workshop. But who lives in an ideal world?

Over many years of riding, however, we’ve found that it really does pay to have a separate multi-tool for each bike you own, kept in its own saddle bag or kit. This will save you time trying to find a multi-tool before a ride, and it will also allow you to match each multi-tool to the specific bike. On our road bikes, for instance, we keep a lightweight, compact tool with just the basics. For longer gravel and bikepacking rides, we pack a tool with a wider range of functions, along with tubeless tools and plugs, tire levers, and valve core tools and plugs.

It’s also nice to keep a sturdy, multi-tool in your home shop. They’re great for when you want to make quick adjustments and don’t want to fish around in your shop toolbox. It’s also nice if the multi-tool in your shop includes a bottle opener.

Do you absolutely need a chain tool?

In our experience, broken chains don’t happen all that often, but you’re pretty much out of luck if it does break and you don’t have a tool to fix it (or know how to use that tool). It tends to happen more often in mountain and gravel biking when the chain is frequently under heavy loads and ridden in dirty conditions. But even then, if your chain is maintained, it’s possible to go a few years without breaking a link. Still, there’s pretty much no way to fix a broken chain without a chain tool, even if you’re carrying a quick link. That’s why all of the tools in this review have chain tools; because you’re much better off having one and not needing it than the other way around.

Also, keep in mind that it takes some know-how and experience to fix a broken chain with a chain tool. It is much easier if you have a quick/master link, but even then it takes some know-how to do it right. We’ve seen a few riders on the side of the trail with a broken chain, holding a multi-tool with a chain breaker, and not knowing how to use it. (Be a good fellow cyclist and offer to help these folks.) It’s a skill that can be tricky to master, so it helps to practice on an old chain at home first. Note: If you plan to use a quick/master link, make sure it matches the number of speeds on your bike, usually 10, 11, or 12 speeds, which require links specific to each chain.

What’s the difference between hex keys and Allen wrenches?

Nothing really at all. They are two names for the same thing. The term “Allen” comes from the Allen company that produced tools with hex-shaped heads and those tools became colloquially known as Allen wrenches. These days, the terms are used interchangeably to refer to the keys/wrenches with hexagonal heads and are measured in millimeter sizes. Bolts with hex heads are the most common on all types of bikes, so they are among the most important tools on a multi-tool.

Fixed bits vs. separate bits?

Some tools include an array of separate bits that must be inserted into a handle to use. The advantage is that these generally make it easier to access tight spaces because the handles can be configured to hold the bits at different angles. The individual bits are also easily replaceable and can be found in most hardware stores, so you can carry spare bits or a wider selection of bits. The disadvantage is that the small bits are easy to drop and lose, especially in the dirt and poor lighting conditions – and black-colored ones seem to have a talent for disappearing in leafy duff.

Multi-tools with fixed bits hold all the tools together in one neat package, so selecting the right tool is like opening a blade on a Swiss Army Knife. They’re extremely easy to use, and they are much faster to work with in the middle of a ride than multi-tools with separate bits. The downside is that some models, especially those with short bits, can make it tougher to access tight spaces. 

Which is more important: size, weight, or price?

In our opinion, size, though it depends on your specific needs. A compact multi-tool will leave more room in your saddle bag, fanny pack, or jersey pocket for other things, like a spare tube, tire levers, or an extra snack. The shape is also somewhat important because you want a tool that feels comfortable in your hand or a back pocket, is easy to grip, and provides good leverage.

The difference between the heaviest and lightest multi-tools we reviewed is less than 80 grams (a little over 2 ounces). That’s not enough to sway our buying choice, though the very weight-conscious riders among us may prioritize low weight over all else.

Finally, price. Trust us on this: A good multi-tool will pay for itself the first time it saves you from being stranded, and is a wise investment that will last many years.

How should I take care of a multi-tool?

Multi-tools are pretty simple things and they really don’t require much attention. Given that they are made from metal, however, it’s best to try and keep them relatively dry if possible to prevent the bits from corroding over time. Even tools that have corrosion-resistant coatings can start to corrode if they stay damp enough for long enough. If you know your tool has gotten wet, it is good practice to take it out of your saddle bag or pack to let it dry out, just don’t forget to put it back before your next ride.

Also, some folding multi-tools can get loose over time and the tools can fold out too easily, sometimes flopping around while you try to use them. This can usually be remedied by snugging up the bolt that holds the side plates together (the piece from which the tools pivot).

Lastly, taking a little care while using the tool can help to prevent stripping both the tool heads and the heads of bolts.

Related Content

The post The Best Bike Multi-Tools of 2024 appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
347445
The Best Gifts for Your Trail Dog https://bikerumor.com/the-best-gifts-for-your-trail-dog/ https://bikerumor.com/the-best-gifts-for-your-trail-dog/#comments Tue, 28 Nov 2023 16:47:53 +0000 https://bikerumor.com/?p=345797 Ruffwear makes finding a gift for your pupper effortless, with tons of styles, toys, apparel, and accessories for every manner of dog.

The post The Best Gifts for Your Trail Dog appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
gifts from ruffwear

In between merrymaking, snow, and good cheer, the holidays are indeed the most wonderful time of the year. But adding a friendly trail doggo to the mix makes the holiday season truly special. 

By bringing so much love to our lives, dogs earn their keep. Why wouldn’t you give a gift (or two) to your favorite furry companion to show them how much you care?

This holiday season, hit paws on your human shopping and prioritize your favorite canine. Ruffwear makes finding a gift for your dog effortless. With tons of styles, toys, apparel, and accessories for every manner of dog, they’ve got your holiday shopping covered!

Whether you’ve got a wild adventure beast, or a cozy lap-loving companion, Ruffwear has the perfect gift for your four-legged bestie. 

LEARN MORE ABOUT RUFFWEAR

Give the Gift of Ruffwear

(Photo/Ruffwear)

Flagline Dog Harness with Handle

Sometimes your dog needs a boost. That’s why Ruffwear designed the Flagline Dog Harness with a helpful handle for hoisting your beast up steep inclines and tricky spots. Solid, durable construction and a tough lift-to-assist design means you can give them the support they need without putting the pinch on your furry companion. 

SHOP FLAGLINE HARNESS

(Photo/Ruffwear)

Front Range Day Pack

Unless your pup’s an influencer, they’re probably not getting a job. But that doesn’t mean they can’t carry their own weight from time to time! Let them help carry the load with Ruffwear’s Front Range Day Pack. Multiple attachment options, a form-fitting design and plenty of storage space means that your dog can be more self-sufficient out on the trail.  

SHOP FRONT RANGE DAY PACK

(Photo/Ruffwear)

Vert Dog Jacket

Your dog’s a 4-season beast — so wouldn’t it be nice to give them a little insulation for those cold winter outings? The Vert Dog Jacket combines cozy warmth with plush design and comfort. A waterproof shell resists light precipitation and a hi-loft insulation brings tons of warmth to keep your companion going for miles of snowy adventures. 

SHOP VERT DOG JACKET

(Photo/Ruffwear)

Grip Trex Dog Boots

Despite millennia of evolution and survival of the fittest, your doggo has a soft side. That’s why Ruffwear’s Grip Trex Dog Boots add extra protection to your pup’s paws. With Vibram rubber outsoles, a breathable upper, and a secure hook-and-loop closure, the Grip Trex provides the support and protection they need to keep hammering miles on the trail or pavement. 

SHOP GRIP TREX BOOTS

(Photo/Ruffwear)

Gnawt-a–Rock Treat Dispensing Toy

Working for rewards is half the fun. That’s why the Gnawt-a–Rock Treat Dispensing Toy adds a bit of anticipation and play to your dog’s treat sessions. A durable, chew-proof construction and small kibble/treat dispensing notches extend your dog’s reward cycle and makes them an active participant in the feasts and fun.

SHOP GNAWT-A-ROCK

(Photo/Ruffwear)

Knot-a-Hitch Campsite Dog Tether

It’s easy at the campsite for your pup to get excited. And with so many neighbors to greet, there’s bound to be mischief afoot. The Knot-a-Hitch Campsite Dog Tether lets you stake your spot and give your dog a wide berth — but not so wide as to disturb other campers. It uses climbing-inspired components and hardware that are easy to use and convenient to stow.

SHOP KNOT-A-HITCH

(Photo/Ruffwear)

Highlands Dog Sleeping Bag & Pad

Making your dog sleep on the ground is pretty cold. That’s why Ruffwear designed the Highlands Dog Sleeping Bag & Pad — to give your lovable best friend a warm and cozy setup when you’re on the trail or at camp. The Bag is lightweight and synthetic, so it’ll retain heat even when damp. For an extra layer of warmth, throw the Highlands Sleeping Pad into the mix to keep your furry friend cozy on those cold outdoor adventures.  

SHOP HIGHLANDS SLEEP GEAR

(Photo/Ruffwear)

Float Coat Dog Life Jacket

One of the joys of having a dog is taking them on the river. Ruffwear’s Float Coat Dog Life Jacket provides your pup with extra flotation and reflective strips for visibility in low-light conditions. A lift-and-assist handle makes it easy to help your dog out of the water and strategically placed foam panels help support your pup’s natural swimming position so they can doggy paddle to their heart’s content. 

SHOP FLOAT COAT

This post is sponsored by Ruffwear. To learn more and shop, head to Ruffwear.com.

The post The Best Gifts for Your Trail Dog appeared first on Bikerumor.

]]>
https://bikerumor.com/the-best-gifts-for-your-trail-dog/feed/ 1 345797